News Half Year Manga Sales Ranking 2021 !

#62
I predicted this years ago

Major Problems:

Pace:
Its awful its dragging and slow unnecessary things get more attention then it should be
WCI did took nearly 80 chapters but could be wraped up in 50 chapters
The same with Wano awful long

Side-character focus:
Rebecca, Otama and so on are so dragging and arent liked yet he still insists on them

fight:
Major problem Kingdom, MHA or OPM they scorring in combat scenes there well written and the choreography is top notch
And OP
just teasing , skipping few scenes and you have to wait 40 weeks for it fights are just 10% of an arc a 15-year old doesnt want to see plot armour but want to see the technique of his favorite characters instead skipping
Doflamingo, Fuji vs Law
Doffy vs Law
clash royale in colosseum
Burgess vs Sabo
Fujitora vs Sabo
all skipped but Rebecca gets 4 chapter for her background


next point flashbacks:
Some are really intersting but its too much another dragging point

Yonko:
are the biggest disapointment
they are stupid, clumsy, easy to deceive you cant take them seriously and they dont have the enemy vibe like Croc or Lucci
buffons that can easily be tricked

Crew:
Oda soley focuses on Luffy the crew doesnt play a major role like in the pre-ts-arcs

Robin and Nami fanservice
Sanji punchin bag
Ussop and chopper didnt evolve one bit
and so on
most of them cant even use haki bad


anime:
Its one of the major factors it sucks it just milking awfully animation awful pace
The characters dont even have proper animation its like a cartoon for 6 year old a decacde ago the animation was much better

breaks:
Oda stretches things up the breaks make it even longer

Plot-armour
its so stupid Nami gets Zeus
Otama can take out elite-pirates
Luffy will be saved everytime he fails
Brulee saves Luffy
BM hunger attack
BM take out P1 and Ulti
and so on


All in one Oda is past his zenith he doesnt have the quality how things are solved is stupid
Nami gets Zeus and Sanji gets Suit
just give them haki or adv haki why do you need to give them something from someone else its like cheating

Its a pity but this trending will ruin One Piece
Every series loses fans as time goes on and one piece has fans equivalent to pre-marneford hype.
Assuming sales correlate with guality is wrong so what you typed isn't the reason why OP is losing fans but rather every series loses fans and One Piece has rather done well for keeping around 2 million fans 25 years into the story.
 
#63
Every series loses fans as time goes on and one piece has fans equivalent to pre-marneford hype.
Assuming sales correlate with guality is wrong so what you typed isn't the reason why OP is losing fans but rather every series loses fans and One Piece has rather done well for keeping around 2 million fans 25 years into the story.
by now OP should have increase a child born 2008 is now 13 years old so if you cant increase your fanbase it means you have hardcore fans but not new fans
 
#64
The news are clearly showing that there are mangas increasingly surpassing One Piece in quality and
Imagine talking about quality in a ranking where KNY is at the top.
The fact is there are more manga readers today than ever before in history so new gen anime with hype like JJK and KNY have the highest fans ever which surpasses Dragon ball, slam dunk and One piece's peaks.
 
#65
Imagine talking about quality in a ranking where KNY is at the top.
The fact is there are more manga readers today than ever before in history so new gen anime with hype like JJK and KNY have the highest fans ever which surpasses Dragon ball, slam dunk and One piece's peaks.
DB is a worldwide phenomen.

The new gen Mangas will never reach that
 
#66
by now OP should have increase a child born 2008 is now 13 years old so if you cant increase your fanbase it means you have hardcore fans but not new fans
Yes, One piece has old fans not new fans. 13 year olds in Japan today would rather read JJK, KNY and other short manga with hype rather than One piece which has almost a 100 volumes and has less hype
Post automatically merged:

DB is a worldwide phenomen.

The new gen Mangas will never reach that
We are comparing sales here, and KNY at it's peak is selling more than dragon ball. So bashing one piece for it is silly since even a monster like dragon ball is getting out sold
Post automatically merged:

DB is a worldwide phenomen.

