Role Madness NieR: Automata Mafia Game Thread [Game State: Night 6]

mmm I still think Orca reloading Flower is super anti-mafia and that the talk at night and prevent boss monster attacks is anti-mafia, moreso than being able to post mod messages every day (Yoho) or give people a second target (York). Why would mafia have a role that spawns boss monsters and protect from boss monsters? And so far every mafia role besides boss monsters seems to be infinite shot so what use do they have for a reload? Unless they could reload boss monster and if so they could just quietly spam unvoteable boss monster and just steal a partners fakeclaim.

I stick with my POE of KWEH York Yoho. All the scum roles so far have “you are x alignment but treated as y alignment” and the backup target seems just as lame as Lemon’s “you get too priority”-izer. I still don’t buy KWEH’s 2-shot rust prevention + 2+ shot commute claim. And Yoho has a bad D1 with motivations I can’t fully understand. The mod messages are confirmable but don’t say anything much. Also the messages from the Yorha don’t say much either.
I am also still under the impression that mafia shot Polar on accident and that Polar - despite maybe knowing he could convert to mafia - found too many scum D1 and was shot for it and their top reads were KWEH and Yoho as scum
I'm liking this one more because it doesn't feel like he is trying to solve and the logic he is displaying isn't very critical or intense. Its just plopping stuff and hoping a vote goes, but I'm still concerned with Hime. Emil is one to try and throw curveball punishing setup solving
 
Or maybe it’s just Yoho?

its WIFOM but why would York be the 2nd person to claim Yorha and why would they think they’re a miller if scum had fake claims for both (Gad had a 2nd fakeclaim to be Yorha and Lemon had a fakeclaim to be machine so)
 
Who is it then that narrows it down a lot
I think I'm coming back around to Yoho being my solution just because there are no other options that make sense to me. Hime and Kweh don't fit, Flower certainly doesn't, Orca has the very positive action of refilling Flower, and you were rolecrushed at times that wouldn't make sense for it to be you, I think


I hate this endgame I hate this endgame I hate this endgame
 
Day 6 - Vote Count 3 New

Emil

Kekko Taro
Day 6 - Vote Count 3


Votes:
Orca ->
Hime
Hime -> Kweh
Kweh -> Yoho > Unvote > Orca > Hime > Unvote
Flower -> Yoho
York -> Yoho
Crying -> Yoho > Unvote



Count:
Yoho = 2 (Flower, York)
Hime = 1 (Orca)
Kweh = 1 (Hime)



Please let me know if I made any mistakes.​

You have 5 minutes to discuss lynch.
With 7 alive, it is 4 votes required to achieve majority.


Day 6 ends in - Countdown

Living Players [7/23]
  1. @Yoho
  2. @York
  3. @The Orca
  4. @KWEH
  5. @Flower
  6. @Crying bc no Cryo
  7. @hime
Dead Players [16/23]
  1. @Butterscotch Sundae - YoRHA No. 9 Type S (9S) - YoRHa aligned - Lynched Day 1
  2. @Polar Bear - Adam - Machine Network aligned - Died Night 1
  3. @Luka - Eve - Machine Network aligned - Lynched Day 2
  4. @lemon.de - The Logic Virus - Machine Network aligned - Died Night 2
  5. @Fujishiro - ??? - YoRHa aligned - Consumed by Simone Day 3 - Flipped Day 3: YoRHa No. 6 Type O (6O)
  6. @Gadonkadonk - The Network - Machine Network aligned - Dueled out Day 3
  7. @Pot Goblin - YoRHa No. 2 Type B (2B) - YoRHa aligned - Executed Day 3
  8. @Ultra - Animal Loving Machine - Machine Lifeform aligned - Died Night 3
  9. @Charlie - Immanuel - Machine Lifeform aligned - Died Night 3
  10. @Red Night @tepig19283 - Plato 1728 - Machine Lifeform aligned - Died Night 3
  11. @T-Pein™ @Rej - Jean Paul - Machine Lifeform aligned - Claimed by the Sand Trials Day 4
  12. @Alwaysmind - YoRHa Type A No. 2 (A2) - Pearl Harbor Descend aligned - Lynched Day 4
  13. @Indigo - Kierkegaard - Machine Lifeform aligned - Died Night 4
  14. @Alexis2282AE - Jackass - YoRHa aligned - Died Night 4
  15. @Yo Tan Wa - YoRHa No. 21 Type O (21O) - YoRHa aligned - Died Night 4
  16. @Random Asshole @Worst - YoRHa No. 8 Type B (8B) - YoRHa aligned - Lynched Day 5.
Subs
  1. @Ratchet
  2. @Orwellian
 
Top