Who receives the official MVP?


  • Total voters
    15
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.

Emil

Certified Memelord
1. Kiku - Lean Scum (was on the wrong side of Ultra as his wagon was growing iirc, will need to check.
2. Alwaysmind - Null
3. Flower - Lean Town
4. HeWhoHasNoEqual - Lean Town
5. Hayumi - Lean Scum
6. T-Pein™ - Lean Town, but I will posit that he *could* bus Ultra. Don't think it's particularly likely though.
7. Naomi - Lean Town
9. Mr. Reloaded - Null - Undecised, voting was not good end of day but I don't really think it's scum indicative
10. Dr. Watson - Lean Town
11. Ekkologix - Lean Town - Mostly on the wrong side via his pushes, which gives me some reservation, but probably town.
12. Red Night - Indie/Scum - Viable lynch, looked bad off the Ultra flip.
13. Polar Bear - Lean Town - Don't see him being scum with Ultra.
14. CakeWalker - Lean Town - I don't think as scum she defend a scum mate like that. Big day for her today though, I expect some good solving.
15. MangoSenpai - Null/Lean Scum- Ultra did draw some attention to him, but it was mostly soft and didn't go anywhere. Mango had a weird comment about a lack of Ultra vs Ratchet, despite it beginning and he didn't seem to really have anything to offer to the thread insight-wise.
18. Seatonnes - Lean Town - I think he was the countereagon for scum to pivot to.
19. Indigo - Lean Scum - Vote on Flower was pretty horrible, and poorly explained, and actually only came once Flower was a viable wagon. Was again on the wrong side of the Ultra flip, poor reasoning for town reading him. My second pick for scum after Hayumi confidence wise currently.
20. Luka - Lean Town - Very selfish player, and doesn't really seem to care about working with the town. I attribute this more to town because there is a lack of concern about how one is perceived here. Weak read, and can pivot.
21. Michelle - Lean Town - Not quite fully sold on Michelle, yet, but generally have been in agreement with her and was on Ultra early.
23. Sallucion - Null - Needs to be replaced.

@Flower
when was this post written?
 

Ratchet

The End and the Beginning
vote lynch seatonnes
Votes a counter wagon to Ultra.
Vote lynch Ekkologix

CFD! CFD! CFD!
Attempts to go another direction (there was thread sentiment for this, so it could be a viable push).
Ultra as the day one lynch, huh? Thats rare
I don't really have a horse in the ultra vs seatonnes war I'm just tying it for fun
These are the only comments specifically around the Ultra wagon.

It's not great. Part of me supposes though, that as scum you might perhaps be more invested in making sure you have a position here, this just reads as largely ambivalent in everything *except* the mechanical actions that you have taken (that is, the votes you've cast). I think my leaning stands.
 
Also self meta is a little whack. I can also say waking up on a Sunday morning and being like "Imma bus Ultra today for no reason" is a thing that's absolutely within my scum range as I did the same to Rottkins in his first game, but I'm Town and know I'm Town and if you're Town and you know that as well there's no reason for self meta. It just shows you're aware of that and creates WIFOM.
 

Emil

Certified Memelord
I just wrote it. I haven't read anything except my mentions from when I said I was leaving for the day, aside from some of these last two pages.

Any more smarmy comments from you and I think I'll just ignore. Not literally, of course.
that was obvious enough because cake's solve so far is me and seatonne as scum, while hayumi and indigo town. thats already 4 opposing your reads so the expectation of good solving from her PoV shudnt be met so far for you

the rest of the reads r basically a summary of who was on which side of ultra's wagon. it's pretty lazy and one dimensional. i hope the game is this easy, maybe it actually is. we'll see. i hope we can get another list after u catch up
 

Ratchet

The End and the Beginning
so scum is incapable of lynching there buddies for town cred.

k
Have you actually read my interactions with Ultra? It's not just the fact I voted him. In fact, I know you haven't read them, so I'll explain them, and then you can go and fact check for yourself.

Early on, I ask Flower for a read on Ultra. When she says Slight Town, I tell her that I have him at Scum. This came after I shut down Ultra's attempt to open up suspicion on Ekko. Now if you go back to that time, you'd see that Ultra's response to that was to meekly concede his stance. If he and I are planning to distance, you can assume we would be doing so - it wouldn't just be me hurting his position (and undermining town reads on him) while he offers meek resistance. He would have no issue aggressively defending that because it would be manufactured.

I know you have a scum read on me for whatever reason - that's on you to solve, not me. All I can do is point you to the answers.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top