Role Madness Elden Ring

I guess you missed the post where I gave my reasoning for the melkor read?

Or just deliberately ignored it even tho it was a few posts after that one?


I thought flower would be scum after Polar flipped town. And worst was the best town read I had. If flower turned out to be town after all, there was a 50% chance she was being truthful about the lightning rod thing. So It was 75% to be a good or neutral choice and 25% to be bad choice.
I don’t think you’re a bad town, but I don’t why exactly you’re talking about probabilities that surely if you’re not informed
 
Luka's Iso is empty and disconnected from the game. I hoped to find more than 15 posts from him, all one liners -.-
It's a coin flip.

I see Red posting and he seems involved on solving which is a plus.

What do we know about the setup? If anything.
Something like censor exists?
 

Worst

Custom title
my guts say Vote Lynch Orca

For the previously discussed reasons and he also basically disappeared from the thread my guess is he's hoping we go for Michelle / Luka
 
there's also hayumi being janitored

why did they bother with that? nobody pushed melkor at all for claiming vig early while scum janitored a role which could have been the town vig.

If they bothered to janitor a random townie in the hopes of getting a mislynch on melkor as town vig, he would have gotten some kind of pressure or push from at least a few scum. i don't remember anything like that happening.
You always janitor a random townie. You janitor the guy + you role cope. There are high chances that there is a scum among people who claimed after this janitor kill. Why did nobody had suspicions on Yoru after this, wth?

Plus, going for a vig who claimed early is clearly dangereous because your play has to follow in the thread and also because players will protect the guy. Same for watchers. Two years ago I played a game on NF and I was the vig, people pushed me to claim Day 1 so after that I had constant protection while I vigged the whole scum team one after another.

If this is your reasoning to suspect Melkor, this is dogshit. And since, I think you’re not bad town as you can say, you’re scum for this.
 
First part of the ISO, Charlie claimed indy and talked very much with Flower. I saw Worst pushing Charlie and Charlie pocketing Worst after that.
Idk how that ended, going further
 
Top