HA001

World's Strongest Swordsman
Could be also charisma
Post automatically merged:


I mean we know already kaido gets clapped so hard he almost died
Big mom was there to save him with a DF, so she is also there at least till that point
and i think its save to assume WB and Shiki are also there as the 2 strongest
the rest is not important anyway imo in the grand scheme of things
Kaido gonna get clapped pretty early in god valley
Meme saves him and gives the fruit and then we know kaido runs away meme has no reason to stay on the island after getting the fruits either

Let's see what happens with wb and garling
 
Because you ignore them every time like now

Huh? Being at the booze cabinet again? :shocked: I never said Gaban = Sanji, that was you. Sanjis ceiling will be much higher, cause he is odas favorite, every week the cope detoriates more, this week "haha sanji has heart eyes and jobs agains woman, oda does not like him" :finally:
My god, Sanji's lighter has more backstory than Zoro. He is my 2nd favorite character, I'm genuinely sad, he deserves much better.
 

HA001

World's Strongest Swordsman
yeah people think oda gonna clown his MCs goal lol

And it's funny that a lot of zorotards are slandering roger. When one of their main argument for mihawk being above shanks is "oda won't clown zoro's end goal"
It's a sword eat sword world out here Roger being stronger or weaker than xebec is fine either way.

Xebec wins by not being solod by Roger

Roger can only win by soloing rocks

ANY imu involvement and he's finished
 
All the dickriding Roger getting from former Rocks member makes it feel like he soloed their captain ngl
Otherwise I just don't understand
I feel that Roger is currently just a victim of being the "middle link" between Joyboy and Luffy.

Hence why Oda has made him so much softer and goofier, to fit with the whole laughing liberator chosen one stuff.

IMO if Nika/Joyboy stuff wasn't a thing Roger would be more prominent and Oda would write him as less of a butt monkey.

I also think he'll definitely be very strong for sure since he's Shanks' parallel and Oda adores Shanks, just that he'll be less like WB (strong w/o being goofy) and more like Luffy (strong but also a clown).
 

HA001

World's Strongest Swordsman
I do doubt most of these yappers even witnessed the fall of Xebec, it just feels that they had more respect for Roger than their own former captain.
Could really just be a matter of personality/charisma though
Perception vs reality is a real thing

All these rocks pirates gassing Roger do you think their opinions would change if they saw him kneel to wb for Oden?
Cause I sure do
He'd still be pk but they for sure wouldn't look at him the same
 
It's a sword eat sword world out here Roger being stronger or weaker than xebec is fine either way.

Xebec wins by not being solod by Roger

Roger can only win by soloing rocks

ANY imu involvement and he's finished
what if Imu is involved but Roger banishes her?

If imu did come down to GV, i doubt she would have gone away with just killing Rocks. Someone must have desummoned her. Similar to how the gorosei got sent back. Since Roger is the pirate jesus reincarnation, it makes sense for him to do it like how soyboy's rope haki sent the gorosei back.
 

HA001

World's Strongest Swordsman
what if Imu is involved but Roger banishes her?

If imu did come down to GV, i doubt she would have gone away with just killing Rocks. Someone must have desummoned her. Similar to how the gorosei got sent back. Since Roger is the pirate jesus reincarnation, it makes sense for him to do it like how soyboy's rope haki sent the gorosei back.
You got to remember Roger and Co do not look that injured when they open the treasure and find shanks
And Roger not neg diffing rocks for shit
And that's when the island wasn't lulusiad
It's more likely everyone leaves bar Saturn and whoever imu gunkos and they beat rocks and blow God valley up and just teleport back (imu may not even care about the host)
 
All these rocks pirates gassing Roger do you think their opinions would change if they saw him kneel to wb for Oden?
Cause I sure do
He'd still be pk but they for sure wouldn't look at him the same
I mean he knelt to arguably the strongest subordinate of rocks and that subordinate was still a roger wanker after that.
And meme knows roger ducked her cause well, she's the one who made him duck. But she still wanks him as she's dying.
Shiki knew roger got his ass saved by a lucky storm against shiki's fleet. But still 2 v 1'd Garp and Bumgoku to free Roger.

So all but kaido knows Roger has his fraud moments. But they wank him nonetheless.
Post automatically merged:

You got to remember Roger and Co do not look that injured when they open the treasure and find shanks
And Roger not neg diffing rocks for shit
And that's when the island wasn't lulusiad
It's more likely everyone leaves bar Saturn and whoever imu gunkos and they beat rocks and blow God valley up and just teleport back (imu may not even care about the host)
I don't think we can take the film red promo chapter as canon tbh
We gonna see a bloody and battered roger pirates for sure in the actual manga
 
It's a sword eat sword world out here Roger being stronger or weaker than xebec is fine either way.

Xebec wins by not being solod by Roger

Roger can only win by soloing rocks

ANY imu involvement and he's finished
Roger will prove slightly superior but Imu will kill Xebec at the last minute. I feel like Roger has to win 1v1, it’s the only thing left to justify his hype. If Xebec proves superior then Roger will be a fraud relative to his 20-year buildup. Xebec should be the true pirate king of that era.

The Rocks crew hyping Roger up leads me to believe that they saw him beat Xebec though. This feat will undisputedly cement Roger as the top dog of his generation, he can “tie” (offscreen) 1000 times with Silver Axe within the next 13 years for all I care.
 
I don't believe Oda will outright throw Roger in the trash but since Joy boy/Nika took prominence, I don't think he's some untouchable God either.
Roger is literally a failed Joyboy/Luffy in the narrative, as hash as it sounds
Well in all fairness he’s never been an untouchable god

We’ve known that since we found out his only pirate rival/equal had no interest in the One Piece

At least that’s when it hit me
 

HA001

World's Strongest Swordsman
Roger will prove slightly superior but Imu will kill Xebec at the last minute. I feel like Roger has to win 1v1, it’s the only thing left to justify his hype. If Xebec proves superior then Roger will be a fraud relative to his 20-year buildup. Xebec should be the true pirate king of that era.

The Rocks crew hyping Roger up leads me to believe that they saw him beat Xebec though. This feat will undisputedly cement Roger as the top dog of his generation, he can “tie” (offscreen) 1000 times with Silver Axe within the next 13 years for all I care.
Or it shows being pirate King =/= needing to be the strongest or at least rogers version
 
Well in all fairness he’s never been an untouchable god

We’ve known that since we found out his only pirate rival/equal had no interest in the One Piece

At least that’s when it hit me
I mean that some fans believe it's absolutely impossible Oda would "disrespect" Roger by not having him solo Xebec.
Personally I'm 50/50. Yes Oda might have Roger finally live to his portrayal but on the other hand Oda might want to protect Teach's daddy as it will only make Luffy feat of defeating his son more impressive if it is 1 vs 1.
 
Top