Anime & Manga One Piece Spoilers - The Wailing Room

Garps tekkai

Garps tekkai

‎
#294,461
#294,461
I think we might get ourselves a rough timeline, cause 1. Vegapunk does not know much, so we lack info for a detailed FB and 2. Redon's "200" hint makes it seems like that incident from 200years ago is likely included.

And if that underwater city hint means what it means, then the void century plot is likely very similar to the openining plot of the Atlantis Disney movie.
I think Laughtale is going to be additionally guarded by a gigantic mecha sea beast weapon
 
D

Dragon777

‎
#294,463
#294,463
Sir Yasheen said:
Yeah God Valley got retconned to being Shanks’ hometown. If Oda didn’t want there to be a connection he just would’ve made shanks be born somewhere else
Click to expand...
We actually don't know if Shanks was born there, we just saw him as a baby there. As far as I know, at least.

But anyway, Oda tought of GV and Shanks and surely It has not even crossed his mind to change his big plot for some irrilevant phrase said in chapter 434. He did way worse with Nika, let alone this.
 
Warine

Warine

‎
#294,467
#294,467
Etzel Andergast said:
The planet is Imu himself, he ate the planet planet fruit
Click to expand...
Glorified pizzaro, not my final villain:gonope:
Post automatically merged:

Dragon777 said:
Seriously doubt It, but anything Is possible.
Click to expand...
He stated multiple time the story was supposed to be way shorter, initially they were just the 4 emperors, we also got the gold and oden ost like 25 years ago tol
 
Sir Yasheen

Sir Yasheen

‎
#294,468
#294,468
Dragon777 said:
We actually don't know if Shanks was born there, we just saw him as a baby there. As far as I know, at least.

But anyway, Oda tought of GV and Shanks and surely It has not even crossed his mind to change his big plot for some irrilevant phrase said in chapter 434. He did way worse with Nika, let alone this.
Click to expand...
We are told shanks has a Celestial Dragon heritage and was born in the West Blue and was found on God Valley as a baby. Oda isn’t keeping Shanks’ hometown a secret.

And none of what Shanks said was irrelevant god valley disappeared from the west blue. But it still exists. We can’t just ignore the canon of it.
 
D

Dragon777

‎
#294,475
#294,475
Sir Yasheen said:
We are told shanks has a Celestial Dragon heritage and was born in the West Blue and was found on God Valley as a baby. Oda isn’t keeping Shanks’ hometown a secret.
Click to expand...
Ok, but so It was like that. We Indeed have no confirmation GV was his birthpalce. It could be, but could not.
Oda could actually save It that way.

And none of what Shanks said was irrelevant god valley disappeared from the west blue. But it still exists. We can’t just ignore the canon of it.
Click to expand...
It's the peak of irrilevance honestly. As I said, Oda did way, way worse with Nika so it's really reaching trying to come up with conclusions using some completely secondary phrase about a liquor that Shanks said 500 chapters before Oda had probably come up with the idea.

Obviously free to think otherwise, but don't be flabbergasted why others don't.

Also, since this discussion went this far, I might as well saying that what you are referring to Is not even the actual/present translation (if what you were referring to was the first phrase):



"In the Place I grew up"

That further confirms GV hasn't anything to do with It, because obviously Shanks' story was different back then. Also, GV's population was likely killed so no one should remember how to make their wine.
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top