Role Madness NieR: Automata Mafia Game Thread [Game State: Night 5]

[Butterscotch Sundae]

Why aren't you just ISO'ing the players in question?

Reading the entire game over again kinda seems performative, you're opting to do this over answering questions and all you're really concluding is "yeah these players with 10 or less posts seem scummy.". Woah real innovative stuff.

Two reasons:

1) I find ISOs of limited utility when the thread is relatively short. Posts in context tend to reveal more.
2) I've never played on this site before and don't know how to iso yet.

And bonus third reason:

3) Because it gives me time for my blood pressure to return to normal after interacting with you which I find intensely irritating.

 

[Charlie]

Town reading Red Knight for this callout

i mean, did rn do much tho

flower did enough to get town reads at least

 

[Ultra]

Two reasons:

1) I find ISOs of limited utility when the thread is relatively short. Posts in context tend to reveal more.
2) I've never played on this site before and don't know how to iso yet.

And bonus third reason:

3) Because it gives me time for my blood pressure to return to normal after interacting with you which I find intensely irritating.

What irritated you? The fact that I caught you, or the fact that I'm too damn handsome for you to do anything about it

 

[Yoho]

oh boo hoo my trip through the isos didn't leave me feeling great

the most filler slots among the unclaimed appear to be hime, random asshole, indigo, yoho, and gadonk. everyone else i took notes on but the notes don't say much.

SEE NOTES BELOW: I THOUGHT THERE WOULD BE A NICER WAY TO POST THEM BUT I DONT SEE IT

Yoho
- asked fushi if they were scum
- tells gadonk they should meme vote Polar for not liking pineapple on pizza
- asks "what's the plan" and "how many scum?" a couple of times
- votes the miller(?) claim York


T-Pein
although it's 3 posts i think the gimmick is hilarious. I don't want to vote it today and it's only bc i liked the chicken quesadilla joke

Gadonk
- votes flower
- rest is memeing

Yo tan Wa
- says all machines are bad
- tries to solve factions via nier automata lore. idk if scum would put in the effort since they probably(?) know who the bad guys and good guys are(?)
- rest is memes

alwaysmind
- mostly filler posts and misunderstanding
- votes flower
- says butter was opportunistic (i think?) for voting flower after being convinced flower is town
- implies polar is butter's partner and is trying to shift the wagon elsewhere

hmm. i see the progression from flower to butter, and sort of from butter to polar, but it could be another misunderstanding as to why alwaysmind thought polar was trying to shift wagons may be yet another misunderstanding


orca
-votes alwaysmind when he only had 2 posts.
-asks who crying cryo is
-continues pushing for alwaysmind and gives many many different reasons
-trs flower and crying
-asks Ultra for opinions on ppl
-is now pushing alwaysmind and sundae

idk i don't like how orca is deathtunneling alwaysmind. the reasons given are a bit too shakey for orca to have that much of a confident sr on alwaysmind.


polar bear
- doesn't like my gimmick and only signed up bc someone else was supposed to
- then a bunch of memes
- calls out ultra for trying to do a gotcha attempt but the gotcha was actually just a misunderstanding so idk who it looks bad for (polar bear or ultra)
- makes some read lists and tosses some shade on lemon, bs, and gad. for the most part the giant lists seem solvey-ish

random asshole
- he claims to be a lurker and the rest is just filler so idk if im gonna get a good read on the slot

luka
- appears to be solving and they're fun to play with so far. just skimmed their iso cuz nothing really pinged me as bad

indigo
- gets confused by fuji and flower claiming at start
- trs flower charlie and fuji
- says he won't claim but his role is weird
- votes alexis and says they just know Flower isn't the big bad

tbh i don't like the confidence in the reads but it's not the worst.

hime
- it's mostly memes and telling ppl not to claim bc they think this is an assassin setup (multiple factions who don't know their teammates)

Thank you for the recap, I do kinda agree with indigo it is strange people will just suddenly start claiming unprovoked almost as if they planned it in the scum chat

 

[Crying bc no Cryo]

anyway, with Yoho claiming machine that makes 8 machine claims and 3 yorha claims boo hoo

 

[Red Night]

I wonder if i should do Replicant and then Automata

or the other way around

I think you should find a girlfriend first

 

[Charlie]

anyway, with Yoho claiming machine that makes 8 machine claims and 3 yorha claims boo hoo

who are android people? fuji, ytw (saying machines are bad) and who?

 

[Charlie]

oh, york, nvm

 

[Polar Bear]

Why is Butter's a low hanging fruit? Kind of an odd thing to say.

Really?? I'd say outside of your attempt to shade my joke post, Sundae is the lowest of hanging fruit. Your 2 pushes have been based on a pure joke post (me) and Sundae for going at flower. In fact, from that moment on, Sundae has been the LHF within the thread.

I'll go back to that post and see who all just go for it as it hit the thread in the head.

