Role Madness Elden Ring

And no this isnt me throwing

Im town but im not going to argue against shit points that I cant defend against

If you've never seen scum use an execute to frame someone then you simply need to play more games, it happens constantly
 
So why would we lynch RA over anyone else? Moreover, you're avoiding all the main discussion points too.
I don't want to lynch RA. I only said it because it seemed like we were seesawing back and forth. I really, really want to lynch York and remove the rot factor. That doesn't seem to be happening. Flower wants to leave it be because if one of us die by it, she unlocks an ability.

I can see why Cal is leaning more scum. Since it's plurality lynch, I could throw my vote on him but it wouldn't do much. And I'm following the conversation. I just don't have much to contribute to it. I don't understand enough about the role mechanics to know the in and outs of plurality and such. I'm relying on better players for that.
 
And if you think im scum for being on the wrong side of baudib then you should consider the favt he ignored every one of my posts against him. Go look. He ignored like 20 posts, including multiple attempts to call him into discussion.

What was i meant to think.

Oh and also...

Town are wrong about things, it happens, im not perfect guy!!!!!
 
I can apply 1 stack of Rot to someone each night, which I did to Cal
Last night(N2)?

Who did you apply the single stack on N1?
and I can track someone, which I did to Polar
This is unrelated to your rot stuff right?
Like this is x shot track ability?
If so why'd you use it on Polar who a lot of people had as town?
How? I targetted scum both times, they likely had protects in place as is the case in super role madness games
Why did you target Cal when he claimed he had "50% redirect"?
Did your kill shot have amp or some way to bypass the supposed redirect?

Also, who did you target with 1 stack rot?
I know it failed because if he was town, I would be dead, if he was scum he would be dead
Does your kill shot have some way to bypass his "50% redirect" ?
Is it amped or something for being "if your target is not scum, you die" restrictive ability?

Also, did you know he claimed the "50% redirect" before you shot him?
Nope, nope, nope.

Vote Lynch Worst.

There was one thing I did different last night and got an instance of scarlet rot for it and that visit Worst.
1 stack? 2 stack?

Why assume Worst did it just because you visited him?

York already claimed the Rot main role. You think there's 2 people who have "get rotted if you visit them" ability?
I don't know. It was supposed to be a two person invest to see if at least 1 is nontown or at least 1 is town. My understanding of it wasn't clear and I may have annoyed fuji lol. The result though, was...1 is town
Annoy him some more. We need to know what it would have said if there were 2 townies, and what it would have said if there were 2 scum.

You claimed you were roleblocked on N1. Forgive me if it's already been posted by you or someone else. But how did you know you were roleblocked?

Also, you claimed "almost vanilla"

You think that's an almost vanilla ability? Seems a pretty good ability imo(the cop ability)

If Cal is town's power role he must have a way to survive

And it literally says baudib got executed
2 kill shots with only a "50% redirect" ?

He claimed Preceptor Seluvius. unless Fuji just went ham with "may deviate from flavor/lore", i just can't see why Seluvius of all people would be town's power role.
What does Cal's have common with the Scarlet Rot? Did he not claim the 50% of redirecting abilities that affect him
So why'd you shoot him without any counter measures for the "50% redirect"?
Did you have any? Or did you know someone else would also be shooting him So the "50%" would not kick in for at least one kill?

We need to kills mafia, not sk
Lynching York will hard confirm you. So why not?

With you hard confirmed, you can lead the town much much better no?
Ripped is outed, no one is using the exexute except to save themselves. Not when it looked like baufib1 was gonna be the lynch anyway.
Isn't it kinda dumb to use an execute to save yourself at the last minute? Cause wouldn't that just confirm he's scum anyway?
Couldn't he have been framed easily?
Pero. He said he watched me N2
I can conceded that, but 1) why did Melkor shoot 2) why wouldn't it be redirected on someone else versus who it may have been 3) why didn't the watch watch Melkor...this is SpongeBob all over again. 4) what good does watching me do after D2
Am i misunderstanding what a Watch does?

@Peroroncino you watch someone and see if anything is done to them right? Not whatever they do? Cause you said you didn't see any protects being used on your target.

But then why would you watch Orca? You said you targeted Orca because of his Duel vote on Charlie to win. Isn't Voting against everyone else a good way to stand out? Especially if he was scum he would know Charles is scum. You might have thought it was Orca doing so BECAUSE of that, but that's just Wifom. So surely you had better targets than Orca?

