Role Madness Elden Ring

Worst

Custom title
Uh, what? York claimed with info against her, where are you getting "volunteering" from?
in the sense of " if york was mafia, by claiming SK they would essentially volunteer one of their memeber for whatever reason " there's no way york gets out of this alive with that claim so why would scum come forward essentially volunteering themselves for an inevitable lynch / vig ?
 
Oh yeah, Sigis must have hit Cal anyhow. If he was redirected onto Town he would have gotten killed. If redirected onto scum he would have killed scum. So my guess is Cal was just protected.
 
This will be the last game I play with Melkor and Flower and probably the last game on this forum

Saying someone thats town is in anti spew and should be ignored when they're trying to give town reads that are against consensus is so fucking disrespectful and demoralizing, who the fuck do these two think they are?

Genuinely considering getting myself modkilled if it wasnt for trying to respect the host because whats the actual point of playing with these fuckwads if they're just gonna ramble on and tell everyone to ignore me

Its obviously redeemable if they're scum but im pretty sure they're not
 
This will be the last game I play with Melkor and Flower and probably the last game on this forum

Saying someone thats town is in anti spew and should be ignored when they're trying to give town reads that are against consensus is so fucking disrespectful and demoralizing, who the fuck do these two think they are?

Genuinely considering getting myself modkilled if it wasnt for trying to respect the host because whats the actual point of playing with these fuckwads if they're just gonna ramble on and tell everyone to ignore me

Its obviously redeemable if they're scum but im pretty sure they're not
Nowhere did I say that. That was just Melkor. I‘m literally working on different scenarios in which you can still be Town, but I just can’t arrive at any. That’s on you to figure out, too, and you’re not helping.
 

Ratchet

The End and the Beginning
in the sense of " if york was mafia, by claiming SK they would essentially volunteer one of their memeber for whatever reason " there's no way york gets out of this alive with that claim so why would scum come forward essentially volunteering themselves for an inevitable lynch / vig ?
Did you read the post you're quoting?
 
Cuz I feel like York having only that probably means she’s either GF or Serial and scans as her fake role because this isn’t enough for a regular scum role tbh.
 

Ratchet

The End and the Beginning
This will be the last game I play with Melkor and Flower and probably the last game on this forum

Saying someone thats town is in anti spew and should be ignored when they're trying to give town reads that are against consensus is so fucking disrespectful and demoralizing, who the fuck do these two think they are?

Genuinely considering getting myself modkilled if it wasnt for trying to respect the host because whats the actual point of playing with these fuckwads if they're just gonna ramble on and tell everyone to ignore me

Its obviously redeemable if they're scum but im pretty sure they're not
Does he post this as scum? Would be pretty low brow I feel.
 
Nowhere did I say that. That was just Melkor. I‘m literally working on different scenarios in which you can still be Town, but I just can’t arrive at any. That’s on you to figure out, too, and you’re not helping.
Almost like Cal is fucking outed and I got Charlie dueled out, and Saber is outed for voting for the Exe, too, BUT FLOWER WHO CALLED THEM OUT IS FUCKING ALIGNED WITH THEM OF COURSE!!!
You can leave her to me honestly. I want to off Cal. I can render York Vanilla so she can’t do shit anymore.
Cal and Saber need to go.
Oh yeah, the guy who didn’t get executed is not outed now.
Already said to nuke Cal and Saber.
You've given zero consideration to any world where im not scum despite me giving the argument why not, in fact your response was to agree with me that executions happen on town town wagons in order to add a frame to the initial kill, you even gave examples, yet continue to consider me outed. You've not even tried to read me outside of this.

Not only do you continue to consider me outed, but youre pushing this view on others too and then trying to absolve any sort of responsibility for it, despite being the high poster this game and making enough annoying shit posts that its impossible for everyone else to ignore.

You will be responsible for my town flip and I hope people consider you as scum and make this game as miserable for you as you've made it for me.
 
You've given zero consideration to any world where im not scum despite me giving the argument why not, in fact your response was to agree with me that executions happen on town town wagons in order to add a frame to the initial kill, you even gave examples, yet continue to consider me outed. You've not even tried to read me outside of this.

Not only do you continue to consider me outed, but youre pushing this view on others too and then trying to absolve any sort of responsibility for it, despite being the high poster this game and making enough annoying shit posts that its impossible for everyone else to ignore.

You will be responsible for my town flip and I hope people consider you as scum and make this game as miserable for you as you've made it for me.
Okay, how would you call somebody who survived an Execute, a Desperado and a Strongman and isn’t doing jack to help people sort this out. Surely you wouldn’t go Damn that’s Town .
 

Worst

Custom title
Because she had info against her which came before the claim, ergo the claim is designed to give her one more go out of a scum role.
Oh i see what u mean now, but still let's think about it

People were already focussed on Cal
She comes forward with that info on Polar bc maybe Cal could be GF and they wanted to protect him

Let's say we followed her and lynched polar, polar flips town both of them are just insta dead

Would that be a good plan to take down 1 town ?
 
Top