The baiting Room

[Jailer]

MF is 100 times better

MF is only better because of Ace's and WB's death. Remove those two and the fights are even worse than Killer vs Hawkins/Drake vs Apoo.

 

[Doggo]

MF is onpy better because of Ace's and WB's death. Remove those two and the fights are even worse than Killer vs Hawkins/Drake vs Apoo.

That's because the "fights" are actually just skirmishes.

 

[Twin Milf]

You can think whatever you want about Wano as a whole but even with all its filler Onigashima delivered more on the actual fighting part of a war than Marineford did

 

[OnePiss]

MF is only better because of Ace's and WB's death. Remove those two and the fights are even worse than Killer vs Hawkins/Drake vs Apoo.

Lol and that’s why Marineford is better. Who actually wants to see fights

 

[Jailer]

That's because the "fights" are actually just skirmishes.

Exactly one hit clashes, scene switches to Buggy and Luffy running

 

[Kurozumi Wiwi]

yeah let's the compare the fights of an arc that lasted 30 chapters vs an arc that lasted five times as long

 

[Twin Milf]

Exactly one hit clashes, scene switches to Buggy and Luffy running

Luffy running and screaming Ace's name for the 26th time in a chapter

 

[Doggo]

You can think whatever you want about Wano as a whole but even with all its filler Onigashima delivered more on the actual fighting part of a war than Marineford did

I legit think Marineford is better in this sense.
Wars are chaotic. At one moment you're fighting X, and the other moment, you're fighting Y, etc.
Its just that it wasnt an arc about "1v1's" like Wano is.

 

[Jaguark101]

Sry man.
The ending of the movie is simply too trash. It legit negates all the good the movie had.
Talia's death scene is trash B movie tier. Bane being a mere pawn....dear lord...why...

Look at this shit How did no one filming realise what a shit death scene this was. Her acting in this scene is garbage which is ironic because she is actually a pretty good actress.

 

[Twin Milf]

I legit think Marineford is better in this sense.
Wars are chaotic. At one moment you're fighting X, and the other moment, you're fighting Y, etc.
Its just that it wasnt an arc about "1v1's" like Wano is.

I've always seen Wano as a mix of EL and MF

 

[Doggo]

Exactly one hit clashes, scene switches to Buggy and Luffy running

Buggy, the Legendary.

 

[Jailer]

Lol and that’s why Marineford is better. Who actually wants to see fights

Yeah who wanted to see Whitebeard, Marco, Jozu fight, who wanted to see haki be explained, fuck lore info dump, let's follow most panels Luffy running to save Ace.


I will say tho Blackbeard saved MF actually even more than WB's death.

 

[Kurozumi Wiwi]

My only problem with MF is the haki stuff
No hardening
Apparently Sengoku has COC but never used it for some reason

 

[Doggo]

Yeah who wanted to see Whitebeard, Marco, Jozu fight, who wanted to see haki be explained, fuck lore info dump, let's follow most panels Luffy running to save Ace.


I will say tho Blackbeard saved MF actually even more than WB's death.

It's not like we had 100% chance of getting actually good fights even if we had them.
It's One Piece, after all.

 

[Jailer]

Luffy running and screaming Ace's name for the 26th time in a chapter

*Dressrosa flashback of Luffy screaming Mingo every now and then only to fight him 40+ chapters later

 

[Twin Milf]

yeah let's the compare the fights of an arc that lasted 30 chapters vs an arc that lasted five times as long

Nah Marineford isn't exempt from criticism just because it's short
You can unironically take all the Marineford pages of Luffy running and shit and make some decent short battles from them

 

[qwer8888]

"Zeami, in his work "Sandō" (The Three Paths), originally described a five-part (five dan) Noh play as the ideal form. It begins slowly and auspiciously in the first part (jo), building up the drama and tension in the second, third, and fourth parts (ha), with the greatest climax in the third dan, and rapidly concluding with a return to peace and auspiciousness in the fifth dan (kyū)."

 

[OnePiss]

Yeah who wanted to see Whitebeard, Marco, Jozu fight, who wanted to see haki be explained, fuck lore info dump, let's follow most panels Luffy running to save Ace.


I will say tho Blackbeard saved MF actually even more than WB's death.

You speak like Haki was fully developed back then???

 

[Wolverine]

Hint.

 

[Kurozumi Wiwi]

Nah Marineford isn't exempt from criticism just because it's short
You can unironically take all the Marineford pages of Luffy running and shit and make some decent short battles from them

It's still a silly a comparison, Marineford was never going to have lenghty 1 vs 1. In that sense it was a real war