Role Madness NieR: Automata Mafia Game Thread [Game State: Day 5]

[Charlie]

You mean Rust Status?

Yeah. I mean, idk what that is but i assume it's negative. If it's something like poison, i guess it would make sense if we had some role to counter it

 

[Ultra]

@Flower you scum or something

you're too quiet...

 

[Ultra]

Vote lynch Butter

 

[Flower]

@Flower you scum or something

you're too quiet...

Bro I'm literally at work.

 

[Charlie]

Yeah.
BS was the first to claim yorha and i don't think their role is a scum role (although it's not great if scum have fakeclaims), but also I still think BS's arguments could come from town.

AM has been misunderstanding ppl all game so it makes me think theyre just doing it on accident instead of deliberately misunderstanding ppl all game

and apparently Gad is the world's easiest vote and get voted out 90% of their games

plus with how scattered the votes are rn and how i think ultra vs bs is town vs town violence

yeah i wouldnt say scum is entiely afk but it's probably the case that most of them are given that i've seen like 3 or 4 other games go like this recently only for top wagons to be pure and on 2 towns

Didn't Fuji claim android like, on page 2?

Thing with bs that really bugs me is how he listed flower as Town after tunneling her for like half of dp. Idk how to rationalize it.

AM i could see pretending to be confused tbh.

Gad is random af. Like i said, he's no different than any other inactive. I mean of course this could be scum but like, if it's Town we've learned nothing from that Lynch.

 

[Charlie]

she

 

[Charlie]

So like, it's basically BS, Gad or noone since we need 12 people

 

[The Orca]

Didn't Fuji claim android like, on page 2?

Thing with bs that really bugs me is how he listed flower as Town after tunneling her for like half of dp. Idk how to rationalize it.

AM i could see pretending to be confused tbh.

Gad is random af. Like i said, he's no different than any other inactive. I mean of course this could be scum but like, if it's Town we've learned nothing from that Lynch.

Im an android lol.

 

[Crying bc no Cryo]

Didn't Fuji claim android like, on page 2?

Thing with bs that really bugs me is how he listed flower as Town after tunneling her for like half of dp. Idk how to rationalize it.

AM i could see pretending to be confused tbh.

Gad is random af. Like i said, he's no different than any other inactive. I mean of course this could be scum but like, if it's Town we've learned nothing from that Lynch.

idk

BS is a doc-ish claim and i have a gut feeling that however contradictory their reads seem that it comes from a towny place and not from malice. i also think at this point if BS is scum then they wouldve been coached better than this / informed on ppl better than this

the rest i dont know either i feel lost boo hoo

 

[Charlie]

idk

BS is a doc-ish claim and i have a gut feeling that however contradictory their reads seem that it comes from a towny place and not from malice. i also think at this point if BS is scum then they wouldve been coached better than this / informed on ppl better than this

the rest i dont know either i feel lost boo hoo

I mean, scum has fake roles. So if it's not straight up doctor, i could see it being fake.

Tbh i don't think it's great Lynch, but it's better than lynching at random what gad is tbh

 

[Crying bc no Cryo]

vote lynch gadonkadonk

sorry i just dont think BS is a hit

 

[Alwaysmind]

Didn't Fuji claim android like, on page 2?

Thing with bs that really bugs me is how he listed flower as Town after tunneling her for like half of dp. Idk how to rationalize it.

AM i could see pretending to be confused tbh.

Gad is random af. Like i said, he's no different than any other inactive. I mean of course this could be scum but like, if it's Town we've learned nothing from that Lynch.

No, ultra has also been considered, and so was Flower.

We should form a tv show and call ourselves the Confused Bunch.

 

[Alwaysmind]

vote lynch gadonkadonk

sorry i just dont think BS is a hit

Bullshit usually isn’t a hit, so I’d agree with you on that one.

 

[Butterscotch Sundae]

@Butterscotch Sundae

Ia your role connected to "rust" in any way perhaps?

It's a bit broader than that but I suspect that would fall under my purview, yes.

 

[KWEH]

Day 1 - Vote Count 6

​

Votes:
Flower -> Ultra > Ultra > Alexis > Butter
Ultra -> Hime > Yo Tan > Butter
Hime -> Fuji > Flower > Butter
Kweh -> Hime > Butter
Butter -> Flower > Flower > Ultra > RA > Ultra > Gad
Orca -> AM > Gad
Fuji -> Fuji > Gad > AM > Gad > Flower > Gad > AM > Gad
Crying -> Butter > Unvote > Gad > RA > Gad > Unvote > Yoho
Luka -> Yo Tan
Yoho -> York
Gad -> Flower
Charlie -> Hime
Lemon -> Pot > Alexis > Yoho
Indigo -> Alexis > Butter
AM -> Flower > Unvote > Butter
Polar -> Ultra
York -> Butter
Alexis -> Gad
T-pein -> Flower > Butter
RN -> Butter


Count:
Butter = 8 (Flower, Hime, AM, Indigo, York, Kweh, RN, T-pein)
Gad = 5 (Fuji, Orca, Alexis, Butter, Ultra)
Yoho = 2 (Crying, Lemon)
Ultra = 1 (Polar)
Flower = 1 (Gad)
Yo Tan = 1 (Luka)
York = 1 (Yoho)
Hime = 0 (Charlie)

Not Voting = 3 (Yo Tan, RA, Pot)

Please let me know if I made any mistakes.

