Controversial How would you rank em?

[Yoho]

How would you rank the first commanders, Sabo included in terms of favorite to least favorite? For me it goes

Zoro
Katakuri
Sabo
Marco
King
Mihawk
Shiryu
Beck

And for power scaling purposes I'd rank em

Mihawk
Zoro
Sabo
King
Beck
Katakuri
Marco
Shiryu

 

[Mr.Baj1o]

In Terms of strongest

-Mihawk
-Benn Beckman
-Zoro
-Shiryu ( i dont see shiryu stronger than Zoro... if they fight it wont be a extreme diff win for Zoro)
-King
-Sabo
-Marco
-Kata

 

[Erkan12]

Shiryu
-Best CoA and AP by piercing Garp, equal AP to Magellan's, and speed to be undetectable vs Koby's CoO, will improve with new DF more.

Sabo
-Very Good CoA to overpower Bastille and Burgess with ease, will improve with new DF.

Marco
-Very Good CoA to clash equally with Big mom and Akainu, blitzes Alber and Queen.

Mihawk
-Most wanked shit of all time, strong but not that strong.

Zolo
-Will get stronger, not yet top 3.

Beckman
-Very good CoA to stop Kizaru for a while, thats all.

Katakuri / Alber depends on the match-up.

 

[Wh1p]

Favourites:
Zoro
Mihawk
King
Katakuri
Sabo
Marco
Shiryu
Ben

I mainly rank Shiryu and Ben at the bottom because their character's are the least explored so far. Zoro at the top for obvious reasons.

Strength:
Mihawk
Ben
Shiryu
Zoro
Sabo
Marco
King
Katakuri

Mihawk at the top of course since he's practically the Yonko of Cross Guild. Not sure if Shiryu has or will surpass Ben but he should be above Zoro at the very least. Sabo and Zoro are interchangable but giving it to Zoro for now since he actually defeated a FM. The rest are interchangable but I put Kat last even though he's a badass because he's a victim of powercreep.

 

[DonWick]

Favorite Power Scaling
1. Zoro. 1. Mihawk
2. Sabo 2. Ben
3. Katakuri. 3. Sabo
4. Ben 4. Marco
5. Mihawk. 5. Katakuri
6. Shiryu. 6. Shiryu
7. Marco 7. Zoro
8. King. 8. King

 

[SakazOuki]

Favorites
Beckman
Shiryu
Zoro
Mihawk
Katakuri
Marco
Sabo
King

Strength
Mihawk
Beckman
Zoro
Sabo
Shiryu
Katakuri
Marco
King

 

[El Pekor]

Crocodile fits the first commander spot more than Mihawk in terms of power scaling but it's ok I'll rank both. I'll put Kuzan as well.

Strength right now:
Mihawk
Kuzan
Sabo
Crocodile
Shiryu
Beckman
Zoro
Marco
Katakuri
King

Down the line Sabo and Zoro will top this list

 

[Mr.Baj1o]

Crocodile fits the first commander spot more than Mihawk in terms of power scaling but it's ok I'll rank both. I'll put Kuzan as well.

Strength right now:
Mihawk
Kuzan
Sabo
Crocodile
Shiryu
Beckman
Zoro
Marco
Katakuri
King

What kind of Piece are you watching/reading if i may kindly ask?

 

[Cozy Sofa]

Power scaling

Mihawk
--
Sabo
Beckmann
--
Zoro
King
--
Marco
Katakuri
Shiryu

I think almost every character on the list can give the rest at least hard diff if not extreme or victory. Shiryu is so low because we've hardly seen him fight but I expect him to be between Sabo and Beckmann.

 

[El Pekor]

What kind of Piece are you watching/reading if i may kindly ask?

There's nothing shocking about my list it's the most basic shit ever no hot takes here but I can explain some of my choices if there's confusion somehow

 

[Buggy D Clown]

Power Scaling:
Mihawk
Zoro
Shiryu/King
Beckman
Marco
Katakuri
Sabo

 

[Rurushu]

Favorites:
Zoro
Katakuri
Sabo
Mihawk
Shiryu
King
Marco
Beckman

Strength:
Mihawk
Beckman/Zoro
Zoro/Beckman
Sabo
King/Kata/Marco
Shiryu

 

[drumming_seawizard]

strength:
whitebeard
mihawk
beckman
sabo
shiryu
zoro
king
marco
katakuri

favorites:
whitebeard
beckman
sabo
zoro
marco
katakuri
mihawk
king
shiryu

 

[Lor D. Coast]

Haki monsters on top (CoC coating)> the invincible bird duo > others
I'll wait for confirmation that Shuryu's awakening is based on nothingness to scale him.

 

[Erkan12]

. Shiryu is so low because we've hardly seen him fight but I expect him to be between Sabo and Beckmann.

Lmao if this is your reasoning then Beckman and Mihawk has less fights than Shiryu yet you put them above.

You must be thinking Mihawk's incredible battle vs. Vista and Beckman's legendary duel vs. Mountain Bandits puts them above Shiryu.

 

[MonsterKaido]

Favs --

--King
--Pre skip zoro
--Post skip zoro

--Katakuri
--Marco/Mihawk
--Shiryu
--Beck

--Sabo

Strength wise --

--Mihawk
--Zoro
--Benn*
--King
--Kata
--Marco
--Labo

 

[RoronoaZorro]

Don't forget guys, Beck cuts Kidd's arm, and we know how beastly Kidd's def/dura is

 

[TheKnightOfTheSea]

Power scaling:

Mihawk
Sabo
Shiryu
Zoro
Beckmen
King
Katakuri
Marco

Likeability:
Shiryu
Zoro
Mihawk

Katakuri
King

Marco
Beckmen

Sabo

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

Favorites:

1. King the Wildfire
2. Roronoa Zoro
3. Ame no Shiryu
4. Marco the Phoenix
5. Katakuri
6. Mihawk
7. Sabo
8. Ben Beckman

Strength:

1. Mihawk
2. Sabo
3. Ame no Shiryu
4. Roronoa Zoro
5. Ben Beckman
6. King the Wildfire
7. Marco the Phoenix
8. Katakuri

 

[IsaziSempi]

Favorite
Katakuri
rayleigh
Marco
Sabo
Beck

The rest don't matter