A break for Night Lynch Deciders after N1?

  • Yay

    Votes: 2 6.9%
  • Nay

    Votes: 11 37.9%
  • Are you enjoying the Game?

    Votes: 7 24.1%
  • Yay

    Votes: 8 27.6%
  • Nay

    Votes: 1 3.4%

  • Total voters
    29
Status
Not open for further replies.

Pot Goblin

Conejo Blanco
Wendy`s services are available!

Did you have a hard day at work and your brain is cooked out? Come have some moments with me at the Crossroads motel, i promise you will have the best time of your life in the company of t` greatest girl this city has ever seen, we will do anything you like.

Quote this post if you are interested.​
I'll go ahead and join this if it's not too late
:endthis:
 
Dofla looks like a possible scum slot. Iso offers nothing of merit except from a eccentric Ekko/Ratchet bus theory, seems like he's caught up so wondering why he isn't doing anything
 

Ratchet

The End and the Beginning
What part of me discussing the new information and not placing much stock into it is 'not reflecting' on new info?

Clearly I have reflected on it but do not agree with the assertion that it confirms your character. I do think it bares factoring in, and will consider it when I have finished thinking about where to leave my vote come end of day.
The part where you admit you haven't actually put it into consideration. My point is, even if you believe characters other than Marie could send that message, Marie is a very plausible option, and for the purposes of Day 1 that should be enough to not be resolved immediately as in through the lynch.

All I see here frankly is you stalling.
Flower argument is in no way nonsense, although I had not factored in the gifts as I had not read it. I do still have qualms about the confirmation but happy to leave that for the moment with the info coming in.
My nonsense comment was in regards to the new information.
 
The part where you admit you haven't actually put it into consideration. My point is, even if you believe characters other than Marie could send that message, Marie is a very plausible option, and for the purposes of Day 1 that should be enough to not be resolved immediately as in through the lynch.

All I see here frankly is you stalling.
My nonsense comment was in regards to the new information.
Where did I say I haven't considered it? My literal question about it was me considering it, as I wanted to know if you were confirmed to be Marie via charlies pm, which he says you were not.

Marie is plausible, I also said that, it is certainly possible for you to be Marie but it is also possible you aren't. As mentioned, I'm considering where I leave my vote end of day you aren't locked in as my vote.

Stalling for what exactly?
 

Lindltaylor

There's no "Tina!"
What part of me discussing the new information and not placing much stock into it is 'not reflecting' on new info?

Clearly I have reflected on it but do not agree with the assertion that it confirms your character. I do think it bares factoring in, and will consider it when I have finished thinking about where to leave my vote come end of day.

Flower argument is in no way nonsense, although I had not factored in the gifts as I had not read it. I do still have qualms about the confirmation but happy to leave that for the moment with the info coming in.
I haven't read majority of the day phase, but my assumption of what I read is that you and Ratchet have been going at each other before Day 1 started, and you're still going at each other.

I don't know the flavor and the fact that you say other characters can message Skylar are possible tells me why you wanna question Ratchet, but you're overdoing it. At this point if Ratchet is really someone else, I believe only mechanical evidence can prove that and further arguments seem to be running in circles.

Could you give us something else? Going only at Ratchet isn't enough. Do you have any other town/suspicious reads?
 
I've gone over it a few times now. Meta plus soft pushes from him plus fallacious engagement. We need to go somewhere and nobody seems to town read him so it shouldn't be this hard to get votes going.

And yet it is.
Does he lean into flavor more as scum. I've noticed he's done that quite a lot here. I do think he's been engaging the game more early than I noticed last game but i was also scum last game so maybe wasn't noticing things to the same extent.
 
Where did I say I haven't considered it? My literal question about it was me considering it, as I wanted to know if you were confirmed to be Marie via charlies pm, which he says you were not.

Marie is plausible, I also said that, it is certainly possible for you to be Marie but it is also possible you aren't. As mentioned, I'm considering where I leave my vote end of day you aren't locked in as my vote.

Stalling for what exactly?

who else sends Skylar a message tho?
He said he would send a message to skylar.
And charlie did not deny it.
He could....
he said some weird thing about having a fake claim which is strange tho.
 

Ratchet

The End and the Beginning
which he says you were not
I said I was not, too.
Marie is plausible, I also said that, it is certainly possible for you to be Marie but it is also possible you aren't.
The problem is you're assigning equal weighting to both scenarios, when there is no good reason to do so. While something may be possible, it's not so likely that it needs to be considered much for the purposes of Day 1.
Stalling for what exactly?
To manufacture your opinion to that of the thread temperature, possibly, or simply to pivot to somewhere else. I don't think you're all that scummy, to be clear, but I have no reason to think you're Town either, and your behaviour can be easily explained as scum too (especially if Ultra flips scum).
 

Rej

I wear Dior, not a fad, fad, fad, fad...
But I will place my vote nevertheless on any policylynch wagon. So where is my non-existent vote, that doesn't count needed?
 

Ratchet

The End and the Beginning
Does he lean into flavor more as scum. I've noticed he's done that quite a lot here. I do think he's been engaging the game more early than I noticed last game but i was also scum last game so maybe wasn't noticing things to the same extent.
Not particularly but I wouldn't rule it out either. He tends to be less interested in actually trying to scum hunt as scum and I didn't like how willing he was to engage in the fluff.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top