Who will be the next Strawhat


  • Total voters
    895
Status
Not open for further replies.
Fighting with the crew? Momo, Scabbards, Coliseum fighters etc...once again, why is Carrot so different than rest? Once again, Carrot has done the opposite of what every other SH has done...

But Carrot is a good candidate simply because she traveled and fought with them like many others? What story reasons of you have any?



Never said you did....I was clearly talking how so many say people don't want Carrot to join because they hate her..
She bond and have a role on the ship and she was with them in jimbei reunion and she want to have adventure. She share the pain of losing someone with them. That way more than yamato has ever done.
 
I want to emphasize: clearly Carrot says “just take me with you” to Pedro, not to the Straw Hats. Carrot tagged along because Pedro went with the Straw Hats. It’s the same case if Pedro goes with Law, or Kid; she will still tag along. Yamato clearly says she wants to set sail with Luffy, not Law, or Kid. Even Pedro himself thought that Carrot “a bother to our saviors”. Which part of that panel Carrot fans don’t understand?:smart:
 
Last edited:

Uncle Van

Taxes Are a Sickness
She bond and have a role on the ship and she was with them in jimbei reunion and she want to have adventure. She share the pain of losing someone with them. That way more than yamato has ever done.
Wanda was in the Jinbe reunion panel as well to the right....and Carrot and Wanda fought against Pero to avenge Pedro...does Wanda have SH potential now? Nami really likes her too

Carrot still doesn't have any special bond with Luffy unlike the other SHs....Yamato does.
 
She bond and have a role on the ship and she was with them in jimbei reunion and she want to have adventure. She share the pain of losing someone with them. That way more than yamato has ever done.
what role does Carrot have precisely? So far I haven’t seen Oda specifically stated about Carrot’s proficiency nor role in anything whether it’s in SBS or Vivre Card book. Real role, not theorized role.
 
Some people talk about Luffy like he is gonna reject Yamato or something like that xD, what manga are you reading ?.

By the way, Carrot probably has a deep connection with Luffy (in your minds) but all the role that she has in Wano is avenge Pedro, and she doesnt give a fuck about the mugiwaras plans. Why she dont help in anything related to Momo or tobbi roppo ? she leaves in the start of the climax of the main battle whitout saying anything, Yamato directly obbeys Luffy and she cares more about him that the vengueful Rabbit. So in the end if the headcanon of anti-Yamato fans happens, Luffy is gonna being the mayor idiot and insensitive main character of the Shonen Jump, cuz Yamato its fighting and give all for him, meanwhile Carrot its eating grass for his failling intent of anger
 
Wanda was in the Jinbe reunion panel as well to the right....and Carrot and Wanda fought against Pero to avenge Pedro...does Wanda have SH potential now? Nami really likes her too

Carrot still doesn't have any special bond with Luffy unlike the other SHs....Yamato does.
Just ignore the othter arguments. Wanda was in the shot so what she does not know jimbei carrot already care about him. Yamato bond not that strong. Luffy barely shown interest about her knowing ace. She not different than xdrake for him.
 

Uncle Van

Taxes Are a Sickness
Just ignore the othter arguments. Wanda was in the shot so what she does not know jimbei carrot already care about him. Yamato bond not that strong. Luffy barely shown interest about her knowing ace. She not different than xdrake for him.
Many characters shared pain with the SHs so why is Carrot special?

Many characters fought with the SHs so why is Carrot special?

Many characters traveled with the SHs so why is Carrot special?

All the SHs has had said pasts but Carrot was happy so why is Carrot special?

All of the SHs had a special bond moment with Luffy but not Carrot so why is Carrot special?

All of the SHs had one of the biggest roles in their arcs while Carrot has been a side character so why is Carrot special?

All of the SHs has narrative and thematics reasons to travel but Carrot has none so why is Carrot special?

Luffy has shown more interest in Yamato than Carrot and even trusted Yamato in protecting Momo so why is Carrot special?

You're just saying Carrot is special just because....
 
