Who will be the Next Strawhat?


  • Total voters
    489
I know ya'll are gonna say it's stupid, but hear me out. Lilith has both a role and a dream now. Scientist role, and a dream to find an eternal fuel source/create her own sun. I'm still not jumping on board the Vegapunk train, but that's something to consider. I do think if there's another crewmate they'll join on this island, so it's not outside the realm of possibility imo.
I don't think any of the six Vegapunks are candidates, but at least Lilith is showing some signs of being independent and actually willing to guide the Strawhats. We've been burned out before with the last "candidates", but still a better scientist option than Caesar. She's definitely a focus of this arc just like Bonney.
 
I'm glad caribou is leaving I just can't stand him and his nakama supporters
I definitely can’t see him as Luffy’s 10th person in a one vs. one in 11 Straw Hats vs. 11 Titanic Captains.

Speaking of which, not that I want to make people who like Kinemon, Tama, Carrot, or Vivi feel bad, but I’d definitely be more interested to see Yamato as an officer in an 1 vs. 1 against a Blackbeard Captain. No offense to fans of those other characters of course.
 
I definitely can’t see him as Luffy’s 10th person in a one vs. one in 11 Straw Hats vs. 11 Titanic Captains.

Speaking of which, not that I want to make people who like Kinemon, Tama, Carrot, or Vivi feel bad, but I’d definitely be more interested to see Yamato as an officer in an 1 vs. 1 against a Blackbeard Captain. No offense to fans of those other characters of course.
Yamato vs Kuzan is a matchup that makes a lot of sense to be fair, both have ice powers and Yamato is within his power level
 
I definitely can’t see him as Luffy’s 10th person in a one vs. one in 11 Straw Hats vs. 11 Titanic Captains.

Speaking of which, not that I want to make people who like Kinemon, Tama, Carrot, or Vivi feel bad, but I’d definitely be more interested to see Yamato as an officer in an 1 vs. 1 against a Blackbeard Captain. No offense to fans of those other characters of course.
Nah there’s always an ally helping out. So the question is just who’s the next ally.

We get Sabo and Bonney with direct connections to Blackbeard so it’ll be one of those two.
 
Nah there’s always an ally helping out. So the question is just who’s the next ally.

We get Sabo and Bonney with direct connections to Blackbeard so it’ll be one of those two.
Yeah, I’ve concluded Yamato will indeed join the Straw Hats as the 10th recruit after returning from temporary leave, like Jinbe did. Pretty excited for that to happen, but I can still see Sabo and Bonney helping out from the revolutionary side.
 
Top