[FNZ] Role Madness Breaking Bad Role Madness

[RippedCal]

Fwiw I think this is a townie post. Strikes me as a player that is convinced their theory was evidenced.

I don't agree with the conclusion but + for the process

I don't really agree with the conclusion either but how are you justifying the play? Like what's the rationale if you're town of not just PM'ing host about your role rather than giving scum info

 

[DoflaMihawk]

I got a good role

 

[Flower]

@BakiDou do you have your role by now?

 

[Charlie]

there were? i dont remember that

i think i was the only one who claimed voteless vanilla but i was lying

there were like 3 vanilla roles

gendry, margery's dad, pip/pop?

 

[BakiDou]

@BakiDou do you have your role by now?

If will have it soon.

 

[hime]

Well the problem I have is that it's your only meaningful position all game. A brief skim over your ISO and I can't say I'm impressed.

im not sure what u consider a meaningful position but one post questioning whether vanillas r present in the game is not enough to be a "meaningful position" in my book

kinda seems like u have tmi and know flowa is town and since shes being scum read rn anyway and might be lynched, ur trying to get the next mislynch ready (me) by making it seem like i was making some big push on her

 

[Flower]

im not sure what u consider a meaningful position but one post questioning whether vanillas r present in the game is not enough to be a "meaningful position" in my book

kinda seems like u have tmi and know flowa is town and since shes being scum read rn anyway and might be lynched, ur trying to get the next mislynch ready (me) by making it seem like i was making some big push on her

Yeah, I 100% won't be mislynched lol.

 

[Adam 🍎]

Yeah, I 100% won't be mislynched lol.

That is correct, because you will be lynched properly as scum

 

[hime]

there were like 3 vanilla roles

gendry, margery's dad, pip/pop?

yea i forgot, i think michelle died pretty early iirc and the other 2 were inactive af

 

[Rej]

A vanilla claim in a role madness game? How distracting!

 

[DoflaMihawk]

im not sure what u consider a meaningful position but one post questioning whether vanillas r present in the game is not enough to be a "meaningful position" in my book

kinda seems like u have tmi and know flowa is town and since shes being scum read rn anyway and might be lynched, ur trying to get the next mislynch ready (me) by making it seem like i was making some big push on her

So we lynchinh Ratch or what?

 

[Ratchet]

I don't really agree with the conclusion either but how are you justifying the play? Like what's the rationale if you're town of not just PM'ing host about your role rather than giving scum info

I don't have an answer to this. I don't think she gains anything by drawing attention to herself as scum like this.

im not sure what u consider a meaningful position but one post questioning whether vanillas r present in the game is not enough to be a "meaningful position" in my book

To be clear, your meaningful position in this context would be Flower not being truthful about her initial claim of being a vanilla.

kinda seems like u have tmi and know flowa is town and since shes being scum read rn anyway and might be lynched, ur trying to get the next mislynch ready (me) by making it seem like i was making some big push on her

I've had a town read of Flower for quite some time now, dismissing that as TMI is at best very lazy, and jumping to the conclusion I'm somehow setting you up as a mislynch here is, well it's either paranoia or overly defensive. I don't believe for a second you think what you just wrote

Vote: Hime

 

[Ratchet]

There are also several other players I'd be far better to prep as a mislynch on the basis of a town Flower flip than er, a largely inactive player.

What is that post.

 

[RippedCal]

I don't have an answer to this. I don't think she gains anything by drawing attention to herself as scum like this.
To be clear, your meaningful position in this context would be Flower not being truthful about her initial claim of being a vanilla.
I've had a town read of Flower for quite some time now, dismissing that as TMI is at best very lazy, and jumping to the conclusion I'm somehow setting you up as a mislynch here is, well it's either paranoia or overly defensive. I don't believe for a second you think what you just wrote
Vote: Hime

It's a reasonable point slightly diluted by the fact she already has a significant amount of attention on her, sure.

 

[hime]

I don't have an answer to this. I don't think she gains anything by drawing attention to herself as scum like this.
To be clear, your meaningful position in this context would be Flower not being truthful about her initial claim of being a vanilla.
I've had a town read of Flower for quite some time now, dismissing that as TMI is at best very lazy, and jumping to the conclusion I'm somehow setting you up as a mislynch here is, well it's either paranoia or overly defensive. I don't believe for a second you think what you just wrote

Vote: Hime

u said u ISO'd me, if u did then youd know i didnt read the thread yet and said id try and do it in the np

 

[Ratchet]

u said u ISO'd me, if u did then youd know i didnt read the thread yet and said id try and do it in the np

So why is your initial assumption that I have TMI to read Flower as Town? Why are you not even attempting to establish the facts around my positions before coming to your conclusions?

I also have no reason to take your claim to be ignorant on the thread at face value.

 

[Ratchet]

It's a reasonable point slightly diluted by the fact she already has a significant amount of attention on her, sure.

I feel like it would just be more negative attention, as if she's scum she would have had to see her role and then made the conscious decision to claim she's received nothing. Which is a strange process for scum to follow really.

 

[Dragomir]

That's some weak reasoning, Flower. Doesn't at all match the certainty you expressed at the time of that vote.

Looks more to me like you saw a chance to jump at Ekko and side with Ratchet. Your suspicion of Ekko doesn't look organic, Flower. It's looking very opportunitic.

You're approaching this at a very weird angle. You have the perspective of knowing you're town but Ultra doesn't share that perspective. He will only know once you're flipped. How can you expect him to know whether his read on you is right or not before that flip? And saying that Ultra's reads can never be wrong on you means nothing because nobody as of now has anyway of learning your alignment that isn't flipping you. You can easily say that as scum to throw him off. You're trying to incriminate the guy at an angle that he can't measure.

@Flowa you better not ignore this.

 

[RippedCal]

I feel like it would just be more negative attention, as if she's scum she would have had to see her role and then made the conscious decision to claim she's received nothing. Which is a strange process for scum to follow really.

Agree actually. I don't put morally questionable tactics past Flower entirely but I do think it's more likely that she didn't actually get anything than that she's faked a host mistake. Still hate the way she shoved it in our faces but I guess town wants to be town read to an extent just like scum does

 

[Ratchet]

Agree actually. I don't put morally questionable tactics past Flower entirely but I do think it's more likely that she didn't actually get anything than that she's faked a host mistake. Still hate the way she shoved it in our faces but I guess town wants to be town read to an extent just like scum does

Right. I do have something against this but it has already reached enough angle shooting territory for my liking and beyond speculation none of it is very conclusive so I'm inclined to believe she just didn't really think her posts through. Outside chance she still hasn't received anything and is saving face until she does.