I feel like I have seen enough to make an updated post up to page 40 regarding my thoughts so far.
Not big fan of charlie reaction, it seems he is just focused on a simple vibe/observation post I pointed out and others as well, and throwing a fit, def is frustrated, and instead of trying to solve, he seems to be stuck. Will see if that changes or not moving forward, in one of his posts, I believe it's the one where he replied to my initial post where I posted my thoughts, he stated that he is town, I would actually like if someone can lie detect and see if he is capping or not. I am not putting money on using excuses as 'frustration' to give someone a pass per say.
Flower, liked her push on ratchet, engaging with players, and even defending players. Feels herself and don't see anything malicious from her at the moment. Town lean.
Ratchet, not the biggest fan of how defensive he was toward flower and michelle push, I feel like scum ratchet would try to eliminate things from the beginning and kinda bring things to heel. I thought his post regarding flower not picking a fight with him as town, while true to certain extent, felt calculated, to kinda ease her up by starting the back and forth with 'hey, i think you are town for doing this, but let's do this back and forthuntil you really come around.' , it's subtle but def something I see him planting ahead on.
Ekko, I like how forthcoming he is and hitting the gas and moving forward with his thoughts and engaging and pushing players. He atleast gives the impression that he is a man on a mission and want to capture scum, would think he would be more layed back as scum.
Saber, voted for flower and dipped, I do think there is a decent chance he rolled scum here and is making some 5d chess moves in the scum chat to nuke town to the cosmos.
Polar gives the impression that he taking a backseat, making posts here and there just enough to show that he is engaging, not looking good for him so far tbh.
Crowned Witch, I don't know why, but I am not getting any scum vibes from her. I guess I am bewitched or something. She is making content, making analysis posts, nothing crazy, nothing new. I wouldn't be surprised if she is an indie actually.