Which One is the Most Heart Melting Confession?

  • Flower's Tragic Love Confession

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Charlie's Work Affair Confession

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Xeno's Court Confession Case

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    20
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.
The Second Quintuplet

Mashiro Blue

𝓦𝓲𝓼𝓱 𝓾𝓹𝓸𝓷 𝓪 𝓼𝓱𝓸𝓸𝓽𝓲𝓷𝓰 𝓼𝓽𝓪𝓻 ✰
Last edited:
I

Indigo

We need to get a wagon going and get a claim

we need more information

we have like 8 hours left this phase

the focus on the Murder Mystery is killing any normal Mafia play
 
I'm pretty certain we do lol. But waiting on full clarity. Would be WAY too easy if we just have to get 1 of X. They're meant to be very difficult per the hosts (who are thoroughly enjoying seeing me rip my hair out.)

I'm actually starting to come to the conclusion I'm probably gonna be stuck playing for town this game. God help me. I'm losing faith in my meal ticket by the hour.


Cal, et tu brute?
Non

Ce n'est pas personnel

Seule entreprise
 

Mashiro Blue

𝓦𝓲𝓼𝓱 𝓾𝓹𝓸𝓷 𝓪 𝓼𝓱𝓸𝓸𝓽𝓲𝓷𝓰 𝓼𝓽𝓪𝓻 ✰
The Second Quintuplet



Miku Nakano has activated The Second Quintuplet on ???

[Delusion] was used on [???]

Edited to add an ability
 
i have lots of catching up it seems

so basically, no culprit has ever really died

people who died for sure are:
- kanon*
- najno
- everyone checked by najno, assuming he was telling the truth - genji, natsuhi, krauss, shannon, gohda, kumasawa
- jessica

one of these people killed at some point, either T1 or T2 or both - Eva, Hideyoshi, Rudolph, Kyrie, Rosa - either Kyrie or Rosa, if it's Rosa, Maria killed someone

so culprits are among Kyrie, Rosa, George, Battler and Maria.

what i thought could've happened is

T1 - Rosa kills everyone else, Maria covers for Rosa
T2 - Rosa kills Natsuhi AND Krauss, hides in their room and gets locked, they didn't search for killer in the room

T4 - Maria kills Shannon - she can't kill anyone else tbh and she has to kill someone

now there's a problem

who's the third killer? who's 2nd suvivor?

maaaaaybe, doctor kills kumosawa, faking Gohda's death

then Gohda kills doctor and Jesicca

this still leaves us with 4 people and i assume it's nowhere close to truth
 
you can drop the vote on Prof for now, i vouch for his indie claim

we need a new wagon
All indies need to go

I have taken the role of indie hunter in the absence of the acclaimed brother Zolo

We will start from here

Fish rots from the head, as long as we aren't chopping the tail we still have room to breathe
 
i have lots of catching up it seems







so basically, no culprit has ever really died







people who died for sure are:



- kanon*



- najno



- everyone checked by najno, assuming he was telling the truth - genji, natsuhi, krauss, shannon, gohda, kumasawa



- jessica







one of these people killed at some point, either T1 or T2 or both - Eva, Hideyoshi, Rudolph, Kyrie, Rosa - either Kyrie or Rosa, if it's Rosa, Maria killed someone







so culprits are among Kyrie, Rosa, George, Battler and Maria.







what i thought could've happened is







T1 - Rosa kills everyone else, Maria covers for Rosa



T2 - Rosa kills Natsuhi AND Krauss, hides in their room and gets locked, they didn't search for killer in the room







T4 - Maria kills Shannon - she can't kill anyone else tbh and she has to kill someone







now there's a problem







who's the third killer? who's 2nd suvivor?







maaaaaybe, doctor kills kumosawa, faking Gohda's death







then Gohda kills doctor and Jesicca







this still leaves us with 4 people and i assume it's nowhere close to truth


Jessica died for sure at the end so she can't be a culprit, so she couldn't have lied about Godha being dead in T5/6
 
Jessica died for sure at the end so she can't be a culprit, so she couldn't have lied about Godha being dead in T5/6
i mean, i'm mostly thinking about doctor

but he died too

if we assume doctor couldn't ever lie, there's like nobody who could've killed jessica

unless it's time to write down beatrice
 

Reborn

Throughout Heaven & Earth,I alone am d Honored One
Jessica died for sure at the end so she can't be a culprit, so she couldn't have lied about Godha being dead in T5/6
i mean, i'm mostly thinking about doctor

but he died too

if we assume doctor couldn't ever lie, there's like nobody who could've killed jessica

unless it's time to write down beatrice
Read Jessica statements.


She isn't culprit so we can rule out many people based on her talks
 
Good Morning, everyone!

hime's thoughts as of page 43

1. Pot Goblin
only two posts of his that amount to anything

prof is the only person he really interacted with and he seems to believe his claim

2. Psylocke
dont know if its serious, believes prof's claim

first real post of substance

i liked @Kiku's take on this
doubt scum would go for an indie over town unless they were desperate
it's the start of the game, it feels too early them to resort to that

well if she was really that curious, id expect her to try and engage with him more rather than soft defend him right off the bat
(e.g. ask him what he thinks of the wagon on him or whatever)

idk y she cares if ppl vote him or not in this case
she clearly is familiar with his playstyle and knows that his slot is going to be unreadable

reeks of TMI
either feels like she knows hes going to flip town and is soft-pushing the idea that scum targets him or is trying to offer defense of her scum mate by appealing to our emotions

leaning more towards the first, either way it ain't a good look

3. T-Pein™
not much to go off on
first person to sus xenos and small engagement with prof on his reads

firmly in null category for now.

