Role Madness One Piece Mash 2.0

Waluigi

Waluigi

‎
#2,801
#2,801
Meow meow praise the everlight, the dawn mother cat goddess of healing.

Hunting thrall converts is also dumb because you just have to like, erase your towncore and it gives wolves and townies who aren't so wise an excuse to hit cleared and obvious townies.

Meow meow

It's super bogus, hitting a thrall just lets the cult recruit someone else and interferes in the town-cult alliance against the wolves.

I will start voting for folks who argue that we need to hit a cult convert.

That does not reduce the numbers of wolves and in my experience wolves never get recruited into cults.

If that happens town is boned because they face off against a cult+mafia faction that can GROW.

That's super borked.

If that's the case, feel free to fight for the alignment win but the game is more like a haha joke after that, not something we need to lose sleep over.

I'm operating under the assumption the game is reasonable.

If it is not, then I love the game host already for the creativity and I've personally made mad scientist games that arent at all fair or balanced by mistake and its a postgame discussion that should be respectful.

TLDR- meow
 
Charlie

Charlie

‎
#2,802
#2,802
Flower said:
Orca can be Town here. I have no idea why he‘s low on anyone‘s list, he‘s just doing his usual shit.
Click to expand...
i feel like i'm beating a dead horse with this one, but what do you think of him saying udell is scummy before udell made a single post? for me personally it reads as "i'll just throw random people on the list and look like i care"
 
Waluigi

Waluigi

‎
#2,804
#2,804
Flower said:
Yeah, Duck and me. But protecting from Cult at night is worthless when they can convert during the day.
Click to expand...
I believe @Random Asshole claimed to also be one

Like, it's not on my radar but im taking notes to try to hit wolves and I anticipate one anti cult role is a wolf, minimum.

They NEED one or they have NO chance to win.

I also dunno if they'd ever claim it publicly so that might be a 4th unknown cult role hunter, which is a wolf, outside of your three names.

@Flower meow meow meow, o townie leader who art granted me this divine cat blessing

These are my super serious thoughts. Iso RA and you will see what I mean, I did.
 
Flower

Flower

‎
#2,805
#2,805
Charlie said:
i feel like i'm beating a dead horse with this one, but what do you think of him saying udell is scummy before udell made a single post? for me personally it reads as "i'll just throw random people on the list and look like i care"
Click to expand...
He‘s doing random player guessing shit all the time as Town.
Like, I‘m not defending him, he can do it himself, but shit like this can easily come from him as Town, so I‘m not willing to vote him over more sus slots.
 
Waluigi

Waluigi

‎
#2,807
#2,807
Charlie said:
i feel like i'm beating a dead horse with this one, but what do you think of him saying udell is scummy before udell made a single post? for me personally it reads as "i'll just throw random people on the list and look like i care"
Click to expand...
....

People often vote for players not playing yet and say they're wolfy as a joke.

This isn't what happened there?

All the other orca posts look town to me. It would be so very strange if thats what brings orca down when they're otherwise a competent looking player and also very townie at the same time.

I'd be baffled, lick myself, and take a cat nap

 
Charlie

Charlie

‎
#2,810
#2,810
Flower said:
He‘s doing random player guessing shit all the time as Town.
Like, I‘m not defending him, he can do it himself, but shit like this can easily come from him as Town, so I‘m not willing to vote him over more sus slots.
Click to expand...
can you like, give example of him doing sth like this as town? it's not just ranom players, it's dude who has not posted
 
Waluigi

Waluigi

‎
#2,816
#2,816
FOR REFERENCE

Gianfi was one of my top suspects last night in the city chat

They werent fighting for town in their iso

thats why i blocked them. because if theyre wolf under the radar, I block those. I detest lurkers.

This is a hard claim and not a joke.

Meow praise kitten jesus
 
Flower

Flower

‎
#2,818
#2,818
The Orca said:
Gonna be hard to explain, just something I do on the fly. In general there is almost always an inactive or inactives as scum, scum tend to talk less, scum tend to want to make it through D1 meaning talking less then. So inactives are more up on the radar. Then look at the field as a whole, is it mostly people solving and being active and more towny feel. In this case I'd say so. So ultimately the odds are higher based on the rest of the players, odds higher because of their inactivity, odds higher because D1 activity, maybe some other quick summations in there as well
Click to expand...
@Charlie here his shit theory.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top