Also, if Watchsees both what they do and what is done to them, then why didn't you see Orca visiting Flower and Melkor for his cop?

Can‘t see Melkor faking Vig
Why not? He claimed too early. Is that something Vigs do usually?

And he also failed both times. Depending on his answer, he targeted Cal with no way to bypass the supposed "50% redirect" Cal has.

Do these seem like a town Vig's actions to you?
I factually know I was targeted by scum, so who the fuck knows.
Mech or just gut feeling?
I can literally deal with her if she killed somebody.
And what if you get killed this coming night phase?
She‘s killed somebody, right?
Not from what we know so far
@Peroroncino what does Thunderstorm do?
It's the weapon art of the axes Nepheli has

https://eldenring.wiki.fextralife.com/Thunderstorm
 
Last night(N2)?

Who did you apply the single stack on N1?

This is unrelated to your rot stuff right?
Like this is x shot track ability?
If so why'd you use it on Polar who a lot of people had as town?

Why did you target Cal when he claimed he had "50% redirect"?
Did your kill shot have amp or some way to bypass the supposed redirect?

Also, who did you target with 1 stack rot?


Does your kill shot have some way to bypass his "50% redirect" ?
Is it amped or something for being "if your target is not scum, you die" restrictive ability?

Also, did you know he claimed the "50% redirect" before you shot him?

1 stack? 2 stack?

Why assume Worst did it just because you visited him?

York already claimed the Rot main role. You think there's 2 people who have "get rotted if you visit them" ability?

Annoy him some more. We need to know what it would have said if there were 2 townies, and what it would have said if there were 2 scum.

You claimed you were roleblocked on N1. Forgive me if it's already been posted by you or someone else. But how did you know you were roleblocked?

Also, you claimed "almost vanilla"

You think that's an almost vanilla ability? Seems a pretty good ability imo(the cop ability)


2 kill shots with only a "50% redirect" ?

He claimed Preceptor Seluvius. unless Fuji just went ham with "may deviate from flavor/lore", i just can't see why Seluvius of all people would be town's power role.

So why'd you shoot him without any counter measures for the "50% redirect"?
Did you have any? Or did you know someone else would also be shooting him So the "50%" would not kick in for at least one kill?


Lynching York will hard confirm you. So why not?

With you hard confirmed, you can lead the town much much better no?

Isn't it kinda dumb to use an execute to save yourself at the last minute? Cause wouldn't that just confirm he's scum anyway?
Couldn't he have been framed easily?


Am i misunderstanding what a Watch does?

@Peroroncino you watch someone and see if anything is done to them right? Not whatever they do? Cause you said you didn't see any protects being used on your target.

But then why would you watch Orca? You said you targeted Orca because of his Duel vote on Charlie to win. Isn't Voting against everyone else a good way to stand out? Especially if he was scum he would know Charles is scum. You might have thought it was Orca doing so BECAUSE of that, but that's just Wifom. So surely you had better targets than Orca?

Also, if Watchsees both what they do and what is done to them, then why didn't you see Orca visiting Flower and Melkor for his cop?


Why not? He claimed too early. Is that something Vigs do usually?

And he also failed both times. Depending on his answer, he targeted Cal with no way to bypass the supposed "50% redirect" Cal has.

Do these seem like a town Vig's actions to you?

Mech or just gut feeling?

And what if you get killed this coming night phase?

Not from what we know so far

It's the weapon art of the axes Nepheli has

https://eldenring.wiki.fextralife.com/Thunderstorm
No they're not
Melkor needs to be seriously scrutinized for his play, now and then moreover when I flip town

His shot on me is absolutely baffling
 
Last night(N2)?

Who did you apply the single stack on N1?

This is unrelated to your rot stuff right?
Like this is x shot track ability?
If so why'd you use it on Polar who a lot of people had as town?
Night 1 I didn't do anything because I didn't have access to my role PM until the day started, and kweh didn't do shit


Yeah 3 shot track, and I used it on Polar because I scum read him and frankly I don't care what everyone else thinks because you're all acting like headless chickens this game anyway
 
Night 1 I didn't do anything because I didn't have access to my role PM until the day started, and kweh didn't do shit


Yeah 3 shot track, and I used it on Polar because I scum read him and frankly I don't care what everyone else thinks because you're all acting like headless chickens this game anyway
If you were town why wouldnt you track me

Everyone was suspecting me and all I claimed was a passive that wouldnt count as a visit

Bad
 
Top