Role Madness NieR: Automata Mafia Game Thread [Game State: Game End - Indie Victory]

[Yoho]

Vote Lynch KWEH

Best option for today imo

 

[hime]

the thing i cant really wrap my head around is the fact that in order to believe kweh's claim, purple machines would have to have 2 protective roles with an additional x-shot commuter?

my role is every odd cycle and ultra was 6 shot
it feels like a lot tbh

 

[KWEH]

only u and RA can visit ppl tonight tho
if the mark on me is real, im pretty much guaranteed to die since u r commuting

Let's pretend I commute and you don't die then. In that case I'm confirmed to be the real target of the death mark which oughta automatically clear me

Generally speaking I think the two of us oughta be off limits today because of the death mark.

 

[Yoho]

the thing i cant really wrap my head around is the fact that in order to believe kweh's claim, purple machines would have to have 2 protective roles with an additional x-shot commuter?

my role is every odd cycle and ultra was 6 shot
it feels like a lot tbh

Whose currently on your suspect list?

 

[hime]

Whose currently on your suspect list?

u and kweh

 

[hime]

Let's pretend I commute and you don't die then. In that case I'm confirmed to be the real target of the death mark which oughta automatically clear me

Generally speaking I think the two of us oughta be off limits today because of the death mark.

u said u commuted but didnt use ur rust protect role bc u didnt know what rust is?
or was it a diff reason?

 

[KWEH]

the thing i cant really wrap my head around is the fact that in order to believe kweh's claim, purple machines would have to have 2 protective roles with an additional x-shot commuter?

my role is every odd cycle and ultra was 6 shot
it feels like a lot tbh

Evidently we have no vig and no cop, was that something that was on your bingo card for this game? You shouldn't try to apply conventional ideas of balance to this setup imo.

 

[Yoho]

u and kweh

And between the two of us, which one of us seems like they'd be more dangerous if they are scum and don't get taken out?

 

[hime]

Evidently we have no vig and no cop, was that something that was on your bingo card for this game? You shouldn't try to apply conventional ideas of balance to this setup imo.

i thought crying was our vig?

 

[KWEH]

u said u commuted but didnt use ur rust protect role bc u didnt know what rust is?
or was it a diff reason?

I said at first I didn't know what rust was supposed to be since I myself don't rust (flavor says I'm capable of self-maintenance). Then come n1 I figured I was mostly town read so chances are I might get killed, therefore I went with the commute. Then n2 I went with the derust stuff on a machine claim I thought was likely town

 

[KWEH]

i thought crying was our vig?

He can kill people under some circumstances but it's nowhere near a straightforward vig. I'd sooner accept the duelist to be our vig tbh.

 

[hime]

I said at first I didn't know what rust was supposed to be since I myself don't rust (flavor says I'm capable of self-maintenance). Then come n1 I figured I was mostly town read so chances are I might get killed, therefore I went with the commute. Then n2 I went with the derust stuff on a machine claim I thought was likely town

y didnt u do anything np3?
also how did u not know what rust was when u even talked abt rust protection dp1?

 

[Crying bc no Cryo]

There's no big ole case, I merely have no reason to town read him and also think he's currently trying to throw whatever he can against the wall and hope something sticks

I mean it’s LYLO potentially right? Surely there’s more of a case right?

 

[KWEH]

Well if you can make yourself immune to it then you can very well still be scum, they give you the real one knowing you can be immune and then we waste resources on Hime who wasn't in danger in the first place, painting you in a good light thus cementing your town cred

Or vice versa Hime is the scum and whoever set this trap didn't expect you could defend against it

We're 8 players left and I wasn't feeling particularly threatened or in desperate need of town cred until people suddenly decided I'm a leading suspect for today. Why would I go for some sort of gambit that requires me to claim a role nobody knew I had, instead of just trying to net an additional kill? We know people are running out of roles, if I give the marks to two townies it'd be just about impossible for town to save the one with the real mark.

 

[The Orca]

Day 1 - Final Vote Count

​

Votes:
Flower -> Ultra > Ultra > Alexis > Butter > Unvote > Butter
Ultra -> Hime > Yo Tan > Butter
Hime -> Fuji > Flower > Butter
Kweh -> Hime > Butter
Butter -> Flower > Flower > Ultra > RA > Ultra > Gad
Orca -> AM > Gad
Fuji -> Fuji > Gad > AM > Gad > Flower > Gad > AM > Gad
Crying -> Butter > Unvote > Gad > RA > Gad > Unvote > Yoho > YTW > Gad
Luka -> Yo Tan
Yoho -> York
Gad -> Flower
Charlie -> Hime > Butter
Lemon -> Pot > Alexis > Yoho
Indigo -> Alexis > Butter
AM -> Flower > Unvote > Butter
Polar -> Ultra > Gad
York -> Butter
Alexis -> Gad
T-pein -> Flower > Butter
RN -> Butter
YTW -> Ultra
Pot -> Butter
RA -> Butter

