General & Others When does a weapon become a sword and a man a swordsman?

[shastar-sei]

Law and Monet, the swordsmen qualification experts

 

[gz89]

 

[Rootbeer]

@Albino 👑 Yo.. I couldn't sleep i was thinking about One Piece, and this has suddenly become so Obviously clear to me now, thank you for your thread.. You were actually right..

Knowing a Sword Skill doesn't make you a Swordsman..
Having a Sword Style makes you a Swordsman..

So Mihawk must have a specific Sword Style name..

Everything is so Gucci in my head now.. Rocks is not a Swordsman..

 

[kom5]

its easy to answer its time prob

 

[Nidai_Kitetsu]

Imagine fans of other manga reading this thread title

 

[Rootbeer]

Imagine fans of other manga reading this thread title

Imagine fans of other manga reading that a Katana in One Piece can be a Spear..

 

[Terra Arseid7]

Imagine fans of other manga reading that a Katana in One Piece can be a Spear..

 

[Rootbeer]

 

[Gaimon The Pirate]

All this just to sneak in the conclusion that Shanks, the man most known for being the world's strongest swordsman's greatest rival, isn't a swordsman

Just part time swordsrat, full time rat, and as such cannot compete for swordsman title.
People focused on the weapon, not the species.

 

[Rootbeer]

@Terra Arseid7

 

[Terra Arseid7]

@Terra Arseid7

I was buying things for my house lol.
Don't worry friend, now I'm making you look ridiculous once again, although you alone are enough to do it xD

Shirohige's halberd is not a sword, the 12 most powerful "swords" in OP refer to weapons with cutting blades, be it an axe, a spear, a scythe, etc. It is a fairly common mistake that you brainless people make.

 

[Rootbeer]

I was buying things for my house lol.
Don't worry friend, now I'm making you look ridiculous once again, although you alone are enough to do it xD

Shirohige's halberd is not a sword, the 12 most powerful "swords" in OP refer to weapons with cutting blades, be it an axe, a spear, a scythe, etc. It is a fairly common mistake that you brainless people make.

Alright..

What does it say in the red Rectangle?..

 

[L57]

What is kamusari again? @Albino 👑

 

[SkySanji]

What is kamusari again? @Albino 👑

Haki technique, even someone like Rayleigh couldn't learn it.

 

[Albino 👑]

@Albino 👑 Yo.. I couldn't sleep i was thinking about One Piece, and this has suddenly become so Obviously clear to me now, thank you for your thread.. You were actually right..

Knowing a Sword Skill doesn't make you a Swordsman..
Having a Sword Style makes you a Swordsman..

So Mihawk must have a specific Sword Style name..

Everything is so Gucci in my head now.. Rocks is not a Swordsman..

Technically using a sword in any way is part of swordsmanship yet it doesn’t make someone a swordsman

What is kamusari again? @Albino 👑

An attack not a part of any sword style

 

[Rootbeer]

Haki technique, even someone like Rayleigh couldn't learn it.

Depends.. Roger's Kamusari is CoA, Shanks is AdCoC..

Technically using a sword in any way is part of swordsmanship yet it doesn’t make someone a swordsman

Yeah, so we agree or not?.. Rocks' Sword Skill didn't prove that he was a Swordsman in One Piece..

 

[Albino 👑]

Depends.. Roger's Kamusari is CoA, Shanks is AdCoC..


Yeah, so we agree or not?.. Rocks' Sword Skill didn't prove that he was a Swordsman in One Piece..

Yeah I think so

 

[HA001]

Yeah I think so

Even this cope doesn't work any more

Shanks acoc is part of his swordsmanship which oda has said is INFERIOR to mihawks irrespective of mihawks wss title lmfao

 

[Rootbeer]

Yeah I think so

I can prove Sword Skills doesn't make someone a Swordsman through CoC, but i want to save it for a Video if possible.. I found that last night..

 

[Albino 👑]

Even this cope doesn't work any more

Shanks acoc is part of his swordsmanship which oda has said is INFERIOR to mihawks irrespective of mihawks wss title lmfao

Yes shanks can use haki…
Mihawk is a better skilled at swordsmanship than big mom or kizaru but he’s also the only actual swordsman between them