So the reason why I specifically listed Kiwi, Cinera, and Celestia was because they matched the people I wanted to go after. The guys that were watching the Bo vs TAC argument. I wouldn't say they were skirting around it cause they didn't. All 3 gave thoughts on the matter. I would say that Cinera looks the best out of the 3. At this time, Kiwi was the one who I thought looked to be worse, but as you know now, my read on her has changed! Let's look into why.
My initial suspicion had to do with how reserved she was. Like TAC pointed out, she isn't being assertive. She has been more on the fence considering her reads(until the last post). All these things pinged me and triggered my FoS. I decided to go back and look into her games as scum to see if the meta changed. Guess what? They didn't! In Finalbeta's and the Dressrosa game, she was a lot more assertive, had a much bigger impact in the discussion, thus my read went from scum to town. But, I wanted to check out another game of hers when she was town to again, see if the meta matched. It didn't! In the Bachelor game, she was vanilla and oh my, she put in work. She had reads and wasn't afraid to show them. She got into arguments, made her points(good ones btw), and didn't back down. She was being very, very proactive. When you compare her play this game and to that one, they're basically polar opposites. Now, I've got this neutral read because her meta from scum don't match, and meta from town don't match. BUT. In the games that she was scum in, she was indie. Indie playstyle compared to mafia playstyle are usually different because of the different circumstances involved.
Now, I must say, I do like this post from her. I understand what she's trying to say about Bogard and it does make sense. Bogard did look like he was ready to nitpick against TAC but that particular aggressive playstyle isn't very indicative of scum. It's an illogical way to play from a mafia perspective.
If I had to pick a side, I will lean town on Kiwi. Now, onto Celestia.