Count:
Butter = 12 (Flower, Hime, AM, Indigo, York, Kweh, RN, T-pein, Ultra, Pot, RA, Charlie)
Gad = 5 (Fuji, Orca, Alexis, Crying, Polar)
YTW = 2 (Luka, Crying)
Yoho = 1 (Lemon)
Ultra = 1 (YTW)
Flower = 1 (Gad)
Pot = 1 (Butter)
York = 1 (Yoho)

Not Voting = 0 ( )

Please let me know if I made any mistakes.

Hammer is reached. Everyone please stop posting
​

Spoiler: Player List

Living Players [23/23]

1. @Yoho
2. @Alexis2282AE
3. @Fujishiro
4. @Yo Tan Wa
5. @Alwaysmind
6. @York
7. @The Orca
8. @Polar Bear
9. @Flower
10. @Red Night
11. @KWEH
12. @Random Asshole
13. @Charlie
14. @Pot Goblin
15. @Ultra
16. @Luka
17. @Butterscotch Sundae
18. @Indigo
19. @lemon.de
20. @T-Pein™
21. @Crying bc no Cryo
22. @Gadonkadonk
23. @hime

Dead Players [0/23]

Subs

1. @Lord Melkor
2. @Rej
3. @tepig19283
4. @Worst
5. @Ratchet

Day 2 - Final Vote Count
​

Votes:
Flower -> RA
Ultra -> Pot > Luka
Indigo -> RA > Unvote > YTW > Luka
Orca -> AM > YTW > Luka
Luka -> RA
Kweh -> Luka
Fuji -> YTW > Lemon > Luka > Unvote
YTW -> Ultra
Gad -> Ultra > Lemon > Luka > Lemon
Charlie -> YTW
York -> YTW > Lemon > Luka
T-pein -> Luka > Gad
Crying -> RA
AM -> YTW > Luka
Alexis -> Lemon > Luka
Hime -> Luka
Yoho -> Fuji > Luka
RA -> Luka
Pot -> Yoho
RN -> Luka


Count:
Luka = 11 (Ultra, Kweh, Hime, York, Indigo, RA, Yoho, AM, Orca, Alexis, RN)
RA = 3 (Flower, Luka, Crying)
Lemon = 1 (Gad)
Ultra = 1 (YTW)
YTW = 0 (Charlie)

Not Voting = 2 (RN, Lemon)

Hammer is reached. Day 2 has ended.

Please stop posting.


​

Spoiler: Player List

Living Players [21/23]

1. @Yoho
2. @Alexis2282AE
3. @Fujishiro
4. @Yo Tan Wa
5. @Alwaysmind
6. @York
7. @The Orca
8. @KWEH
9. @Flower
10. @Red Night
11. @Random Asshole
12. @Charlie
13. @Pot Goblin
14. @Ultra
15. @Luka
16. @Indigo
17. @lemon.de
18. @T-Pein™
19. @Crying bc no Cryo
20. @Gadonkadonk
21. @hime

Dead Players [2/23]

1. @Butterscotch Sundae - YoRHA No. 9 Type S (9S) - YoRHa aligned - Lynched Day 1
2. @Polar Bear - Adam - Machine Network aligned - Died Night 1

Subs

1. @Lord Melkor
2. @Rej
3. @tepig19283
4. @Worst
5. @Ratchet
6. @Orwellian

Day 3 - Final Vote Count​

Votes:
Yoho -> Gad
Charlie -> Gad > Pot
Tepig -> Gad > Pot
Crying -> AM > Alexis
Orca -> Tepig > Pot
Kweh -> RA
Ultra -> Flower > Yoho > Pot
Hime -> Pot
Indigo -> Yoho > Pot
Flower -> Pot
RA -> Pot
AM -> Pot


Count:
Pot = 9 (Charlie, Tepig, Hime, Orca, Ultra, Flower, Indigo, RA, AM, Kweh)
Gad = 1 (Yoho)
Alexis = 1 (Crying)
RA = 1 (Kweh)


Sand Trail 3 Kick Out:
Rej = 0
No Kick = 4 (Charlie, Flower, Pot, Orca)


Duel Winner:
Flower = 14 (Tepig, Yoho, Pot, Indigo, Charlie, York, Flower, RA, Crying, Orca, Ultra, Alexis, Kweh, Hime)
Gad = 0

Please let me know if I made any mistakes.

Day 3 has ended. Everyone please stop posting.