With 23 alive, it's 12 votes required to achieve majority.
Day 1 ends in a little less than 3 hrs.

Countdown
​

Spoiler: Player List

Living Players [23/23]

1. @Yoho
2. @Alexis2282AE
3. @Fujishiro
4. @Yo Tan Wa
5. @Alwaysmind
6. @York
7. @The Orca
8. @Polar Bear
9. @Flower
10. @Red Night
11. @KWEH
12. @Random Asshole
13. @Charlie
14. @Pot Goblin
15. @Ultra
16. @Luka
17. @Butterscotch Sundae
18. @Indigo
19. @lemon.de
20. @T-Pein™
21. @Crying bc no Cryo
22. @Gadonkadonk
23. @hime

Dead Players [0/23]

Subs

1. @Lord Melkor
2. @Rej
3. @tepig19283
4. @Worst
5. @Ratchet
6. @Orwellian

ayy lmao Butter and Ultra are voting the same guy

 

[KWEH]

Honestly I'm not sure Flower would bet everything on a machine fake claim, her introduction seemed real and not faked.

Who was the second person who claimed to be a good machine after Flower. I don't remember who it was, but I think they probably are townie. For the others who claimed Good machine, I think we should treat every case one by one.

This guy analyzing stuff that happened 60 pages ago smh

 

[Charlie]

It's a bit broader than that but I suspect that would fall under my purview, yes.

Kinda vague af .-. is this word mentioned?

 

[Alwaysmind]

Day 1 - Vote Count 6

​

Votes:
Flower -> Ultra > Ultra > Alexis > Butter
Ultra -> Hime > Yo Tan > Butter
Hime -> Fuji > Flower > Butter
Kweh -> Hime > Butter
Butter -> Flower > Flower > Ultra > RA > Ultra > Gad
Orca -> AM > Gad
Fuji -> Fuji > Gad > AM > Gad > Flower > Gad > AM > Gad
Crying -> Butter > Unvote > Gad > RA > Gad > Unvote > Yoho
Luka -> Yo Tan
Yoho -> York
Gad -> Flower
Charlie -> Hime
Lemon -> Pot > Alexis > Yoho
Indigo -> Alexis > Butter
AM -> Flower > Unvote > Butter
Polar -> Ultra
York -> Butter
Alexis -> Gad
T-pein -> Flower > Butter
RN -> Butter


Count:
Butter = 8 (Flower, Hime, AM, Indigo, York, Kweh, RN, T-pein)
Gad = 5 (Fuji, Orca, Alexis, Butter, Ultra)
Yoho = 2 (Crying, Lemon)
Ultra = 1 (Polar)
Flower = 1 (Gad)
Yo Tan = 1 (Luka)
York = 1 (Yoho)
Hime = 0 (Charlie)

Not Voting = 3 (Yo Tan, RA, Pot)

Please let me know if I made any mistakes.

With 23 alive, it's 12 votes required to achieve majority.
Day 1 ends in a little less than 3 hrs.

Countdown
​

Spoiler: Player List

Living Players [23/23]

1. @Yoho
2. @Alexis2282AE
3. @Fujishiro
4. @Yo Tan Wa
5. @Alwaysmind
6. @York
7. @The Orca
8. @Polar Bear
9. @Flower
10. @Red Night
11. @KWEH
12. @Random Asshole
13. @Charlie
14. @Pot Goblin
15. @Ultra
16. @Luka
17. @Butterscotch Sundae
18. @Indigo
19. @lemon.de
20. @T-Pein™
21. @Crying bc no Cryo
22. @Gadonkadonk
23. @hime

Dead Players [0/23]

Subs

1. @Lord Melkor
2. @Rej
3. @tepig19283
4. @Worst
5. @Ratchet
6. @Orwellian

Charley having no voting power

 

[Ultra]

ayy lmao Butter and Ultra are voting the same guy

Just wanted to see what would happen

Think I just wanna get rid of her tho

 

[Alwaysmind]

Not Voting = 3 (Yo Tan, RA, Pot)

sus….very sus.