She was jailed and I thought she'd wouldn't be fool enough to lie to the jailor.
But if she's scum, then what option does she have, but to lie? Given that she was jailed, then at least one other person must have had your conviction on her being scum. She could have claimed anything and the Jailer couldn't risk shooting. And with the knowldge that the Jailer could not kill her anyway, your current assertion that the Jailer believed her claim
may not be completely true! Until we see another Night, they may have some suspicion on her, and will jail her again.
First I thought Prince had the ability to shoot night 1 itself but then Zara corrected me.
Which makes you not rethinking your earlier stance all the more puzzling.
But then again, she wouldn't know who the jailor is and there's still a possibility that she'd be shot if she was found scummy. Jailor can again jail you later on and shoot you when he gains that ability
But Kag, if she's scum, she has no choice here but to hunt for the Jailer. And we also know that the Jailer didn't really talk to Zemmi, so we can assume they only use her claim to read her here. Given that, until she's caught in a lie, the Jailer has no reason to pursue a lynch on her. That doesn't mean you should then abandon your approach entirely.
I rest my case, Your Honour. The defendent is
Guilty.