Who will be the Next Strawhat?


  • Total voters
    370
I am not going to withdraw my support for Vivi... two Ds? So what? I mean, Blackbeard and Ace were on Whitebeard's crew. We have two AdvCoC users on the Strawhats. Heck, in the past, the idea of a Warlord joining them was thought impossible.

Besides, a line Vivi thought when she was captured intrigued me. "I might have to do something about this." What Vivi, what could you do against these CP-0 Agents? You were clearly thinking of something....

Also, her ancestor, Lili, pushed for the Dawn of the World. Her father is dead and Cobra made it clear that Alabasta was to stand with the D. Surely this adds credence rather than the opposite?
 
I am not going to withdraw my support for Vivi... two Ds? So what? I mean, Blackbeard and Ace were on Whitebeard's crew. We have two AdvCoC users on the Strawhats. Heck, in the past, the idea of a Warlord joining them was thought impossible.

Besides, a line Vivi thought when she was captured intrigued me. "I might have to do something about this." What Vivi, what could you do against these CP-0 Agents? You were clearly thinking of something....

Also, her ancestor, Lili, pushed for the Dawn of the World. Her father is dead and Cobra made it clear that Alabasta was to stand with the D. Surely this adds credence rather than the opposite?
Vivi also has plenty of Dream options now too.

1. Avenge her father.
2. Usurp the World Government for a better one.
3. Find out who Lily was like her father before her.
 
I am not going to withdraw my support for Vivi... two Ds? So what? I mean, Blackbeard and Ace were on Whitebeard's crew. We have two AdvCoC users on the Strawhats. Heck, in the past, the idea of a Warlord joining them was thought impossible.

Besides, a line Vivi thought when she was captured intrigued me. "I might have to do something about this." What Vivi, what could you do against these CP-0 Agents? You were clearly thinking of something....

Also, her ancestor, Lili, pushed for the Dawn of the World. Her father is dead and Cobra made it clear that Alabasta was to stand with the D. Surely this adds credence rather than the opposite?
It's not the two D thing. It's the fact that Alabasta is clearly important and Vivi needs to lead it. Cobra literally said they need to fly the flag of the dawn of the world. Is Igaram going to take care of that while Vivi runs around getting rescued from Blackbeard fodder by Sanji? Alabasta will probably be at the forefront of the WG war alongside Wano. It's the exact same situation as Momonosuke. There's simply no reason for her to become a low ranking member of a yonko crew instead of becoming Queen of Alabasta.
Vivi also has plenty of Dream options now too.

1. Avenge her father.
2. Usurp the World Government for a better one.
3. Find out who Lily was like her father before her.
The first two can be the dream of 90% of One Piece characters and also really don't capture the strawhat's spirit. Vengeance isn't a dream. Overthrowing the government isn't a dream. Finding all blue is a dream. Drawing a map of the world is a dream. Dare I say creating an infinite energy source in order to achieve world peace is a dream? It's not about destroying someone or something.

As far as the third, I assume Sabo will tell her. And even if he doesn't it's a pretty crappy dream if it gets fulfilled a couple of weeks after she thinks of it.

Regardless, this is all speculation, and I can do the same thing for literally any character in the series.

Edit: To add to this, any character joining the strawhats with a dream to kill Imu or overthrow the WG would have to be the one who does that instead of Luffy, which is ridiculous.
 
Last edited:
Wow! This must have been so intense back then. Would have loved to read some of the stuff that was deleted - would have constantly been in Risita-popcorn mode.

"Cum droplets!" :gokulaugh:


@Adam-san is still around as I looked him/her up just now. You must be glad Yamato didn't join.


Thanks so much for the digging! :smoothy:
i dropped one piece for a few months after buggy became emperors but oda is cooking
 
Partially, Vivi kinda lose her place to be on the deck. Maybe That why she is 5.5 nakama, she is a D too.
And Hancock kinda lose some place.
Luffy- King,
Vivi- Queen,
Hancock- Concubine :catblush:
 
If Vivi meets with the SHs again then I do believe there is a good chance she will rejoin them.

I highly doubt a new character will join the crew, and Yamato fans and Carrot fans can cope all they want but I really don't see them joining.

To me either Vivi rejoins the crew or no one else joins.

:shocking:
Trust me - there will be one character joining the crew this arc and it will be Lucci. And by the way, I am as sure about that as I am sure about Stussy not being on Vegapunk's side (and Shaka being related to Lucci by blood.).

And if you still think I am coping, then lets bet about all three of those statements. One month for each.
 
I am now formally withdrawing my support for Vivi as a nakama, there is no way in hell you're gunna have 2 Ds in the SH, this reeks of Law, this reeks of Yamato, this reeks of ultimate princess in distress arc format, the starter of the D thing is literally Vivi's ancestor.

I'm gunna hold out till 1088 for a certain someone and if that doesn't pay off, i'm officially retiring and deleting my account and tapping out of this ordeal.

:peperain:
the nostalgia :steef:
 
Remember folks, don't commit so hard to a nakama candidate based on two panels and your own theories. Wait for real evidence like a dream and a role.
Yeah, don't commit to a candidate even after "shining nakama action", constant focus and being SH ally/travelling on Sunny. We had characters do that and still no luck joining.

SH need a mighty 6 though for the WG battle (Luffy vs Imu, 5 SH vs Gorosei), unless Luffy is going to defeat 1 Gorosei per arc now....
 
Top