General & Others Top 5 fav Old Dudes of the series.

Top 5 Fav old dudes

  • Rayleigh

    Votes: 30 69.8%
  • Gaban

    Votes: 14 32.6%
  • Marz

    Votes: 3 7.0%
  • Garling

    Votes: 12 27.9%
  • Saturn

    Votes: 2 4.7%
  • Nusjuro

    Votes: 10 23.3%
  • Zeff

    Votes: 13 30.2%
  • King Riku

    Votes: 1 2.3%
  • Whitebeard

    Votes: 31 72.1%
  • Garp

    Votes: 20 46.5%
  • Sengoku

    Votes: 9 20.9%
  • Jupeter

    Votes: 2 4.7%
  • Warcury

    Votes: 4 9.3%
  • Vegapunk

    Votes: 3 7.0%
  • Clover

    Votes: 3 7.0%

  • Total voters
    43
#21
1. There are no other characters quite like the Admirals in any other manga. Even characters with similar power sets like Ice or Gravity or whatever don’t have their raw Yakuza energy and badass fighting styles. Garp is literally generic punch man #5000 that I’ve read 10 million times before. I literally can’t fathom enjoying a character this painfully generic.

2. Garp is absolutely a copy and paste of Luffy lol. He is meant to be old man Luffy is Luffy was a Marine. So if the Admirals are copy and pasted off badass Yakuza actors (they aren’t, they are just based off of them), then Garp is a million times worse.

3. So you acknowledge that Garp is a hypocrite? Well that’s good at least. Most cro-magnon mouth breathing breast milk drinking titty licking Garp fans are actually stupid enough to think that Garp is who he thinks he is instead of acknowledging the reality that Garp is the only Marine who is truly a slave. Lol
I’m at a loss as to who you are talking about. Lol
1. Yea you just don't read a lot of manga/manhwa. Nice you have a preference for those type of personalities. Nice you're exaggerating shit to slander Garp. Absolutely nothing about this has anything to do with quality writing, just your preference.

2. Nice, you've stated something I've already stated numerous times, has nothing to do with the quality of his character writing. You stated "not based off a famous actor", I said nice he's not copy pasted. I'm assuming you're referring to the character designs based off of famous actor, specifically the faces since you stated "Actor", and not "Character". Nice you tell us again you have a thing for Yakuza. I mean cool, you like Yakuza characters. I mean Fujitora, the noodle eating HAHAHAHAHAHAHAH laughing, slave freeing, Luffy loving is def not the one who fits the Yakuza mold, despite who his character design is based off of. I mean I guess if a lazy dude riding his bike wearing bright white suit fits the Yakuza vibe to you, or now dressing up as a depressed emo guy. Outside of Saka, Borsalino, and now Tensei, i'm not seeing the Yakuza vibes.

3. I don't think he's hypocrite in the sense you're trying to make him out to be. "Trying to be free of the CD, while also being their biggest shield", I think that's just headcanon. The sole hypocritical part about his character would be that he wants the best for civilians while also being in the Marines as his bosses are the CD who can just enslave any civilian off the street. But I'm pretty certain that's something all marines acknowledge. However, that's a hypocrisy that exists with every single marine, aside from Fujitora. Calling the only Marine the CD want dead for insubordination "only marine who is truly a slave" is weird.
 
#27
Bro put Gaban over Rayleigh and got banned for it:risisure:

1. Rayleigh, the coldest MF on the planet. Bro is 185 years old, is in an open relationship with a hot former queen, bangs young freshmen pirate chicks, gambles and drinks 24/7. Also fights off an admiral in his prime as first exercise in decades and scares off a yonko, that challenged the RHPs, Garp and Sengoku at once, simply by his presence.
2. Gaban, bro got himself the biggest cake a man can have. Doesn't bother with piracy and shit anymore. For once, a seemingly good (and present) father
3. Garp, didn't like him before but his fighting proved he was a beast in his youth
4. Younger VP. I appreciate his capitalism and the fact he neglected Dragon for it
5. Zeff, small time pirate but he's cool.
 

