I am going to have to disagree here Lord Baron Ratchet. I believe Tarvern Hostesss Michelle is a good citizen of the kingdom that serves good ale. I am usually good at reading her and I dont see the usual signs of a villainous Michelle.
I like to think I'm pretty good these days too. As town I expect a certain level of thought and solving intent from her that I am not seeing. And her defence is a bit of a lame duck. So we will have to agree to disagree. Who do you have your eye on?
I think there is a risk of giving players too much of a pass for this sort of thing. Michelle as scum wouldn't really go out of her way to defend me. Could see it as just jumping on lazily.
With all due respect I believe you are reaching, perhaps if you had more votes on you I could see that being the case but correct me if Im wrong she was the second vote on you right.
I like to think I'm pretty good these days too. As town I expect a certain level of thought and solving intent from her that I am not seeing. And her defence is a bit of a lame duck. So we will have to agree to disagree. Who do you have your eye on?
Basically I think you have no explainable reason for your vote on me, what you gave doesn't hold water, and that your game so far is missing parts of your solving that I expect from you as town. I felt your vote on me was driven from a desire to place it somewhere than have any solving intent behind it.
With all due respect I believe you are reaching, perhaps if you had more votes on you I could see that being the case but correct me if Im wrong she was the second vote on you right.
Well tbf from what I remember Town Michelle normally ask players why they're voting someone and maybe a little back and forth before following a vote. That's my recollection of it.
With all due respect I believe you are reaching, perhaps if you had more votes on you I could see that being the case but correct me if Im wrong she was the second vote on you right.
Doesn't that go against your argument though? Because if it's only two votes, it's a wagon she can safely park on that won't be accused of doing nothing because of who it's on, and when I respond to it to go against her, the defence is that the wagon didn't grow and she's a coward? Like you can't have both.
Basically I think you have no explainable reason for your vote on me, what you gave doesn't hold water, and that your game so far is missing parts of your solving that I expect from you as town. I felt your vote on me was driven from a desire to place it somewhere than have any solving intent behind it.
I will say and this is me playing devil's advocate here that in hindsight Milicia Guard @EkkoLoJinx mightve not understood this post where she said lady Flower is solving really as what she was quoting was Flower complaining about a dead game but I looked back at prior posts and she did like one post where Flower can be considered to be ''solving'' where she gave Naomi a town read and me as well for trying to guess my role.
See, this is where we have issues. Because I don't think any part of my play around you has been "upset". So you're introducing an emotional angle to this where there isn't one, by way of defence. I don't think that there is anything wrong with questioning a vote that I think doesn't make sense under the stated reasoning, and I'm not sure why you'd disagree?
Doesn't that go against your argument though? Because if it's only two votes, it's a wagon she can safely park on that won't be accused of doing nothing because of who it's on, and when I respond to it to go against her, the defence is that the wagon didn't grow and she's a coward? Like you can't have both.
No because it depends on whom the votes are placed on, my argument was never about the number of votes anyways but the fact that she voted you which is something I dont see her doing at all as scum. Bonus point when its very early and not like later on at as a sheep vote where she sees the opportunity to get rid of a strong player and decides to take it.
I want you to read Crowned Witchs case on him and let me know your thoughts, I found myself agreeing wiht it. He feels a bit NPCY for my tastes and thats usually a scum tell of his.
I hate to play the Flower card Ratchy but I have been suffering from a fever since Saturday so at the moment I am glossing over which player I am checking or not. Charlie didnt really ping me yet with his posts and you know I can find him easily if he is an enemy of the Kingdom.
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.