Chapter Discussion Oda not making sense by having Who's who going to jail.

[MagmaDog]

So let me get this straight. Who's who gets 12 years in jail for losing a devil fruit but Rob Lucci gets promoted to to Cp0 and doesn't go to jail for losing Nico Robin who's importance is IMMENSE? How does this make sense Oda.

 

[bennbeckman]

That was fine, just the unnecessary add by connecting it to Gomu Gomu no. Just my food for thought

 

[Roo]

Because the Gomu Gomu no mi is the pirate holy grail

 

[Warchief Sanji D Goat]

for losing a devil fruit

It's not just a MERE devil fruit.

 

[Tigapedang]

Dont forget cp9 losing so many bounty at that time
Luffy
Zoro and robin

Also pluton blueprint and cutty flam

But maybe 1 devil fruit is more valuable than those,
5 billion belly for 1 fruit perhaps?

 

[MagmaDog]

It's not just a MERE devil fruit.

The point is that both of them should have been punished if this was the standard.

 

[thodoris5321]

If Who's who didn't lose the gomu gomu no mi, then Rob Lucci would never lose to Luffy. So that's a bargain on Who's who too!
JK
I think it's the fact that who's who made a mistake (probably had his mind elsewhere and they stole the fruit) instead of Lucci who stayed and fought.

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

Who’s Who lost a devil fruit to infamous pirate Shanks. Luffy was a relative no one at the time and seemingly much more valuable.

 

[Kurodiamondo]

Spoiler

 

[Seth]

So let me get this straight. Who's who gets 12 years in jail for losing a devil fruit but Rob Lucci gets promoted to to Cp0 and doesn't go to jail for losing Nico Robin who's importance is IMMENSE? How does this make sense Oda.

Simple.

He doesn't.

He just doesn't care.

 

[TheKnightOfTheSea]

WsW totally fucked someone's wife. It's the only reasonable explanation.

 

[Roo]

Who’s Who lost a devil fruit to infamous pirate Shanks. Luffy was a relative no one at the time and seemingly much more valuable.

Um Luffy was not a no one. He had already beaten Croc and had amassed a 100 million bounty. That was literally the threshold to get the supernova title and they were known by the marines

 

[Dr_Professor83]

WsW totally fucked someone's wife. It's the only reasonable explanation.

This. Losing the DF was just a convenient excuse to send him away.

 

[Monkey D. Luffy]

Spandam wanted them captured after failing in Enies Lobby Arc. The difference between Lucci and Who's-Who is the former used coercion on Spandam and Spandine.

 

[RYNO]

Oh yes let's just shit on oda before knowing all the Info, also lucci had more experience with the world Government his been been them for 15+ years before enies lobby and they may have come to agreement between eachother for many particular reason.

 

[Sir Yasheen]

Lucci and all of CP9 were going to be imprisoned for failure too. We don’t know what happened to keep them out of it, but Luccis also just a much more valuable asset than whos who.

 

[Roronoa-sama]

joyboy haki>>>robin

 

[KiriNigiri]

I imagine it's because Lucci was still their best agent. Even if he failed, no other CP9 agent would've done better anyway, whereas Who's Who failed his mission in a time he and Lucci were still relatively green and unproven.

 

[Herrera95]

Not only that. What about Sengoku responsible for Ope Ope no Mi and still being Fleet Admiral?

And fanboys want to think Luffy's DF is not special and he is not the chosen one hahahaha

 

[Finalbeta]

So let me get this straight. Who's who gets 12 years in jail for losing a devil fruit but Rob Lucci gets promoted to to Cp0 and doesn't go to jail for losing Nico Robin who's importance is IMMENSE? How does this make sense Oda.

It sounds like either Oda messed up Big time or Gomu is that intense. And if it's the latter it might possess the power to overthrow Im sama.