4. Ultra
first one to vote AM after me

advocated for AM wagon

asks Al y he doesnt want to vote for AM

agree

despite being one of the top 3 posters, theres not much mafia related content except for on AM
normally, i would find it weird but no one's really playing mafia at this point so hes fine

minus some of his takes on solving the mystery, i largely find myself in agreement with him
town read

5. Alwaysmind
actually i feel like ive already discussed this guy enough so u can ISO me if necessary and look at the convo between me, ultra, and psylocke

6. Dr_Professor83
indie claim

2 wincons
i dont really know what happened last time but ig u betrayed town even though u were on their side? weird

i dont understand ur role tbh
how will u become an annoyance to scum if u fail ur cases? as far as i understand, u basically become a survivor that can only win if town does
town is more threatening than u to scum...

agree with bolded, but i need to double check once i ISO him

i didnt notice this, but fair points, i'll check it out

i believe ur indie claim for now

disagree

7. Apollo
actually theres nothing at all to really ISO here
the dude asked for a date, complimented the hosts, and worked on the mystery
literally nothing related to talking to other players or game-solving despite having 35 posts
scum lean

8. kavotino
0 posts

9. Peroroncino
acting like u care, feels hella fake considering he hasn't attempted to do a single thing this game except look for a date and fluff post

10. Flower
is this an ability? lol

believes prof's indie claim for now, fair

11. Fujishiro
weird, another indie perhaps?
null read for now

12. Charlie
ok he believes prof is probs scum

ok a neutral indie has no reason to claim that they r pro-town so charlie says he believes prof is scum/hostile indie for sure

lame vote, u could easily push for a prof lynch
there was over 24 hrs left in the phase

anyway, charlie's posts r very largely focused on either the mystery or clarifying ppl's questions abt the game
comes off as fake contribution
going with slight scum lean

13. Gambit
nothing to really ISO
fluff and asked for a date

14. Kiku
fair

agree

i'll go with slight town lean considering i like ur posts
theres just not enough content from them to really say much more tho

15. AL sama
al comes and soft susses flower

starts engaging with prof more and wants him to claim
interesting

susses prof

susses prof

hard susses prof

susses prof

susses prof

alright, so he wants to keep AM around for now

ok... he is aware that AM isnt going to offer anything...

ok... and he knows AM will be unreadable as well...

lol wtf, youve been sussing prof for a while and then nothing? what was the point of ur exchange with prof, u sounded so confident that he was anti-town but now u cant even say hes a possibility for a DP1 lynch?

writing this off as fake contribution or some sort of distancing tactic between u and prof

16. Juliet
nothing to really ISO either here
fluff, date stuff, replied to AL sama about how flavor claiming was bad in recent mafia games

17. Ripped Cal
i have no clue what he's doing or if hes even serious
asked for a date, fluffed, and voted prof
idk how much of the thread hes actually even read

18. Indigo
susses prof

ok, engagement with prof

meh, dont like that he just left after this and didnt wait for ur reply or reply to ur reply later on
comes off like he is more interested in making sure everyone knows that he contributed rather than truly game-solving

20. DoflaMihawk
asks y im voting AM

agrees that AM looks scummy

waits for wagon to pick up and votes AM nearly 24 hrs later ._.

21. xenos5
interesting entrance, feels a bit forced but ive never played with him so perhaps this is in alignment with his playstyle?

fair

idk what to say abt this slot, he came on strong abt how he is observe interactions and everything but i see none of that so far

22. Pew
nothing much to really ISO
seems like a clueless newbie
null read

23. Yo Tan Wa
0 posts

24. Reborn
nothing much to ISO
only seems interested in the murder mystery

25. DarkestKnightofSpoilers
nothing much to really ISO
seems like a clueless newbie
null read

TL;DR, hime's reads as of page 43

Town AF:
  • hime
Town lean:
  • Ultra
Slight Town lean:
  • Flower
  • Kiku
Null:
  • Pot Goblin
  • T-Pein™
  • Fujishiro
  • Gambit
  • Juliet
  • Ripped Cal
  • xenos5
  • Pew
  • DarkestKnightofSpoilers
Slight Scum lean:
  • Charlie
  • Indigo
  • Reborn
Scum lean:
  • Psylocke
  • Alwaysmind
  • Apollo
  • Peroroncino
  • AL sama
  • DoflaMihawk
Inactive AF:
  • kavotino
  • Yo Tan Wa
Indie lean:
  • Dr_Professor83

Closing statements

i'm not really a fan of my reads list atm
too many ppl r null due to a lack of interest in the actual mafia part of the game but i cant really control that
anyway the ppl i find scummy rn r listed
do what u want with my list, ask questions, bounce off discussions, make a case for or against someone, etc.
pls dont ignore it, its not the best but i spent time putting it together to use as a starting point for ppl at least ;-;
Great effort on this read list! A bit shocked to see you scumread DoflaMihawk, but I guess that goes to show you won’t go easy on anyone.

And yeah, I’ll admit I did get caught up in the flow of just enjoying conversations in this game and strayed from my original goal.

I have a google doc with everyone’s usernames where I can list my reads and the connections between different players, and I’m gonna have to start getting to work on that. And I will be sure to share results and highlight if I find anything noteworthy. I’ve got a 12-5 day unfortunately, but I’ll still be around to see how this day phase ends (since it’ll end around 6 something, I believe? and look back over everything so far so I can work on it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top