Role Madness A Certain Magical Mafia II - Game Thread

[Fujishiro]

He gets brownie points for.. voting you?

The one who opens the game by voting himself, now voting you without any context nor reason given - gains points in your book?

I would really love for you to expand your thoughts on how this makes sense, as the logic seems to elude me.

Yeah for voting me, dont see him doing that as scum.

 

[Fujishiro]

Not enough for me to town read him but its something, I can read Alexis pretty well and havent been wrong on him so far. Right now hes null but his voting me points towards town lets see what else he does.

 

[Charlie]

They were in the player list...sketchy

yeah, i thought it's some nickname :o

 

[MangoSenpai]

I just had the sudden thought about whether there was an actual scum team in this game, I thought maybe for a second that there being 2 towns that they were at odds with each other.

But after getting a very vague response from the host in my PM, I kinda read the wincons a few times and also looked up this Orthinus thing- And from my understanding the two towns are on the same team, and the scum team is called Gremlin, and their leader is this Orthinus guy.

Just putting it out there, if not only for my own sake.

 

[MangoSenpai]

Yeah for voting me, dont see him doing that as scum.

Well I can get that it seems unreasonable as a non-town to do such a play, but I don't think Alexis is of the kind that is limited by conventional thinking.
That is not to say I am accusing him of anything, but I do find this vote highly questionable in nature, with his overall contribution of this game in mind.

I do have a hard time thinking he is town, though likewise seems a bit too thoughtless to be mafia - I'll work the assumption that he is most likely some sort if indie for the time being.

 

[Fujishiro]

Well I can get that it seems unreasonable as a non-town to do such a play, but I don't think Alexis is of the kind that is limited by conventional thinking.
That is not to say I am accusing him of anything, but I do find this vote highly questionable in nature, with his overall contribution of this game in mind.

I do have a hard time thinking he is town, though likewise seems a bit too thoughtless to be mafia - I'll work the assumption that he is most likely some sort if indie for the time being.

I get what you say Im not town reading him or anything just said that what he did was townie indicative for me, I havent read him wrong in any game so far lol.

 

[MangoSenpai]

I get what you say Im not town reading him or anything just said that what he did was townie indicative for me, I havent read him wrong in any game so far lol.

Has he rolled scum in any of those games?

 

[MangoSenpai]

Since when do you all tag vote?

Well, seeing as you weren't really present, I did you the honor of letting you know that I voted you.

Now I hope to see some frigid cool plays from you, ser Orca

 

[Random Asshole]

And with the end of the other game, I may not forget this one as easily again lol

 

[Naomi]

Yoho
Dr. Watson
MangoSenpai
Fujishiro
Flower
Muugen
Alexis2282AE
Michelle
York
Ali v2
AlwaysMind
The Orca
Polar Bear
Naomi
Mr Reloaded
~UwU~
Stargate18
Pot Goblin
Random Asshole
Charlie
Ghostface Killa
Grammaton

 

[Naomi]

\

trying the afk strat since it's quite popular.

this afk strat is wide used among scum.

 

[MangoSenpai]

Yoho
Dr. Watson
MangoSenpai
Fujishiro
Flower
Muugen
Alexis2282AE
Michelle
York
Ali v2
AlwaysMind
The Orca
Polar Bear
Naomi
Mr Reloaded
~UwU~
Stargate18
Pot Goblin
Random Asshole
Charlie
Ghostface Killa
Grammaton

Am I to understand this as you've redacted your scum read of me?

Why is that?

 

[Fujishiro]

Has he rolled scum in any of those games?

Yeah.

 

[Naomi]

Am I to understand this as you've redacted your scum read of me?

Why is that?

for now.

thinking could be indie.

 

[MangoSenpai]

Yeah.

What would you say are indicators of Scum Alexis?
Tells, if you will

 

[MangoSenpai]

for now.

thinking could be indie.

But why, I don't think my play have changed since you first accused me of being scum.

From my PoV I shouldn't have given you any reason to change your mind

I would love to hear your expanded thoughts here

 

[The Orca]

Yoho
Dr. Watson
MangoSenpai
Fujishiro
Flower
Muugen
Alexis2282AE
Michelle
York
Ali v2
AlwaysMind
The Orca
Polar Bear
Naomi
Mr Reloaded
~UwU~
Stargate18
Pot Goblin
Random Asshole
Charlie
Ghostface Killa
Grammaton

Add Michelle to the scum pile with Ali v2 and Muugen. I'll guess Always town if he has ghosted

 

[Naomi]

But why, I don't think my play have changed since you first accused me of being scum.

From my PoV I shouldn't have given you any reason to change your mind

I would love to hear your expanded thoughts here

your rainbow list made me pause. but you are still notorious for being afk more as town in past game. then compared to here where your active.

so i will lean indie for now because rainbow list.

unless it fake and your trying to blend in as town/indie is what your telling me.

 

[Naomi]

your rainbow list made me pause. but you are still notorious for being afk more as town in past game. then compared to here where your active.

so i will lean indie for now because rainbow list.

unless it fake and your trying to blend in as town/indie is what your telling me.

Correction

unless it fake and your trying to blend in as scum is what your telling me.

 

[Alwaysmind]

Add Michelle to the scum pile with Ali v2 and Muugen. I'll guess Always town if he has ghosted

I’ll guess that you are town since I’ll take the word ghosted as an insult