Search results

Oda doesn't mention anything like that, so what is the basis of this?

what do you mean good luck? do you consider a weaker swordsman who kill the WSS with a gun, as the WSS? no, i don't consider him WSS if the main cause / ability that he use to beat the WSS is not from being a swordsman. It's not confusing. Its just the real-life logic being applied in OP and...

Oda doesnt exclude other abilities from being a swordsman, just like real life. Your reply doesn't address the real point. WSS in real-life situation can be beaten by weaker swordsman with a gun, so the same apply to WSS in OP before proven otherwise. This is my view on this post and also the...

just like in real life. a swordsman in real life is not prohibited to have other strengths. But you can beat WSS in real life if you shoot him using a gun. So in OP, any other powers that is sufficient to beat WSS, can apply just like the gun analogy. Weaker swordsman can beat WSS if they use...

of course he didn't prohibit them, following the natural laws that doesn't prohibit any swordsman to use other powers, the same natural laws that state being the strongest swordsman in the world doesn't stop any weaker swordsman from defeating that WSS, when the weaker swordsman can use other...

Yes, he does. You consider him WSS, since him being the WSS would fit your definition of WSS being the strongest of all. But Roger doesn't have that WSS title and he have PK title instead, so your train of thought doesn't apply to him. The root of your view, imo comes from your favoritism of...

Roger is titled PK. He is a swordsman, i agree. But no one mentioned him as WSS, especially Oda'a title box. Sso imo your definition of WSS doesn't suit Oda's depiction of what WSS is, since Roger being on par with WB and even using sword (and being a swordsman), doesn't grant him WSS title...

i think our perspective is different. If Mihawk crushes Law's sword, and thwn Law teleports and use Mes or Soul Switch to take Mihawk's heart and win because of that, i don't consider Law to be a stronger swordsman than Mihawk, but he has other powers that makes him a stronger fighter overall...

what about my kind of view? - the title of swordsman applies like in the real world, where being a stronger swordsman or even WSS doesn't always guarantee a victory against weaker swordsman, if the weaker swordsman has other powers/strength that is sufficient to win the battle. - thus the WSS...