She bond and have a role on the ship and she was with them in jimbei reunion and she want to have adventure. She share the pain of losing someone with them. That way more than yamato has ever done.
So, what? There are characters who have had history with straw hats like johnny, yosaku, VIvi, Caesar, and Coby but they are never official join the crew. Plus, the fact is Carrot lacks a story centric arc that makes her certain piece of the arc like other straw hats before her. In other words, she doesn’t feel like the main character of the arc such as.

Zoro-Captain Morgan arc

Nami-Arlong park

Ussop-captain kuro

Sanji-Baraite and whole cake island
Chopper- Drum Island

Robin and Franky-Water 7 and enies lobby

Brook-Thriller Bark

Jimbei-Fishman Island

Yamato-act 3 of wano

We understand that she has experienced tragedy before, however, we do not know in debt history between her and Pedro. In wano so far, she has legitimately been pushed to the background and has become more of support character just going along for ride. Carrot is lacking screen time to flesh her backstory out to tell us more about her as character. With Cat viper dealing with the person responsible for pedro “supposed death” it undermines her motivation drive to join the straw hats in the first place. Most of time Luffy or one of the straw hats basically deals with enemy that has cause them trouble in the past or even the present.



Luffy-punch helmeppo for Zoro

Luffy-defeated arlong for Nami

Luffy- defeats captain kuro- for ussop

Luffy-defeats Don kreig get sanji

Luffy-defeat wapo get chopper

Challenges the world government gets both Robin and Franky to join his cause

Zoro-get Brook shadow back and Luffy defeats moria

Luffy defeats hordy jones-get jimbei join his cause

Luffy defeat Kaido mostly likely Yamato joins him too

Carrot sure has suslong that last for less 3 minutes.

Role on the ship?

Dude ussop took over her role of being look out when they were entering onigashima by taking guards who were drunk One Piece Usopp puts Beast pirates guards to sleep at Onigashima - YouTube.
Yamato-is devil fruit is shown be better version than Carrot suslong transformation in terms of lasting a lot longer than Carrot transform does.

The straw hat didn’t even mention her when they were recruiting jimbei to join the crew or she wasn't alongside with them when that moment happened.
A Toast for Jimbei, Attack on Onigashima Charge! | One Piece - YouTube

We have seen weekly shouen jump magazine of Luffy alongside with Yamato and we have also seen Luffy with Yamato alongside the nine scabbards in volume 98. As well promotion material in volume 99 Yamato alongside straw hats and there alliance against Big mom, the rest flying six and against Kaido . 【99巻発売記念 ARムービー】最強生物カイドウが新宿に出現!99巻のバトルを、リアルスケールで体感せよ。 - YouTube

In volume 100 we have seen Yamato alongside other straw hats such as Ace, Luffy, Zoro, and Sanji.
YonkouProductions on Twitter: "The official cover for One Piece volume 100 looks really good. Personally I like how it isn't as busy as Oda covers tend to be. https://t.co/0QYViz7rdf" / Twitter
 
Last edited:
Carrot still doesn't have any special bond with Luffy unlike the other SHs....Yamato does.
what is this bond people keep talking about? luffy just talked with yamato for five minutes he has no bond with her he just knows who she is.
even in the little time they were talking luffy seemed annoyed by her most of the time what is ironic because he seems annoyed by carrot a in most of their scenes too
 
Yamato gets White. Brook goes from having Black and White to just Black.

Easy, if Franky can go from father to the crew to pervy old granny cause Jinbei joined, a change like that can happen as well.

Or Robin’s purple gets split into indigo and violet or wisteria or something, and Yamato gets that for her purple rope thing that Oden also had.

Or she gets turquoise/cyan for her hair.

She’s got a good few options for a colour
Vivi's color is already white
 

Uncle Van

Taxes Are a Sickness
How? What worse than yamato vs carrot? Especially if one joined
Punk Hazard- Monet, Momo and Kinemon
DR- Viola, Rebecca, Kyros, Barto, Cavendish
Zou- Carrot
WCI- Pudding
Wano- Tama and Yamato

Monet vs everyone was heated and Viola4Nakama were pretty annoying

Pudding vs Carrot was the big one before Yamato vs Carrot
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top