​

Spoiler: Player List

Living Players [18/23]

1. @Yoho
2. @Alexis2282AE
3. @Yo Tan Wa
4. @Alwaysmind
5. @York
6. @The Orca
7. @KWEH
8. @Flower
9. @Red Night @tepig19283
10. @Random Asshole
11. @Charlie
12. @Pot Goblin
13. @Ultra
14. @Indigo
15. @T-Pein™ @Rej
16. @Crying bc no Cryo
17. @Gadonkadonk
18. @hime

Dead Players [5/23]

1. @Butterscotch Sundae - YoRHA No. 9 Type S (9S) - YoRHa aligned - Lynched Day 1
2. @Polar Bear - Adam - Machine Network aligned - Died Night 1
3. @Luka - Eve - Machine Network aligned - Lynched Day 2
4. @lemon.de - The Logic Virus - Machine Network aligned - Died Night 2
5. @Fujishiro - ??? - YoRHa aligned - Consumed by Simone Day 3

Subs

1. @Lord Melkor
2. @Worst
3. @Ratchet
4. @Orwellian

Is this vote count accurate with Kweh voting twice? @Emil

Day 4 - Final Vote Count​

Votes:
Yoho -> Flower > Flower > Unvote > AM
Alexis -> Flower > Unvote > AM
Crying -> Alexis > AM
Rej -> Flower > Unvote > AM > Unvote
York -> Yoho
Flower -> Yoho > AM
Orca -> AM
YTW -> AM > Unvote
Indigo -> Yoho
Hime -> Alexis > AM
AM -> Yoho
KWEH -> Yoho
RA -> York


Count:
AM = 7 (Orca, Crying, Alexis, Yoho, Flower, Hime, Indigo)
Yoho = 3 (York, AM, KWEH)
York = 1 (RA)

Day 4 has ended. Please stop posting etc..
​

Spoiler: Player List

Living Players [13/23]

1. @Yoho
2. @Alexis2282AE
3. @Yo Tan Wa
4. @Alwaysmind
5. @York
6. @The Orca
7. @KWEH
8. @Flower
9. @Random Asshole
10. @Indigo
11. @T-Pein™ @Rej
12. @Crying bc no Cryo
13. @hime

Dead Players [10/23]

1. @Butterscotch Sundae - YoRHA No. 9 Type S (9S) - YoRHa aligned - Lynched Day 1
2. @Polar Bear - Adam - Machine Network aligned - Died Night 1
3. @Luka - Eve - Machine Network aligned - Lynched Day 2
4. @lemon.de - The Logic Virus - Machine Network aligned - Died Night 2
5. @Fujishiro - ??? - YoRHa aligned - Consumed by Simone Day 3 - Flipped Day 3: YoRHa No. 6 Type O (6O)
6. @Gadonkadonk - The Network - Machine Network aligned - Dueled out Day 3
7. @Pot Goblin - YoRHa No. 2 Type B (2B) - YoRHa aligned - Executed Day 3
8. @Ultra - Animal Loving Machine - Machine Lifeform aligned - Died Night 3
9. @Charlie - Immanuel - Machine Lifeform aligned - Died Night 3
10. @Red Night @tepig19283 - Plato 1728 - Machine Lifeform aligned - Died Night 3

Subs

1. @Lord Melkor
2. @Worst
3. @Ratchet
4. @Orwellian

 

[KWEH]

@KWEH

Flower says it's just the flavor but I see no reason not to investigate just in case it isn't

I agree it's just flavor. Again, the win condition says to eliminate everyone, not eliminate everyone except for each other.

 

[KWEH]

Vote Lynch KWEH

Best option for today imo

I want everybody to look at this. I'm potentially marked for death; if Hime doesn't die tonight there's a decent chance it's the real mark. There oughta be absolutely no way anybody thinks that lynching me or hime today is the best option available

Like what makes me a better option than say RA for example?

 

[KWEH]

And between the two of us, which one of us seems like they'd be more dangerous if they are scum and don't get taken out?

Good lord what a slimy post

 

[hime]

I have a Rust Status Passive btw. If somebody can cure that would be cool.

For me it is. If I don’t fulfill the condition to unlock my duel by EoD3 I will be a Vanilla afterwards lol.

i'm 99% sure rust apply to every single machine, not just you, so i don't think so

All robots have rust issues this game and I'm guessing its activated via different manners through the passive and does different things to each robot

these r all from day 1

 

[KWEH]

y didnt u do anything np3?
also how did u not know what rust was when u even talked abt rust protection dp1?

I did nothing n3 because I had only one derust shot left and didn't know if there maybe was some decent use for it instead of just throwing it onto some rando machine again