Current Events Should Jack be replaced by an F6 member?

[Lampyris]

Let's say there's a way to replace Jack in the All-Star rank without taking him out before the war. Would you be in favor of Jack getting replaced?

Arguments for:
1) Jack has taken far too many Ls, broken a blade, and has lost the reader's respect as a threat.
2) Jack is the perfect tool for the Tobbi Roppo to prove they are the real deal and not just an all talk about getting promoted.
3) Jack's most likely opponent is the Mink Tribe taking revenge, not any of the Strawhats. Zoro fights King, Sanji fights Queen, Jack screws up the pattern.
4) Sasaki, possibly another fishman, could replace Jack's race and also fight Jinbe.

Arguments against:
1) Jack has not gone all out. Until we see the hybrid mammoth, possibly awakened, the billion berry Jack has yet to appear.
2) Jinbe could take over if the dukes get wiped out by Jack. Inu and Neko are best friends with Kamawatsu, they could possibly bond with Jinbe over this.
3) Kaido's crew becomes far too powerful. Kaido's Snack equivalent has over a 1 billion berry bounty and his replacement might beat that.
4) Jack would have to change his name or the card order gets messed up.

Do you agree or disagree? And which Tobi Roppo member has the best case to replace Jack?

 

[OmegaPsyche]

Nah, Drake is a traitor, Who's Who is slightly below.

Hope people don't believe calamities will fight flying sixers during Wano war, that's dumb.

 

[Balen]

The problem is they would be injured and tired when they face the alliance and be taken down by the alliance easily they would never defeat without injuries

 

[Just a member]

The problem is that swap or not a fight has to happen and at that point the winner doesn't matter that much because he will be easy prey so most likely it is just to build up hype but we will not have a fight at all even because before they manage to find this son of Kaido, come back with him and set the fight the raid will be already discovered and kicking hard so this match will be put for later.

 

[MonsterZoro]

Tbh yeah I like jack and he’s strong but he’s been used as hype tool for everyone. Who’s who is really badass it would be nice to replace jack

 

[MarineHQ]

People need a reminder who Jack really was back when he was introduced.

Hopefully Who's Who or Sasaki fights Jack

 

[ranady]

Even if they fight, i dont think it will be until finished. Their fight will be interrupted by the attack of luffy alliance. But i think in a 1vs1, they wont beat jack, but could push jack to extreme diff

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

Jack hasn't taken any real Ls.

He almost caused the Mink tribe to go extinct by himself (ft. some fodder)
He sunk 2 battleships guarded by an Admiral. Survived the encounter uncrippled. Jozu can't say he's done that.
Saved a town / grandma from Ashura Doji's cruelty and took a minor wound while doing so. +1 protagonist points

 

[Jo_Ndule]

The one who will be be replaced is Queen

Has has death flags and Demotion flags all over him

He was gonna be killed if BM used soup pocus, the queen was scared for his life.


Oda disnt drop Queen getting demoted/killed for nothing

Luffy and Kidd are already near where he is.
One of them will beat Queen...if kidd fights Queen, then queen might even die

 

[Don DaSlayer]

Dont think so. I dont see them being close to Jack. I dont see him get replaced he is the youngest Calamity. My mans will get stonger and stronger.

 

[Kejon]

Jack shouldn't be replaced. He should stay a calamity and show us his real strength.

 

[Paperchampion23]

Its not happenening. The whole thing is just to further characterize how disfunctional the beasts pirates are a crew. They are entirely defined by strength and ranking. Kaido beats captains into submission and forces them to climb the ranks of his crew. His top Headliners are all a result of this. Hawkins was a recent addition, Apoo a little longer.

They likely wont' get to this point, and if they do, it will very likely be an excuse to show off their powers before the fights occur.

 

[Buusatan94]

No Jack hasn't shown his hybrid yet, he's certainely much stronger than any of the F6 and it's not the right moment for a Calamity to be replace anyway.

 

[Hurley Pirates]

Hell no lol

 

[Bogard]

They will all get a reality check. None of the calamities will be replaced

 

[L o g i a]

Arguments for:
1) Jack has taken far too many Ls, broken a blade, and has lost the reader's respect as a threat.
2) Jack is the perfect tool for the Tobbi Roppo to prove they are the real deal and not just an all talk about getting promoted.
3) Jack's most likely opponent is the Mink Tribe taking revenge, not any of the Strawhats. Zoro fights King, Sanji fights Queen, Jack screws up the pattern.
4) Sasaki, possibly another fishman, could replace Jack's race and also fight Jinbe.

