Questions & Mysteries Is Carrot on the Sunny
- Thread starter Albino 👑
- Start date
What's the point of carrot? She didn't even do anything in wano.
Carrot's journey parallels Inu and Neko's. Both of them sailed with Roger and WB, before becoming king of Zou. However, neither of them accompanied Roger to Laugh Tale.
Carrot sailed with Luffy, but ultimately, she won't accompany him to laugh tale. Just like Inu and Neko. You can truly make a stronger case for Yamato or Momo joining.
Carrot's journey parallels Inu and Neko's. Both of them sailed with Roger and WB, before becoming king of Zou. However, neither of them accompanied Roger to Laugh Tale.
Carrot sailed with Luffy, but ultimately, she won't accompany him to laugh tale. Just like Inu and Neko. You can truly make a stronger case for Yamato or Momo joining.
Right now, it depends on whether SHP vs. BMP get a round 3. If so, it makes sense for Carrot's journey to continue because Perospero was taken out of Battlefield by Sanji, not properly defeated.
But, Carrot beating Perospero would be ridiculous, as that would put her in Yonkou commander Territory.
In any case, I don't care either way. Just saying, as long as BMPs still active, Carrot being with SHP is not as ridiculous as one may think.
But, Carrot beating Perospero would be ridiculous, as that would put her in Yonkou commander Territory.
In any case, I don't care either way. Just saying, as long as BMPs still active, Carrot being with SHP is not as ridiculous as one may think.
I can see both arguments for this
-Queen Carrot is really, really, really fucking stupid and stowing away is an established Mink gag
-On the other hand, we have fuck all reason to care about Carrot and Oda did plenty of really, really, really fucking stupid things in Wano so it would fit in fine
If she’s getting brought along for another arc it has to be for the purpose of really delving in her as a character, and Oda’s so far failed miserably to do that. He had an entire a four year arc to build up a Carrot plotline and did nothing with her. If she has just fucked off to Zou well, she at least got more of a sendoff than Marco who’s just vanished. Or Hyogoro.
Even the stowawaying idea- okay, it’s an established gag, but her telling the Mink leaders she doesn’t think that’s what Pedro’s will meant and asking Luffy to keep going travelling with him until she understands would be far more compelling than “tee hee I’ve ran away! Surprise!”
-Queen Carrot is really, really, really fucking stupid and stowing away is an established Mink gag
-On the other hand, we have fuck all reason to care about Carrot and Oda did plenty of really, really, really fucking stupid things in Wano so it would fit in fine
If she’s getting brought along for another arc it has to be for the purpose of really delving in her as a character, and Oda’s so far failed miserably to do that. He had an entire a four year arc to build up a Carrot plotline and did nothing with her. If she has just fucked off to Zou well, she at least got more of a sendoff than Marco who’s just vanished. Or Hyogoro.
Even the stowawaying idea- okay, it’s an established gag, but her telling the Mink leaders she doesn’t think that’s what Pedro’s will meant and asking Luffy to keep going travelling with him until she understands would be far more compelling than “tee hee I’ve ran away! Surprise!”
She's practically being forced to take a role she's not interested in and her potential goodbye scene with the strawhats was off-screened.
If she's not hiding on the sunny and she doesn't join the crew Oda will have treated her faaaar worse than any "potential crewmember" I have seen lol.
Here for the meltdowns either way.
If she's not hiding on the sunny and she doesn't join the crew Oda will have treated her faaaar worse than any "potential crewmember" I have seen lol.
Here for the meltdowns either way.
Carrot recognising that Pedro's will doesn't dictate that she become a leader and instead encourages finding your purpose in the world would be pretty nice. Inu and Neku left it in Carrot and Wanda's hands and if Carrot feels she's not ready yet and wants the others to cover for her till she's old enough, I think that would he fine. She can take over as leader when she's older, it kinda feels like Inu and Neku pushing something on her that doesn't exactly fit with Pedro's words, will or lifestyle. We'll see, I guess.
