Role Madness Elden Ring

[Jan]

We need to start designing games that favour town more because as it stands now town will never win another game here. Not to say it needs to be unbalanced but I think the weighting needs to be more on town - lower scum numbers, weaker roles, greater risk for scum claiming, etc.

Town had 7 KP this game.
It was swingy townsided as is.

I don't think setup can fix the problems this game had.
People need to talk to each other instead of yelling over each other.
And you need to find a way to deal with inactivity that is not sub out half the game.

 

[Fujishiro]

Town had 7 KP this game.
It was swingy townsided as is.

I don't think setup can fix the problems this game had.
People need to talk to each other instead of yelling over each other.
And you need to find a way to deal with inactivity that is not sub out half the game.

Inactivity was a bit blown out of proportions, only 3-4 slots were inactive and two needed to sub out twice. Other then that things were okay.

 

[Lord Melkor]

I was also on a trip on weekend and kind of last the track of the game state.

 

[Charlie]

I was also saying that he was out of scum range most of the game.

I also shoot scum Night 1 at Charlie.

But yes, not a good game from me overall.

@Fujishiro

Why didn't i die N1?

 

[Ratchet]

We could test run a more town favored setup but like at the end of the day I dont want scum to feel shafted.

Right but at this point in time the entire town just has no motivation, so something has to give.

 

[Fujishiro]

Right but at this point in time the entire town just has no motivation, so something has to give.

I mean they were motivated, then they screwed the pooch multiple times in a row.

@Fujishiro

Why didn't i die N1?

He targetted Cal that same night with his rot ability.

 

[Flower]

Inactivity was a bit blown out of proportions, only 3-4 slots were inactive and two needed to sub out twice. Other then that things were okay.

Inactivity is not just not meeting the requirements or no posting. If people don’t generate readable content that’s inactivity, too. We just need ITAs.

 

[Fujishiro]

Inactivity is not just not meeting the requirements or no posting. If people don’t generate readable content that’s inactivity, too. We just need ITAs.

If people just fluff around its not inactivity as they are still posting.

I dislike ITAs tbh.

 

[Peroroncino]

as for activity my pc died for almost the entirety of the orca lynch when i fixed it the day was over, i can only use my phone here and there since i had left it at home

 

[Flower]

15% base hit rate. If people are in the Top 10% posters they only have a 5% hit rate, lowest 10% it‘s 30%. That’ll motivate people to post.

 

[Fujishiro]

Group L is tough

L seems to be the toughest after that its ours or I

 

[Fujishiro]

15% base hit rate. If people are in the Top 10% posters they only have a 5% hit rate, lowest 10% it‘s 30%. That’ll motivate people to post.

I implemented an activity vig in the HP game, might do it again idk. Or some sort of activity related mechanic.

 

[Flower]

Can also give the Top 10% full on immunity.

 

[Jan]

If people just fluff around its not inactivity as they are still posting.

I dislike ITAs tbh.

Itas are great for really big mashes but I don't know if that would be good here.

2 different vigshots landing on cals role and 2 KP on 3p York was overall a big problem.

Some KP or lynches have to be used on slots that are not active enough.
You can't be heroes all the time. Sometimes you have to do the dirty work.

 

[Jan]

L seems to be the toughest after that its ours or I

I would not want to face Norway or France but it really depends on the last team.

 

[Jan]

Can also give the Top 10% full on immunity.

Teach people to police.
Or normalize slank vigs.

 

[Flower]

I implemented an activity vig in the HP game, might do it again idk. Or some sort of activity related mechanic.

That’s just a role ability. It should be something which both kills low posters and also incentivizes and rewards people for posting a lot.

 

[Peroroncino]

what was my hidden ability btw

 

[Fujishiro]

Itas are great for really big mashes but I don't know if that would be good here.

2 different vigshots landing on cals role and 2 KP on 3p York was overall a big problem.

Some KP or lynches have to be used on slots that are not active enough.
You can't be heroes all the time. Sometimes you have to do the dirty work.

Yep vigs should clear out LHF POE slots, people kept targetting Cal after he claimed the passive redirect which in of itself is a problem.

 

[Flower]

Also Slank Vigs are player controlled. It should be put in the hands of the entire Town to decide.