Search results

Vote Lynch Finalbeta. I know I'm Town, and I'd rather not permit my Mislynch.

Finally caught up. I'm going to address Cinera vs Finalbeta because it came up again: I want to make it clear that I was not (at the time at least) supporting his Lynch. What started it was me giving the reasons why someone might want to Lynch Beta as an explanation for Celestia's Lynch. Saying...

You're not a player, so please don't comment in the game thread. :kriwhat:

Yeah, I don't really get your case against TAC. It seemed to me like it was obviously a joke and that you appear to be intent on keeping it comes across as weird. I think this should only apply to dead players. Other players and spectators liking posts shouldn't matter IMO.

Anyway, my position on inactivity is that like fluff posting, it's unhelpful. It's very difficult to build reads on inactive players (as they haven't said much). Furthermore, if all inactive players are given a pass, scum can easily hide amongst them. Inactivity is uncooperative at best...

I'm just waking up, I'll catch up to the game now.

Anyway, @Marimo_420, @Light D Lamperouge, @Jew D. Boy: I think we should stop with the fluff posts now. It's discourteous to other members to require that they read through several pages of non content. It's also unhelpful to Town as it lets scum hide their lack of contribution. I'll be...

Fair enough, I can see why it would look that way.

@Natalija: someone else is bullying me about my sense of humour. :doffycry: Care to share your reasons?

Nah. In multiple past games I've stated that I'm willing to Lynch Don DaSlayer irrespective of his alignment because I didn't expect him to contribute to Town. I am clearly okay with Mislynching players I consider bad, so saying that I "would never assert that a player's Mislynch is no problem"...

Nah. This is a game that has total restrictions on claiming: You are not allowed to disclose Roles or the results of your Actions. As such, Roles in this game are much less important than reads, gameplay and general skill at Mafia. Thus, my conclusion that crap players aren't that valuable...

Nah, this has nothing to do with your role. That was me saying you're a crap player, so if you got Mislynched it would not be as bad as if a good player (say Drago if he was in the game) got Mislynched. Your role had nothing to do with the assessment, as the assessment was about the worst case...

10 Town, 4 Scum and 1 Third Party? That fits the numbers I guess. 2/3 Town is still in the acceptable range. But damn, it must be annoying playing Mafia as TAC. He gets suspected early on irrespective of what he does, and he's a prime target for Mafia Kills. I don't think I would be able to...

:vistalaugh: I see no mistake. :cheers: Beta is a good day 1 Lynch. He's not as likely to be helpful to Town as other players, so if his Lynch is a Mislynch it's not a big loss. That said, my incompetent player Lynch won the last Mafia game, so I'm not as confident in this philosophy as I was...