Now on the flip side, I do feel Sundae is going at the LHF Flower, but it's kinda what I'd expect from her, definitely not from you

 

[Butterscotch Sundae]

So, Random Asshole has done precisely nothing and appeared in the thread at pretty much random times just to demonstrate that they remember how to post. Really unimpressive and I see nothing to have any opinion on or that will help anyone formulate an opinion of me unless I'm missing something. I can only conclude that they were put on the list with Alwaysmind and hime to form the magic number of three players.

Given that, I'd say that of the three, they are the most likely wolf if the person that gave me the list flips wolf. It looks like that player is Charlie, so I suggest watching for other signs that the two of them may be paired.

Alwaysmind is kind of playing up the "nobody is interested in solving me" a little bit in a couple of their posts, which players tend to be more likely to do as villagers than as wolves, in my experience. Leaning village.

Hime I don't have a villager/wolf read on, but of the three so far they are the most fun to play with and I'd rather keep them around than not just for that reason, at least for today.

 

[Ultra]

Really?? I'd say outside of your attempt to shade my joke post, Sundae is the lowest of hanging fruit. Your 2 pushes have been based on a pure joke post (me) and Sundae for going at flower. In fact, from that moment on, Sundae has been the LHF within the thread.

I'll go back to that post and see who all just go for it as it hit the thread in the head.

Now on the flip side, I do feel Sundae is going at the LHF Flower, but it's kinda what I'd expect from her, definitely not from you

Hey genius if I started the wagon you can't accuse me of going after low hanging fruit. Nobody was going after her before

 

[Polar Bear]

i mean, he's in green

i'm in orange

:o

so like, from my pov fairly is valid word to use here

I guess I should make the reads list clearer for you, give me a sec, will do after checking out the start of the flower stuff

 

[Ultra]

Hime I don't have a villager/wolf read on, but of the three so far they are the most fun to play with and I'd rather keep them around than not just for that reason, at least for today.

Over an hour and you still haven't explained this

 

[Polar Bear]

Hey genius if I started the wagon you can't accuse me of going after low hanging fruit. Nobody was going after her before

Hey genius, low hanging fruit to me means easy target and based on the thread and posts, she was an easy target. It doesn't mean following someone else on an easy target

 

[Ultra]

Hey genius, low hanging fruit to me means easy target and based on the thread and posts, she was an easy target. It doesn't mean following someone else on an easy target

And why would she be an "easy target"? As opposed to, say, Alwaysmind?

 

[Crying bc no Cryo]

who are android people? fuji, ytw (saying machines are bad) and who?

oh ig there's 4 yorha claims cuz bs claimed yorha too

 

[The Orca]

He's been trying to shift the wagon elsewhere too, kinda weird if you ask me.

Do explain

thoughts on Buttersquash?

Definitely a current suspect and a main one at that. Some things I didn't like are the posts around Flower and the continued pushed of Flower. The reasoning seems fake to begin with and the subsequent expanding was very eye catching for me. Calling what Flower did, saying she wouldn't be around at the start of the game, wolfing is a bit too much of throwing stuff at a wall and seeing what sticks. Its NAI and can mean many things, now Flower not actually being missing and still posting could mean something deeper, but on this day and at the start of the game it doesn't feel scummy at all imo. Now if she had pressure or was being lynched I could see it in a scummy light. Just continues the fakness or forced nature of her pushes.

Now I do like some of her thoughts, so I'm not fully on board to lynch her, and I really like how she is still going about her way solving

 

[The Orca]

oh ig there's 4 yorha claims cuz bs claimed yorha too

I think that is a plus for Sundae. As scum, probably easier to hide in the larger pile

 

[Butterscotch Sundae]

The rules SPECIFICALLY SAID to paraphrase. "What exactly" is NOT a paraphrase and I will die on this hill. If you think that makes me a hostile, lynch me or stfu.

I also find it informative that shortly after I said this to Fuji, Ultra started trying in earnest to yeet me.

Possible world:

Wolf:
Fuji
Ultra
Luka (based on the fact that it's unlikely an entire wolf team would accuse one player, and Luka had already defended me but appears to have largely dropped that)

Which would mean probable village:
Flower
Indigo

Other possible world:

Wolf
Charlie
Random Asshole

Not sure if a wolf team of Fuji, Ultra, Luka, Charlie, Random Asshole would make sense. I kind of feel like it wouldn't--that there would be at least one more under the radar wolf in place of the more active posters.

 

[Polar Bear]

Just some quotes from the period im reviewing that were interesting

Sundae probably villager

He asked her for wincon and flavor. At no point did he demand she "copy and paste wincon verbatim"

Kinda shameless to use this angle, try and play the game cleanly and honestly 🙏

boo hoo how do u know they didn't just paraphrase the whole time tho? it seemed like a very short wincon to not be paraphrased boo hoo hoo

Pretty close to unacceptable gameplay, in my opinion. Regardless, it's my vote and until I find a better home for it, I'm plopping it on Fujishiro.

BS are you a robot or a yorha? boo hoo hoo

What's your wincon

What's yours?

I stand proudly alongside humanity and am tirelessly loyal to the YoRHa cause.

No