Who will be the next Strawhat


  • Total voters
    810
if we're talking about future arcs then same can be said for yamato

at least for carrot it can be argued that there's perspero
It is true that Yamato does not follow the trope of having future main antagonist like rest of strawhats girls. As well most her backstory is revealed in this arc as well her goal. However, she does have enemy that strawhats are currently facing in wano that has hindered progress in life for 20 years. So, she does follow that trope that relates to zoro, nami, Sanji, Chopper, Robin Franky, Brook, and Jimbei in terms of enemy that betrayed them and impede their goals in life. As wellbeing an outcast and prisoner under her father own organization. Even if Kaido is defeated, she would face mass of amount discrimination based on the fact she is the child of the person who had harm wano for long time. There is something like Luffy, Ussop, Robin and Ace being children of criminals. That even citizen of that country does not entirely treat them like regular people. In addition, the recent vivre card we have no idea where Yamato was born or her mother where abouts. As well what happen to the Oni race. When Luffy does defeat Kaido, it does have an impact for Yamato as a character. Motivated her chance moving forward following her own path in life to get stronger for luffy and possible wano in the future when she comes back. Yamato could have a lot of enemies for her fight like Shanks might have super strong crew member, Smoothie for example from big mom, one of the admirals, and one of Blackbeard pirates




Characters like nami, Ussop, Robin, and sanji would challenge luffy against difficult obstacles. carrot vs perospero would feel like redundant fight in my opinion because one of her masters did the work for her already. Carrot fight would be unnecessary one unless her master sacrifice himself in order defeat him or that wasn't the real perospero all along.
Nami- challenge different species
Ussop-Leadership and worthiness
Robin-the entire world as your enemy
Sanji-one of the four emperor of sea
 
Last edited:
These folks can't even be original with their trolling.
It's the same damn things every time.
Repeated phrases as if that's all they can say, such a small sample of non-issues.

Yamato got them deep in their minds one way or another.
Look, trolls are always trolls man... They aren't meant to have originality since their aim is just to annoy, to get clout, and to seed more activities... Be kind to them and appreciate their efforts... :usosmug:
 
Nah true trolls are the kings of originality. Now you got wannabes who think they can make it.
It's just pitiful.
:risitameh:
Look, it's either you're born with the skill or you craft your skill and start from the scratch... It just so happens that they fall into the latter... Just hope that at some point they will improve... Even true trolls do flop many times...
 
I've spent 22 years with One Piece by my side, spent 16 years analysing it and 7 years examining it from a professionnal point of view. I've listen more Oda in my life that I have with my own parent... so trust me when I say that if I know something about storytelling and One Piece... I don't joke around!
I really hope you are lying here. Because if not, the fact that all other people can better analyze the story than you, is really sad. With some exceptions of course (topi, cocky and especially dizzy)

So after Wano you will realize you wasted so much time with something you have no talent, and other people are much better at this stuff with way lower time spend on analyzing stuff...

Dont you think its time to find another hobby? Something completely different? Maybe something that does not require using your brain that much rather using your muscles or so?
 
You are the only one that thinks like that cause if it was a special ability Oda would have made carrot perform it again but no
Not necessarally. He could keep that for later.

Okay because jinbei is a freshman(who knows the sea) and also in pre-time skip who was the one that was sailing the marine ship to ace execution
Yes, but the need for it was not created.

Well ODA(The Author of the story) doesn't make it seems like they need a lookout but you just see the little lookout moment with carrot and run with it 😕.
The "little moment" with Carrot on the look out is litterally 40+ panels of Carrot on the look out post. If you think Oda would just play with that kind of time.. you are greatly mistaken.

Yo! That doesn't make sense. You're twisting the words to try to give it a different definition but just adding "real".

Carrot is introduced in Zou also means that her introductory arc is Zou.
No. Because the fact here that only a SIDE of the personnality of Carrot was presented during Zou: Her post and her warrior Side.

The real cahracterization of Carrot came later, after her SECOND introduction. Just before whole cake. And this was extended all the way during the arc.

Carrot is a Saga character so far.
Yamato is an Arc character so far.
Tama is an Arc character so far.
Caribou is a multiple Arcs in different Sagas character with a Cover Story so far.
Law is a multiple Sagas character.
Indeed. Carrot is indeed a Saga character. Making her characterization completely different than any other characters. That's why it tool so much time to prepare her. The real end point of her characterization arrived at the moment were she reassured Sanji. At this moment the final brick of her "introduction" was put in. That one being "Carrot might look weak and naive, but she has a strong hearth.



Also who are your favorite characters? I've seen you say Carrot isn't in your Top 3??? So if your wrong would that drop Carrot further?
Yup. Carrot being a Nakama would confirm her current character arc. Making her a very simple yet very interesting character for me. Mine are for the moment Luffy, Usopp and Sanji (despite his huge flaws as a men)


A constant state of introduction similar to Nami and Robin? Here's the thing. To Luffy it was official. Those two were in his crew in his mind after their introductory arcs. They didn't know it but as you can clearly see, it was planned for them to be by Oda. Luffy has not invited nor accepted Carrot as a crewmate but as a guest which is where Carrot differs from Nami and Robin.
What counts is not how Luffy sees thing, it's how the protagonist is treated by Oda during the trip. Luffy might have only accepted Carrot as guest right now (even that we are not sure) the two have spent enough time together for us to say that this relation might have evolved during the adventure. And if it hasn't evolved now, it will later, once Carrot will jump again on the ship.

In fact, I would love for Luffy to refuse Carrot if she stowaway again. This would create something that Oda didn't really do until now.. a conflict between the two.. A reason for Carrot to do her best to be accepted and a development for Luffy. Now that I think about it, that's how I would do that. It would be fresh from a storytelling standpoint. So i'm not afraid about the future as you can see.. even if Luffy doesn't accept Carrot.


I really hope you are lying here. Because if not, the fact that all other people can better analyze the story than you, is really sad. With some exceptions of course (topi, cocky and especially dizzy)

So after Wano you will realize you wasted so much time with something you have no talent, and other people are much better at this stuff with way lower time spend on analyzing stuff...

Dont you think its time to find another hobby? Something completely different? Maybe something that does not require using your brain that much rather using your muscles or so?
Lmao. Coming from you, I take that as a compliment.
 
Not necessarally. He could keep that for later
Idk why he would do something like that when he has sanji doing skywalk to enter wano so just take the L cause u trying to prove something that isn't there 😴.
Post automatically merged:

"little moment" with Carrot on the look out is litterally 40+ panels of Carrot on the look out post. If you think Oda would just play with that kind of time.. you are greatly mistaken.
Nami was also looking out for Jinbei to dodge smoothie's Attack so 🤷‍♀️
Post automatically merged:

Yes, but the need for it was not created
Hmmm, But You trying to make it seems that carrot have to join when she doesn't, I am so glad that you aren't ODA and don't know why you are the only kept saying that she would join when it doesn't in the story shows that she would, but u always bring up being friends/having bonds with the cREw like it's isn't something that every character has by met the strawhats, she has nothing after WCI to bring something to her character other than being chopper 2.0 but as a female, white rabbit nothing special that set her different from her tribe, no different ability that her tribe doesn't have, no standout from them, Nothing prove that she is special/different from them that why u keep saying that she can fly when she can't. The Only Minks That StandOut Is Neko & Inu they are the only one.
 
Last edited:
Top