Super Role Madness Game Of Thrones: A Song Of Ice and Fire

[Jaguark101]

Morning

Got poisoned

I got poisoned as well

 

[Michelle]

oh I forgot, somone stole money from me.. how dare you???

 

[Michelle]

hmm 2 poison claims one probably false poisoning to confuse the healer?

 

[GalaxyLevelShanks]

Morning

 

[GalaxyLevelShanks]

I’m suspecting Melkor as scum

His vibe been off since his very first message

 

[Charlie]

oh so basically he would get some info like: '10 townies 5 mafia 3 pp are still alive' or something like that? Like census of the entire living playerbase?

Precisely. Maybe there's no cult because sometimes when there's one, IT says "current census". Idk

 

[Charlie]

Could have been a vig shot on Yoho then.

Or serial killer

 

[Great Potato]

with the way you think it is weird from me to ask questions about game mechanics and thus maybe hiding behind fake naiviety since so many things are apparantly so obvious to you

I am starting to believe it is hard that you think analysing confirmed information like who got killed and thinking why they got killed and what that could say about players is something you don't think is obviously important
same with someone possibly being poisoned

also after writing your huge list yesterday I found it weird how selective you seemed to be with whom you added to the list, like let's say you focused on analysing the most active players it was weird then how you didn't analyse Al Sama who is one of the most active for example

and it is also weird how you didn't lynch anyone after writing this list, like writing a list and not following up with an action after you spent so much time thinking about players and whom you suspect does seem to me like a way to appear enganged without actually pushing anything forward
what made you lynch polar bear in the end?

you suspecting me doesn't make you already mafia in my eyes but yes I am starting to wonder if it comes from a genuine towny place or if you are trying to find an opportunity to try for a mislynch because your focus seems very selective when you read my posts

I don't believe you being poisoned is important information at the moment because I don't think it's alignment indicative. That Fuji bothered to give everybody hit points in this set-up tells me that every faction probably has some attacking roles in their ranks. If we get a lead on who poisoned you then we'd have something to chew on, but for now it's just some anonymous attack that could very well be town. I also don't believe you need an in-depth knowledge of the game to piece together that a kill which conceals critical information from the town is a scummy role.

We're early into D2 and the two suspects you've shaded are Polar for his reaction to his wagon and myself for putting a wagon on Polar, that doesn't make me feel better about you.

Why I ended on Polar is that I was feeling uneasy about things being dead in a near tied game near the end of phase, and I wanted to gauge the reactions if I rattled the hive. I think things wrapped up too quick to gleam as much as I wanted, but we did score some intel out of that decision and some potentially notable behavior like Orca's jump from Melkor to Dio in the mix of things.

 

[Charlie]

Mafia could have a graverobber role.

And go through all this effort to kill yoho out of all people?

It's either vig or sk who will posture themself as vig

 

[Charlie]

I'm still not liking Tayenne's posts, just the sort of questions he is asking feel like playing naive which I have a hard time buying for someone who claims to have many previous games under their belt.

Why act like Zemmi's death is a confusing choice that needs looking into when the obvious reason is that she sought out a sub because she possessed a powerful town role that she didn't want town to lose and then was voted part of an elite council that will have sway over the thread? Any non-scum members in that council have targets on their back from this point and should become priorities for any protective roles out there.

Why would a janitor kill that scrubs the identity of a killed player to deny information to the thread ever be anything other than a scum role? I don't mean to be rude if these are sincere questionings, but it keeps looking to me like fluff posting designed to look engaged without actually moving the needle in the thread.

tbh, same

Wasn't he (?) the one who responded to "are you new to mafia?" with "on this website, yes"? That would mean he's been playing mafia in general, yet somehow never heard of things like janitor and census.

 

[Charlie]

As for poison, in past one piece game, mafia had healer and serial killer had poisoner so nothing is impossible.

 

[Flower]

No. Although I wouldn't say it was a terrible shot lol

Yoho was obvious Town, so if it was a Vig shot it’s atrocious usage.

 

[Charlie]

I’m suspecting Melkor as scum

His vibe been off since his very first message

Can you give some examples?

Yoho was obvious Town, so if it was a Vig shot it’s atrocious usage.

Pretty sure i saw people putting him as scum when i was catching up. Not many people putting him as town though.

 

[Flower]

Also guys there can be duplicate roles and multiple attacking roles. So it’s not clearing at all if anyone is poisoned unless nobody claims the action.

 

[Charlie]

hmm 2 poison claims one probably false poisoning to confuse the healer?

Or double action

 

[Charlie]

@Crowned Witch @gingerbread can't say i remember much from you tbh

What's up?

 

[Flower]

That Fuji bothered to give everybody hit points in this set-up tells me that every faction probably has some attacking roles in their ranks. If we get a lead on who poisoned you then we'd have something to chew on, but for now it's just some anonymous attack that could very well be town

I like that post honestly.

 

[Flower]

Think Potato overall vibes a bit like in the Marvel game. In that game he also sounded scummy and made posts that rubbed people the wrong way, but that was just because he had his own opinions and wasn’t afraid to speak his mind. While iirc in the Thriller Bark game we played he was a lot more trying to appease to people and he was detached scum.

 

[Jaguark101]

I got info, will share after certain people post.

 

[Charlie]

Think Potato overall vibes a bit like in the Marvel game. In that game he also sounded scummy and made posts that rubbed people the wrong way, but that was just because he had his own opinions and wasn’t afraid to speak his mind. While iirc in the Thriller Bark game we played he was a lot more trying to appease to people and he was detached scum.

I do like myself Mr Potato tbh :o

I got info, will share after certain people post.

@Fujishiro

Silence @Jaguark101

Spoiler

jkjk

Spoiler

or am I? :o