The new gen Mangas will never reach that
We are comparing sales here, and KNY at it's peak is selling more than dragon ball. So bashing one piece for it is silly since even a monster like dragon ball is getting out sold
 
#68
Imagine talking about quality in a ranking where KNY is at the top.
The fact is there are more manga readers today than ever before in history so new gen anime with hype like JJK and KNY have the highest fans ever which surpasses Dragon ball, slam dunk and One piece's peaks.
In manga sales yes, In terms of actual fanbases then no
 
#69
what you consider average is a downfall since a couple of years

Most people have here constructive criticism because its true who needs Otama who needs Rebecca backstory its dragging nothing more even a stone has a sad background story in OP

nobody really dies

In two years the sales will fall further

Here did a piece on the op numbers :

https://worstgen.alwaysdata.net/forum/threads/one-pieces-decline-in-sales.14826/

OP has been constantly declining since MF , you can criticize so much stuff but I feel like its inevitable for story this long to taper down ... Wano volumes as you can see has been going under the 2M

But what I'm mostly talking about is people overreaction of OP falling out of the top which's clearly due to less volumes and not sudden drop in quality
 
#70
You know that quality isn't what determines sales but rather hype. Enies lobby was a good arc and had less sales than fishman island island.
Enies Lobby was the beginning of OP peak. Fishmen Island was the peak and downfall. OP selling less and less after that and having even more hype is the proof anyone needs to know how bad the series is current day. We had G4 hype, BM Arc hype with Snakeman Hype and finally Wano Arc hype that we've waiting since Punk Hazard.
Post automatically merged:

Imagine talking about quality in a ranking where KNY is at the top.
The fact is there are more manga readers today than ever before in history so new gen anime with hype like JJK and KNY have the highest fans ever which surpasses Dragon ball, slam dunk and One piece's peaks.
What is the problem of KNY? We can talk about sales per volume, OP is shitty in those.
 
Last edited:
#71
Enies Lobby was the beginning of OP peak. Fishmen Island was the peak and downfall. OP selling less and less after that and having even more hype is the proof anyone needs to know how bad the series is current day. We had G4 hype, BM Arc hype with Snakeman Hype and finally Wano Arc hype that we've waiting since Punk Hazard.
Wano is the only hype part you can talk about. And again it is natural for sales to fall for any series and One piece is doing good 25 years into publication. No other manga has ran that long still having 2million+ fans. And even the KNY with hype right now would have also fallen if it continued
 
#72
Yes, One piece has old fans not new fans. 13 year olds in Japan today would rather read JJK, KNY and other short manga with hype rather than One piece which has almost a 100 volumes and has less hype
Post automatically merged:


We are comparing sales here, and KNY at it's peak is selling more than dragon ball. So bashing one piece for it is silly since even a monster like dragon ball is getting out sold
Post automatically merged:


We are comparing sales here, and KNY at it's peak is selling more than dragon ball. So bashing one piece for it is silly since even a monster like dragon ball is getting out sold
Sales is not quality and you know Post-TS is shit
 
#73
Yes, One piece has old fans not new fans. 13 year olds in Japan today would rather read JJK, KNY and other short manga with hype rather than One piece which has almost a 100 volumes and has less hype
Its not the length but quality MHA, OPM battlewise is better than OP they dont tease they do actually one o one
look at OP in the past 114 chapters no real battle and this is shounen just tease thats all most readers got sick of it
15 year old boys dont only want battle but they want action and Oda isnt delivering

Here did a piece on the op numbers :

https://worstgen.alwaysdata.net/forum/threads/one-pieces-decline-in-sales.14826/

OP has been constantly declining since MF , you can criticize so much stuff but I feel like its inevitable for story this long to taper down ... Wano volumes as you can see has been going under the 2M

But what I'm mostly talking about is people overreaction of OP falling out of the top which's clearly due to less volumes and not sudden drop in quality
its not less volume look at your numbers the drop is nearly 40% depends on which year you take I took 2015 Dressrosa
 
#75
Wano is the only hype part you can talk about. And again it is natural for sales to fall for any series and One piece is doing good 25 years into publication. No other manga has ran that long still having 2million+ fans. And even the KNY with hype right now would have also fallen if it continued
KNY reach a mark OP will never reach, 80+mi sales in a year. And still now I bet will sell more than OP peak. Yet you keep here saying all those bullshit even with all evidences that OP is falling where it suppose to be the best moment. Chapter 1000 and many more...
 
#76
YES !!!! FINALLY !!! FUCK YOU ODA !!!!

