Search results

This might be valid had I not explicitly mentioned the possibility of Vanilla roles in the sign ups. Every player who signed up was aware of this, some players even prefer it, unfortunately you can't please everyone all the time just from the perspective of maintaining rand integrity.

With respect to the bolded bit, like I've already told you, it was for the best for those concerned. I don't need to go into that any more than I have. As for the rest of your argument, sure, but not every role can do everything either. I'm not particularly concerned about the town losing after...

Speaking of this one, this was actually a misplay, because Prof had the ability to delay the kill a night and charge it, and there wasn't actually a reason not to (he was given an option so that he wasn't forced to have the kill on a timer). Had he charged it, Kagura would have died Night 2, and...

@Flowa I think where we disagree here is the overall quality if the Town play in this game. I think some townies played well. I think a lot were bystanders, and had very little influence on the direction of the game. Put it this way - had Prof cleared his DR duty here and Zolo sided with him, I...

This isn't particularly the case. Zolo could have opted to stall today, but Light would kill him to fight, and it would only buy Prof one extra day to clear DR and beat Chaos. Hence why I called it now. It was for the best for all concerned, and I don't need to qualify that to you here but those...

There wasn't a need for a dedicated one, I had to be more careful with the recruit due to it not being announced.

Of course that writeup came before he had decided, had he rejected the next writeup would have had him refuse to go with them.

He was disguised which is why the grunts didn't recognise him. The higher ups did though, hence why several Legatus and just belows went to meet him, and you could tell he was Garlean due to him being summoned by the Emperor.

What do you mean maybe?

I don't agree with that at all, especially when it was very plausible that Ascians were only ever 2 strong had the Paragons died too early.

I hope you did enjoy some parts of it at least.

They don't tend to stay shut!

I loved the Levia role to be honest, next FFXIV game I'm going to make 8 people run things like that as a party.

:catblush: No please Yukino better win tho

It was more than slight. Had those two kills not happened it would come down to Prof. He still had the execute, too.

The Queen was a fun battle. Look up the "Queen's Edict" mechanic.

I can empathise with your frustration on that, believe me. It's why I'm not too sorry over the town losing, the misplays were really bad.

That shouldn't be what determines your take away from playing, though. Use heals sparingly and rely on the withstands to carry yourself through, the sooner you get 30 attacks in the better, take up to two failed mechs too.

I'm going to look to see if I can change the format here (spoilers - I'm heading the section once Drago steps down) and see if I can't make it more interesting by running it as a weekly turbo session. Anyway, I'm really, really frustrated at myself over that game, so I'm going to stop talking...

I was extremely disappointed you got lynched D1, and it was through no fault of your own. The no lynch was bad too, but I don't put that on one person and I think it's unfair and in poor taste to put that all on your step. You played well, for what it's worth. Y'shtola dying took Thancred away...