Warchief Sanji D Goat

Panty Anarchy!🩲
#28
1. Whitebeard (undisputed king)
2. Garp (he's probably the most controversial Old Legend but it doesn't change the fact that he has a likable personality).
3. Gaban (dope character, love his personality).
4. Rayleigh (cool character, has one of the best debuts in the series, overall aura farmer).
5. Zeff (great character overall and Sanji's best father figure).

For non-power level heavy old folks, King Riku is great. King Cobra should be on the list too.

As for Gorosei, not gonna lie, none of them are likable lol. Oda did a piss poor job at expanding their character in Egghead arc. But if I have to pick, probably Nusjuro tbh. At least he has aura.
 
#32
1. Kuzan is a typical lazy/cool dude personality nothing special in anime, normally depicted with emo hairstyle but Kuzan being the exception though now he does essentially have that emo look. Akainu is essentially Danzo reincarnated in personality, nothing new. All admirals have personalities that can be found in other series, not sure what this has to do with the writing itself. In terms of philosophy, if you're predicating this on "justice" then only Fujitora has any depthful standalone justice worth discussing about right now. With Akainu's just being an extension of Absolute, that he's not unique in. Tsuru/Sengoku/Kuzan/Borsalino's all being gimmick justices.

2. Nice Oda didn't just copy and paste. +1 Garp.

3. Since when did hypocrite = bad character writing? Characters are hypocrites because they're written to be hypocrites... lol. What in the goofy is this? I'm starting to think your reading comprehension and IQ in general falls off a cliff when reading characters you don't like. He's not the best shield CD ever have had. Kuzan/Borsalino/Akainu/Sengoku/Kong based on what we know are all better shields. Idk why you would make such a stupid statement. The guy you deep throat on a daily basis, the guy who you shit on other marines for to hype up, is the best shield the CD have ever had. Hence, he was handpicked to lead the New Marines.


Ahh you're right. Ace became a pirate because how much of a piece of shit Garp is. Luffy wanted to be the PK because Garp was a PoS. Kuzan got a dick up his ass and wanted to fight Akainu for the FA, because Garp was a PoS. Kuzan left the marines after Saka kicked his ass and cripled him, cause Garp was a PoS. Dragon left the marines and started the RA, because Garp was a PoS.
don't compare Lord Shimura to the celestial dragons dog
 
#37
Gaban so far is the best one. Got everything from fun, energetic to badass without having a stick up his ass and design is the best.
Whitebeard could've been good had he not been made a bitch multiple times ignoring his own rules about avenging the death of his crewmate.
Zeff is cool but he lacks screentime, moments and design wise.
Rayleigh is boring af.
Garp is a poorly written meme.
Sengoku is just a leech to Garp.
Gorosei are nothingburgers.

Maybe Garling will do something good? But so far he has been a bitch as well whose biggest feat is literally killing chained up citizens and being afraid of Fujitora
 
#38
Gaban so far is the best one. Got everything from fun, energetic to badass without having a stick up his ass and design is the best.
Whitebeard could've been good had he not been made a bitch multiple times ignoring his own rules about avenging the death of his crewmate.
Zeff is cool but he lacks screentime, moments and design wise.
Rayleigh is boring af.
Garp is a poorly written meme.
Sengoku is just a leech to Garp.
Gorosei are nothingburgers.

Maybe Garling will do something good? But so far he has been a bitch as well whose biggest feat is literally killing chained up citizens and being afraid of Fujitora
stop smoking crack lmao. Gaban is literally the Sabo to Rayleighs Ace
[automerge]1743288080[/automerge]
Also, the Gorosei are cool
 
#39
stop smoking crack lmao. Gaban is literally the Sabo to Rayleighs Ace
How?
Gaban is nothing like Rayleigh

Gaban is actually cool, fun, badass
meanwhile Rayleigh is bland, snoozefest inducing.
Also, the Gorosei are cool
Gorosei are literally the lamest jobber bums in this series.
Probably need autism to invent personalities for them since they are all the same bums x5.
 
Top