Character Discussion Smoker is far more similar to Garp than Coby will ever be, the bias against Smoker is what makes people deny these similarities

#45
He was tired,injured,without his weapon and that fight was offpaneled so no one knows if he got oneshotted or not
Tired from what? They just ate the recipe Judge's son made for them to recover from their fight. Law was also injured and tired the second time he faced Doffy and he did a lot better.
Smoker was indeed one shoted and if not it was still a low diff. Doffy wasn't even serious.

The gap between Luffy and Smoker if Oda cared about power level should be tremendous right now. G2/3 should be able to low or mid diff.
 
C

critical mindset

#46
Tired from what? They just ate the recipe Judge's son made for them to recover from their fight. Law was also injured and tired the second time he faced Doffy and he did a lot better.
Smoker was indeed one shoted and if not it was still a low diff. Doffy wasn't even serious.

The gap between Luffy and Smoker if Oda cared about power level should be tremendous right now. G2/3 should be able to low or mid diff.
Smoker was leages above Law physically. Learn to read One Piece
 
#47
Smoker was leages above Law physically. Learn to read One Piece
Where did I say he wasn't? Physically he may be stronger but law's ability and overall skills were better than Smoker. Law is also more durable.
He defeated smoker in case you forgot. As for you, you don't need to learn to read One Piece, but you should read the parts where Vergo wasn't in it. There is more than a couple of chapters my friend:myman:
 
#48
The Coby = Garp 2.0 are Smoker haters or they Smoke weed on indecent quantity.
If there is a Garp 2.0, that would be Smoker, ofc, no debatable.

The thing here is that there is no need of a Garp 2.0 and this only happened from end of East Blue Arc till end of Alabasta. The other situations where Smoker appeared aren't something like a Garp 2.0
I don't see Smoker doing something greater against Luffy for the rest of the manga, where, in what moment, etc? Luffy would win against Kaido now with Kidd and Law and the next arcs would be him defeating Admiral/Yonko alone already. Smoker has almost no development and he was relegated to Zoro/Sanji's tier since PH.
 

Seth

𝐊𝐨𝐤𝐮𝐭𝐨 𝐒𝐡𝐮𝐬𝐮𝐢
#50
Deluded Smoker hater.
He had the bad luck to appear in an arc where Oda's entire focus was to make Law shine as much as possible. No SN other than Luffy/Zoro has even gotten half of the focus that Law received during PH
Must hurt to know that on screen feats prove that Doffy mopped the floor with him 0 effort.
 
C

critical mindset

#54
Law is also more durable.
Smoker was defeated off-screen so you don't know the effort or intensity Doffy put into attack, only we can say for certain that he was actively chitchatting with Law while fighting talking about the heartseat and whatnot, whereas he was on the warpath against Smoker. As such intensity and effort was much higher against Smoker.

Smoker >>> Law physically means his durability will be scaled accordingly unless other factors are at play. Would agree Law has good durability, in fact surprisingly considering what Vergo did to Sanji.
 
Top