Multiverse General Who is the better older brother?

[Roo]

eh no

ace acted for his friend

itachi acted for his selfish love

Ace was being selfish as well. Again, WB told him to leave Teach alone. WB was Thatch adoptive father and knew him for way longer. Ace did not consider this in his thought process.

His hubris lead to the MF war, the death of his father, several siblings and the mental traumatization of his brother

 

[AL sama]

what makes it worse is itachi knew the outcome from the get

ace had no way of knowing that BB would sell him to th marines

 

[Peroroncino]

Not as alone as he was in Konoha though. Itachi could care for him.

And he became rogue on his own laters anyways

super genius with advance thinking never thought sasuke would want vengeance

 

[RayanOO]

That’s not a real solution though, Itachi knows if he does that, Konoha is greatly diminished and open to new wars.

Running away with Sasuke.. just to see the world erupt in war while being hunted by Konoha.

Yeah maybe Itachi did the best for the village (short term)

but he didn’t do what was best for his little brother

 

[Roo]

Ace told WB to not save him, he can't be hold responsible for that.

Itachi killing entire clan and only leaving Sasuke behind can't be comparable, Sasuke turned into revenge crazy psycho as a result of that lmao. He should've either kill all or not.

WB told Ace to leave Teach alone

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

That just makes him prioritize the village instead of his own family. Which makes him a shit brother (not to mention son).

He put Sasuke in the best situation he could’ve, canonically, with what he had to work with.

No wars
No hatred against the uchiha
More importantly, safety.
More than his parents did for Sasuke

 

[Erkan12]

Ace was being selfish as well. Again, WB told him to leave Teach alone. WB was Thatch adoptive father and knew him for way longer. Ace did not consider this in his thought process.

His hubris lead to the MF war, the death of his father, several siblings and the mental traumatization of his brother

Ace only lived so far because he wanted to live the way he lives freely.

If Ace told WB, or Luffy to save him, then he would be selfish but Ace specifically told them to not save him even told Garp to kill him before. They still did it, its not Ace's fault they decided to save him.

 

[Roo]

He put Sasuke in the best situation he could’ve, canonically, with what he had to work with.

No wars
No hatred against the uchiha
More importantly, safety.
More than his parents did for Sasuke

His plan also almost worked. Sasuke was going to go back to the village as a hero if not for Obito

Post automatically merged: Apr 12, 2024

Ace only lived so far because he wanted to live the way he lives freely.

Yeah, this is literally called being selfish. Having 0 considerations for the those around you

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

His plan also almost worked. Sasuke was going to go back to the village as a hero if not for Obito

Itachi literally dedicated himself to making sure his fathers idiocy didn’t end Sasuke’s life…

Yet some punk who has no sense of gratitude at being rescued is beating him in the polls 😂😂

 

[Natalija]

He put Sasuke in the best situation he could’ve, canonically, with what he had to work with.

No wars
No hatred against the uchiha
More importantly, safety.
More than his parents did for Sasuke

What are you talking about? Sasuke had a happy life until Itachi killed everyone

 

[Erkan12]

WB told Ace to leave Teach alone

WB also knew Ace wouldn't want to be saved so he decided to lie about it later:

So you can't hold Ace responsible after WB decided to lie about this.

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

He didn’t risk Luffy’s life

Luffy almost died because Ace turned back to fight Akainu

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

What are you talking about? Sasuke had a happy life until Itachi killed everyone

And if Itachi didn’t kill everyone, Sasuke would’ve died.

 

[Natalija]

And if Itachi didn’t kill everyone, Sasuke would’ve died.

No, that's just what Danzo used for emotional blackmail.

 

[TheAncientCenturion]

No, that's just what Danzo used for emotional blackmail.

No, that’s reality. The Uchiha clan will be defeated in their coup, Sasuke will die. There’s no one contradicting this in the manga:

 

[Erkan12]

Yeah, this is literally called being selfish. Having 0 considerations for the those around you

Its not selfish if you told them don't interfere before, WB had to lie about it why he is saving Ace.

 

[Roo]

WB also knew Ace wouldn't want to be saved so he decided to lie about it later:

So you can't hold Ace responsible after WB decided to lie about this.

WHAT? I can definitely hold Ace responsible. If my kid does something messed up but I cover for them as a duty of being a parent, the kid definitely holds some responsibility for what they did

WB being a good father doesn’t take away from Ace being a selfish idiot

 

[Luffy is the mc]

Itachi was a cool character but a shitty brother. He achieved the exact opposite of what he wanted and had to rely on Naruto to save his stupid brother.
Ace was a good brother, he protected Luffy whenever he could and even died saving him. He tried to tell Luffy to stay out of MF because he was afraid for him.

 

[Adeer Ruckus]

Luffy almost died because Ace turned back to fight Akainu

Luffy went back for the vice card on his own accord

 

[Roo]

Its not selfish if you told them don't interfere before,

nah, it is selfish. If I do something after people telling me not to do it, just because I told them to interfere doesn’t mean I didnt do it for my own selfish reasons