Questions & Mysteries Does Robin have also mythical devil fruit or did Kaido just never kill Luffy in the first place

which is correct?

  • Aokiji killed luffy before kaido

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Aokiji never killed luffy so did kaido

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Only kaido killed luffy. Explain why

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    0
#6
Yes and they are deaf for that time.

Luffy and Robin were frozen and on a time limit.

Kaido killed luffy. Until his fruit revived him
or maybe fluffy had cardiac arrest. so unless aokiji also killed fluffy and robin since their heart stopped beating, it is wrong too say that kaido also killed fluffy.
Because nothing in the series has shown that you can comeback from the after life (except brook. he never really went to the after life)
[automerge]1676293970[/automerge]
Against Aokiji Luffy was put in cryo. His body was completely frozen, as in his brain didn’t need the oxygen or blood therefore his body didn’t need his heart to pump.

Cryo and death are two very different things
what makes you say that fluffy died in the first place. is it because his heart stopped beating
 

HA001

World's Strongest Swordsman
#7
or maybe fluffy had cardiac arrest. so unless aokiji also killed fluffy and robin since their heart stopped beating, it is wrong too say that kaido also killed fluffy.
Because nothing in the series has shown that you can comeback from the after life (except brook. he never really went to the after life)
Cap. Enel heart stopped and was restarted by his fruit too

Luffys fruit is a zoan it has its own will.
Luffy didn't even know what was going on when he awakened.
 
#9
or maybe fluffy had cardiac arrest. so unless aokiji also killed fluffy and robin since their heart stopped beating, it is wrong too say that kaido also killed fluffy.
Because nothing in the series has shown that you can comeback from the after life (except brook. he never really went to the after life)
[automerge]1676293970[/automerge]

what makes you say that fluffy died in the first place. is it because his heart stopped beating
His heart stopped and his voice disappeared. Oda clearly designed it to be a resurrection
 
#11
His heart stopped and his voice disappeared. Oda clearly designed it to be a resurrection
it also happened against aokiji. so explain why this case is so different. It happened to enel, it happed to robin but against kaido fluffy miraculously died.
Does that mean that luffys fruit transcends death itself
[automerge]1676294271[/automerge]
what is your definition of death. I don't want to have pointless argument if we view death differently
 
#14
Luffy said many times that he would be the one to decide when he would die. So no, no one truly killed Luffy yet.
Death is not determined by your heart coming to a stop, it is the death of the brain that determines death. Luffy's brain didn't die in either case.
With Aokiji, he was simply frozen, and once he was thawed correctly do damage was done.
With Kaido, He probably lost consciousness, maybe his heart stopped for a moment from the shock, but his brain was not damaged, otherwise his DF would have left his body to appear somewhere else.
 
#15
Luffy said many times that he would be the one to decide when he would die. So no, no one truly killed Luffy yet.
Death is not determined by your heart coming to a stop, it is the death of the brain that determines death. Luffy's brain didn't die in either case.
With Aokiji, he was simply frozen, and once he was thawed correctly do damage was done.
With Kaido, He probably lost consciousness, maybe his heart stopped for a moment from the shock, but his brain was not damaged, otherwise his DF would have left his body to appear somewhere else.
Exactly.
 
S

Sasaki Kojirō

#16
Aokiji stated that after being frozen like this, people still stay alive for a while.

Luffy's death was perceived by several people and literally affirmed by Kaidou creating a dramatic atmosphere with Nami crying and throwing herself on the ground without wanting to believe that it happened, in the case above it is just nonsense.
 
Top