1. Being smacked by Zunisha isn't a big L - Same with drawing with (and not using his full power either) Asura Doji, a man who was deemed the strongest Samurai in Wano until Oden beat him
2. This is true and this is why I'm in favour of Who's Who and Sasaki usurping him and getting their spotlight
3. This isn't a point in favour - it doesn't prove anything
4. I suppose so

Arguments against:
1) Jack has not gone all out. Until we see the hybrid mammoth, possibly awakened, the billion berry Jack has yet to appear.
2) Jinbe could take over if the dukes get wiped out by Jack. Inu and Neko are best friends with Kamawatsu, they could possibly bond with Jinbe over this.
3) Kaido's crew becomes far too powerful. Kaido's Snack equivalent has over a 1 billion berry bounty and his replacement might beat that.
4) Jack would have to change his name or the card order gets messed up.

Do you agree or disagree? And which Tobi Roppo member has the best case to replace Jack?

1. He did show us what he was capable of on Zou though
2. Why? There's no reason why this is even a point at all
3. I mean... it's meant to be the worlds most powerful crew - the all stars are hyped up to be superior to the Sweet Commanders and Kaido > Linlin, and the SMILE army - like, i don't see why this is a problem in the least
4. Uh, I doubt Jack is his real name - these guys use monikers and sobriquets

 

[Seth]

Dude survived the battle against 2 Admiral level characters ( Fujitora, Sengoku ) sank two of their ships, almost extinct Mink Tribe, and people think he is a hype tool for F6. Have you eaten a bad smile or something?
Flying Six are strong and that's without a doubt but I think the fight will be very intense for both F6 and All-Stars but I think Kaido wants to show Lin Lin that he has more than 3 Commander level characters. Their fights won't end or All-Stars will end them when Kaido shows the signal but without killing F6 making them strive to become stronger which would only benefit the Beast Pirates.

 

[Patryipe]

Respect the Mammoth, you mofos!

 

[Red Dog]

Let's say there's a way to replace Jack in the All-Star rank without taking him out before the war. Would you be in favor of Jack getting replaced?

Arguments for:
1) Jack has taken far too many Ls, broken a blade, and has lost the reader's respect as a threat.
2) Jack is the perfect tool for the Tobbi Roppo to prove they are the real deal and not just an all talk about getting promoted.
3) Jack's most likely opponent is the Mink Tribe taking revenge, not any of the Strawhats. Zoro fights King, Sanji fights Queen, Jack screws up the pattern.
4) Sasaki, possibly another fishman, could replace Jack's race and also fight Jinbe.

Arguments against:
1) Jack has not gone all out. Until we see the hybrid mammoth, possibly awakened, the billion berry Jack has yet to appear.
2) Jinbe could take over if the dukes get wiped out by Jack. Inu and Neko are best friends with Kamawatsu, they could possibly bond with Jinbe over this.
3) Kaido's crew becomes far too powerful. Kaido's Snack equivalent has over a 1 billion berry bounty and his replacement might beat that.
4) Jack would have to change his name or the card order gets messed up.

Do you agree or disagree? And which Tobi Roppo member has the best case to replace Jack?

Jack is catching too much Ls...Ulti should replace him as new All Star...

 

[majinbe]

Let's say there's a way to replace Jack in the All-Star rank without taking him out before the war. Would you be in favor of Jack getting replaced?

Arguments for:
1) Jack has taken far too many Ls, broken a blade, and has lost the reader's respect as a threat.
2) Jack is the perfect tool for the Tobbi Roppo to prove they are the real deal and not just an all talk about getting promoted.
3) Jack's most likely opponent is the Mink Tribe taking revenge, not any of the Strawhats. Zoro fights King, Sanji fights Queen, Jack screws up the pattern.
4) Sasaki, possibly another fishman, could replace Jack's race and also fight Jinbe.

Arguments against:
1) Jack has not gone all out. Until we see the hybrid mammoth, possibly awakened, the billion berry Jack has yet to appear.
2) Jinbe could take over if the dukes get wiped out by Jack. Inu and Neko are best friends with Kamawatsu, they could possibly bond with Jinbe over this.
3) Kaido's crew becomes far too powerful. Kaido's Snack equivalent has over a 1 billion berry bounty and his replacement might beat that.
4) Jack would have to change his name or the card order gets messed up.

Do you agree or disagree? And which Tobi Roppo member has the best case to replace Jack?

Disagree. Jack isn't getting replaced Queen is.