Multiverse General Who is the better older brother?

[HA001]

Itachi saved sasukes life.

Ace left luffy about to die to akainu ANYWAY and needed others to step in.

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

Wdym by “could’ve”? The idiot basically did that

Ace was so ego driven lol. He couldn’t tolerate anyone disrespecting Whitebeard because of what Whitebeard meant to him and this juvenile stupidity almost got Luffy killed.

Absolute opposite of what Itachi did.

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

Still better than what Sasuke had in Konoha being alone, resentful and full of hate

Imagine Naruto wasn’t around to ease Sasuke a little what would have happened for him ? Only a dark path

A stable life and a shot at happiness versus a life with his missing nin brother, being heirs to coveted bloodlines….

 

[Sir Yasheen]

Ace was so ego driven lol. He couldn’t tolerate anyone disrespecting Whitebeard because of what Whitebeard meant to him and this juvenile stupidity almost got Luffy killed.

Absolute opposite of what Itachi did.

Ace was so hot headed it’s nuts. Sabo is a way better brother.

 

[Roo]

he did it to save luffy i meant it if he did for no reason.

He wouldn’t have had to save Luffy if he had an ounce of reason in his head.

 

[Peroroncino]

He wouldn’t have had to save Luffy if he had an ounce of reason in his head.

unlike itachi, ace had no way of knowing how the situation would end up.

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

Yeah, and that was the point when every normal character would go up in arms with his family. Cause they have a better chance of survival against random ass shinobi after being warned, than a surprise night butchering by two of their strongest clansmen.

Itachi is just shit

They would’ve been crushed regardless though. The Uchiha clan didn’t have the numbers or the strength to compete with Konoha. You have Hiruzen, Danzo, Jiraiya and potentially Orochimaru at this point in time.

the best case scenario for them in a war is doing more damage to Konoha, making it easier for foreign powers to invade.

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

look at that, if itachi tried to talk things out he would have the 3rd hokage on his side

He specifically bought time for Hiruzen to talk it out lmao

 

[Natalija]

They would’ve been crushed regardless though. The Uchiha clan didn’t have the numbers or the strength to compete with Konoha. You have Hiruzen, Danzo, Jiraiya and potentially Orochimaru at this point in time.

the best case scenario for them in a war is doing more damage to Konoha, making it easier for foreign powers to invade.

There's no proof of them being crushed. Danzo wanted a coup in the first place BECAUSE they were afraid of a Uchiha rebellion.

 

[HA001]

Ace was so ego driven lol. He couldn’t tolerate anyone disrespecting Whitebeard because of what Whitebeard meant to him and this juvenile stupidity almost got Luffy killed.

Absolute opposite of what Itachi did.

Now I'm thinking of alternative timeline where luffy dies in marineford
Ace takes over his dream thus doing what wb wanted of him and leads the strawhats make the wb pirates disband anyway
Can still be sun god with an awakened fire fruit

 

[Roo]

unlike itachi, ace had no way of knowing how the situation would end up.

Oh yeah, let me step up to fight the strongest marine. Totally not a chance of backfiring

 

[Natalija]

All in all, Danzo manipulated those clowns to get what he wanted.

 

[Sir Yasheen]

unlike itachi, ace had no way of knowing how the situation would end up.

Ace got his handed to him by Blackbeard and you think he thought he’d have a chance against Akainu?

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

There's no proof of them being crushed. Danzo wanted a coup in the first place BECAUSE they were afraid of a Uchiha rebellion.

Yes there is—Danzo asserts as much.

The Uchiha can do great damage and destabilize the village but never is it suggested they would win. The danger of the revolt is always the consequences of it, weakening Konoha to its neighbors.

 

[Natalija]

Ace was so ego driven lol. He couldn’t tolerate anyone disrespecting Whitebeard because of what Whitebeard meant to him and this juvenile stupidity almost got Luffy killed.

Absolute opposite of what Itachi did.

His pride was his downfall, but in the end he still gave up his life like it was nothing to save Luffy from his death.

 

[Natalija]

Yes there is—Danzo asserts as much.

The Uchiha can do great damage and destabilize the village but never is it suggested they would win. The danger of the revolt is always the consequences of it, weakening Konoha to its neighbors.

Yeah, Danzo the manipulator uses an ultimatum on Itachi, that doesn't make it absolute. The Uchiha would only start a rebellion cause they'd know they had a shot, otherwise what's the point?

Eyeless Danzo and old Hiruzen can't stop them.

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

His pride was his downfall, but in the end he still gave up his life like it was nothing to save Luffy from his death.

Yup. It’s disgusting be risked his brothers life over his own ego, a consistent problem since his youth.

 

[Sir Yasheen]

His pride was his downfall, but in the end he still gave up his life like it was nothing to save Luffy from his death.

It wasn’t pride. It was Ace choosing Whitebeards reputation over Luffys life and sacrifices.

Nothing wrong with that, but Ace showed there he was more of a son of Whitebeard than brother to Luffy.

 

[Natalija]

Yup. It’s disgusting be risked his brothers life over his own ego, a consistent problem since his youth.

Lol he was 20, show me any guy who isn't prideful?

Beats Itachi anytime, you know the emotionless dude who killed his whole family.

 

[Roo]

Ace would get his entire family killed if it meant defending WB’s honor