I'm kinda wavering in between "he's making an enemy out of everyone" and "he's doubling down because it's all he can do". Former would be townie. Want to see how certain people play around it first to be honest.
Do I just copy paste the link of this game thread and insert it into ChatGPT and tell it to find the scums among the posters? I wanna try this myself now.
You copied me because ultimately you don't have any original thoughts.
"Misreading hus response" can you and Naomi read the thread before you say anything? It would really help town, you know the team you're supposedly on? Another "OG" who somehow misses things said in plain sight.
If you claim someone is an OG and experienced then you can't cry about them making basic mistakes. It doesn't track.
Yes, you're a simp or a scum mate. Spare me the paragraphs of whiny justification for white knighting an adult who should be able to defend themselves.
misreading is reading... but thanks for showcasing that you have no actual reads or original thoughts of your own since reentering the game.
Im quite certain up to this point ive done the most for town and drew the most engagement from a wide rwnge of players and havent hyperfocused any single player.. you can refute it if you want it but I'm sure everyone would agree.
the onle person crying about someone making a mistake is you mate. not sure if youre aware but even the most experienced players make mistakes didn't you make plenty of mistakes. You talk a BIG game for someone who has only dre attention for being cased as scum.
yawn.
you're quite boring, yet this is what was expected of a newb.
Muugen: either scum or has a crush on Naomi or is incompetent town. Last game he was scum and came in with big energy then fizzled out into irrelevance. I'll have to see if he keeps the same energy rest of the game, otherwise he's on his scum meta.
so what am i actually, scum, incompetent town or do I have a crush on Naomi sounds like a blanket read that only a new player would make cause they don't even belive their own spew of shit you're chatting.
scum meta lol don't have a real MO, 6oumcan confirm this with onii, rat or Cypher, or really anyone here tbh
but good try to continue on your previous games fumble of finding my meta like you said you would..
misreading is reading... but thanks for showcasing that you have no actual reads or original thoughts of your own since reentering the game.
Im quite certain up to this point ive done the most for town and drew the most engagement from a wide rwnge of players and havent hyperfocused any single player.. you can refute it if you want it but I'm sure everyone would agree.
the onle person crying about someone making a mistake is you mate. not sure if youre aware but even the most experienced players make mistakes didn't you make plenty of mistakes. You talk a BIG game for someone who has only dre attention for being cased as scum.
yawn.
you're quite boring, yet this is what was expected of a newb.
Getting ready to just drop a ya on Ratchet, but he still looks really good from the Fuji interactions, IMO. So I'd tell them to just stay out of the thread, TBH ote on Seraphoenix.
Her reads so far feel real, and I don't see a reason for her to approach it that way as a wolf.
The way she's consistently wanted to read people for herself in the wake of people locking them as town has felt villagery.
Has exhibited a comfortable fluidity to reads.
Fair amount of mindmelds/some towny micromoments.
General mixture of healthy caution and strong reads has in all come across as very natural.
Engagement is consistent.
Reasons Flower isMafia:
In more of a background position early on when lots of pushes on villagers were happening.
Could be playing a more subtle game, not drawing too much attention.
VERDICT: Some minor concerns, but more reasons to townread than not. Still a strong town lean.
Yoho
Reasons Yoho is Town:
Yoho, in general, has not done a lot to direct the flow of the game or to actively pocket people, which to me indicates they are not playing with a wolf-agenda.
Reasons Yoho is Mafia:
Has not done much this game, main pushes have been on villagers. Could be playing a lazy mafia game.
Wolf range is large enough that realistically they could be fooling me this game.
Not a lot of concretely clearing things/can make sense in a few worlds.
VERDICT: Nothing overtly clearing, but still a town lean. Closer to null, could fit in some worlds.
Naomi
Reasons Naomi is Town:
Play aligns more closely with town meta upon review.
Naomi appears to be one of the hardest pushers currently.
Actively engaged in discussions and willing to challenge others.