You get what you deserve! Last 20 chapters was absolute garbage! Like even WCI arc was much much better(before it come to Katakuri fight), people don't want to buy shit and read shit, eat it yourself. Millions started to drop this shit, and now even oldest funs going to threw this shit into garbage can. Case you did by yourself, killed own manga, work of your life.

Turned best potential BEST arc into Dog Shit! There was no way to ruin it, but he did ..idk maybe real Oda died long ago, but this is not manga and author that I love and want to read.


Hope next year you will get 20-th place.
 
#77
KNY reach a mark OP will never reach, 80+mi sales in a year. And still now I bet will sell more than OP peak. Yet you keep here saying all those bullshit even with all evidences that OP is falling where it suppose to be the best moment. Chapter 1000 and many more...
OP is falling which is natural for a series 25+ years in publication.
KNY selling 80mil isn't a reason to mock OP, because KNY has outsold every single manga in history even legendary ones like dragon ball and slam dunk.
Post automatically merged:

YES !!!! FINALLY !!! FUCK YOU ODA !!!!

You get what you deserve! Last 20 chapters was absolute garbage! Like even WCI arc was much much better(before it come to Katakuri fight), people don't want to buy shit and read shit, eat it yourself. Millions started to drop this shit, and now even oldest funs going to threw this shit into garbage can. Case you did by yourself, killed own manga, work of your life.

Turned best potential BEST arc into Dog Shit! There was no way to ruin it, but he did ..idk maybe real Oda died long ago, but this is not manga and author that I love and want to read.


Hope next year you will get 20-th place.
One question
Do you think sales correlate with quality?
Do you think KNY and JJK are quality series more than the likes of Kingdom?
 
#78
OP is falling which is natural for a series 25+ years in publication.
KNY selling 80mil isn't a reason to mock OP, because KNY has outsold every single manga in history even legendary ones like dragon ball and slam dunk.
Post automatically merged:


One question
Do you think sales correlate with quality?
Do you think KNY and JJK are quality series more than the likes of Kingdom?
Is not natural for OP to drop quality. You took one argument about OP but it doesn't fit to KNY?

KNY is 205 chapters. OP started to be good at sales at Enies Lobby around 300 chapters. Peak of Marineford 500 chapters until Fishmen Island 650 chapters. Then the downfall came.

You said "KNY would have sold less even if the series keep going" but that wasn't true for OP. So you have no argument in here.

OP fans always grabbed about the sales and now out of sudden they doesn't matter anymore.

Sales is not equal quality, but what is OP quality since sales were always number 1 argument?

Either way, sales means audicence is liking or not the manga. In all meaninings people are dislike current OP.
 
#80
Is not natural for OP to drop quality
I didn't talk about drop in quality, I talked about drop in sales. And you have to be delusional if you thought OP would be selling 38mil+ every year like marineford till it ends. That isn't possible since people who have read it won't buy the volume again for no reason
Post automatically merged:

You said "KNY would have sold less even if the series keep going" but that wasn't true for OP.
This is true for One piece,KNY and One piece all had their peak and from the peak the series will decline it sales till it ends. One piece's peak was 2011 and it has declined to pre-marineford hype sales in 2021. That is what is expected.
Post automatically merged:

Sales is not equal quality, but what is OP quality since sales were always number 1 argument
One of the best world building, amazing lore and amazing back stories.
Post automatically merged:

Is not natural for OP to drop quality. You took one argument about OP but it doesn't fit to KNY?

KNY is 205 chapters. OP started to be good at sales at Enies Lobby around 300 chapters. Peak of Marineford 500 chapters until Fishmen Island 650 chapters. Then the downfall came.

You said "KNY would have sold less even if the series keep going" but that wasn't true for OP. So you have no argument in here.

OP fans always grabbed about the sales and now out of sudden they doesn't matter anymore.

Sales is not equal quality, but what is OP quality since sales were always number 1 argument?

Either way, sales means audicence is liking or not the manga. In all meaninings people are dislike current OP.
Enies lobby, marineford all got the same if not higher hate than Wano right now. I'm sure the old readers will remember.
Post automatically merged:

In the end of the year Op Will be top 3 at least.

And the haters can ALL Cry.
I expect the final to be JJK,KNY,CSM,AOT and one piece in 5th place. It can also switch with AOT
 
Last edited:
Top