Reasons Naomi isMafia:
My read on her in the beginning could be correct. In past town games especially lately, I've usually found her earlier than I did this game.
Gamestate/my townreads indicate it's likely one where wolves are playing well, and she is one of the most capable people of fooling me.
Early game push on me felt performative.
VERDICT: Town lean.
Fujishiro
Reasons Fujishiro isTown:
Claimed to be Miller early on.
Reasons Fujishiro isMafia:
Unusual claim.
Behavior has been erratic and difficult to read.
VERDICT: I believe that there are less concrete reasons to townread Fuji than I thought. Null for now.
Michelle
Reasons Michelle isTown:
Has been fairly reasonable in attention to detail throughout the game in a way that's come across as villagery.
Has been quite active and is driving the discussion.
Reasons Michelle isMafia:
TBD.
VERDICT: On the nuller side, though I'd be surprised if the amount of attention to detail in some of their reads came from a wolf. They are unpaired enough with people in my direct POE that I'd lean town.
Saber
Reasons Saber isTown:
Made a few posts.
Made a read.
Reasons Saber is Mafia:
Unusual reads.
Seems to be throwing out ideas without a clear, logical progression.
VERDICT: Saber is now a solid scum read for me.
Mr. Reloaded
Reasons Mr. Reloaded isTown:
Has made some contributions to the discussion, although they've been limited.
Some jokes land well.
Reasons Mr. Reloaded is Mafia:
Posts are often more focused on humor than on actual game analysis. It feels like a distraction.
Could be using humor as a way to deflect or avoid scrutiny. It's an easy way to avoid serious discussion.
Seems to be lurking in the background, which is a common wolf strategy. Not taking a strong stance on anything.
VERDICT: Leaning scum. Lack of serious engagement. Humor could be a cover. I'm not seeing much genuine problem-solving.
MUUGEN
Reasons MUUGEN isTown:
Has been active and engaged in discussions. They're definitely participating.
Reasons MUUGEN isMafia:
Early push on Saber felt forced and opportunistic, like they were trying to get a quick lynch.
Might be using a "bold" playstyle to mask wolf intentions. The aggressiveness feels a bit calculated.
VERDICT: Leaning scum.
Ratchet
Reasons Ratchet isTown:
Engages in debates and challenges others' viewpoints. They're not afraid to speak their mind.
Reasons Ratchet isMafia:
Argumentative style could be a way to create distractions and muddy the waters.
Behavior seems somewhat inconsistent.
Might be trying to appear townie by being vocal, but actions don't always align with their words. It feels like a performance at times.
VERDICT: Leaning scum.
Handium
Reasons Handium isTown:
Has made some contributions, although limited.
Reasons Handium isMafia:
Relatively quiet and has not been a major driving force as of D1. It's hard to get a read on them.
Could be playing a lurking game.
VERDICT:Null for now. Need to see more engagement to form a solid read. They're not giving me much to work with.
Yo Tan Wa
Reasons Yo Tan Wa isTown:
None that stand out at the moment.
Reasons Yo Tan Wa isMafia:
Relatively low activity makes it hard to get a read.
Could be any alignment as of now.
VERDICT:Null. Need more data.
Stargate18
Reasons Stargate18 isTown:
Has chimed in occasionally, so they're not completely silent.
Reasons Stargate18 isMafia:
Sporadic participation makes it difficult to gauge intentions. They're not consistently engaged.
Could be any alignment.
VERDICT:Null. Needs to be more active. I can't form an opinion based on so little information.
tepig19283
Reasons tepig19283 isTown:
Some reads seem to be based on careful observation. They're paying attention to details.
Has shown some genuine problem-solving. They seem to be thinking things through.
Asks questions and seems to be trying to understand the game, which is a good sign.
Reasons tepig19283 isMafia:
Could be a wolf playing a more subtle game, trying to appear townie without being too obvious.
VERDICT: Leaning town. There's a sense of genuine effort there, and I appreciate their attempts to solve. I'll keep watching them, but for now, they seem more likely to be town.
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
