Role Madness Elden Ring

[The Orca]

No, keeping Yoho alive after he claimed wouldve led to two back to back nights mate.

So. What was the difference. Town lynching town and town killing town. Sorry you use the moves at hand to catch someone killing him

 

[Flower]

Issue is, some people do make posts, but don’t contribute much and remain a null read for most people. It’s effectively a coin flip. If you don’t include KP or invests on these slots you have to waste a lynch on a coin flip. But that should always be available. If one player is a Slank Vig and dies the role is gone. It can also be messed with which isn’t the point either. So it needs to be something that’s in the game until the end or until half the PL is dead or something and can’t be interfered with or protected from. Or you include more investigative roles with reliable invests that can’t be interfered with. There is literally no way to deal with such slots otherwise.

 

[Fujishiro]

Never. You don't lynch town that you know should be town. You watch and protect them...hell there was a lightning rod to remove strongman possibility. Mafia was gonna have to be caught to kill him

You DID NOT have to lynch him

Scum almost always have the means to kill someone if they want to at night. On the night of the lightning rod even @Jan forgot that @Worst for example was redirect immune.

 

[Fujishiro]

So. What was the difference. Town lynching town and town killing town. Sorry you use the moves at hand to catch someone killing him

Town lynches Yoho = They get a day 2 and maybe lynch scum which did happen with Charlie.
Town doesnt lynch Yoho = Two nights of scum killing and Charlie may or may not be outed day 3.

 

[The Orca]

Scum almost always have the means to kill someone if they want to at night. On the night of the lightning rod even @Jan forgot that @Worst for example was redirect immune.

Doesn't change the fact you don't lynch him.

 

[Worst]

Scum almost always have the means to kill someone if they want to at night. On the night of the lightning rod even @Jan forgot that @Worst for example was redirect immune.

damn can u believe i didn't even read this ?

Kingly disposition: You cannot be redirected.

i was too focussed on this xD

Regal resilience: Your role cannot be destroyed.

 

[Fujishiro]

Issue is, some people do make posts, but don’t contribute much and remain a null read for most people. It’s effectively a coin flip. If you don’t include KP or invests on these slots you have to waste a lynch on a coin flip. But that should always be available. If one player is a Slank Vig and dies the role is gone. It can also be messed with which isn’t the point either. So it needs to be something that’s in the game until the end or until half the PL is dead or something and can’t be interfered with or protected from. Or you include more investigative roles with reliable invests that can’t be interfered with. There is literally no way to deal with such slots otherwise.

Slank mechanics are the solution.

 

[Fujishiro]

Doesn't change the fact you don't lynch him.

Youre not presenting any argument lmao.

 

[Fujishiro]

damn can u believe i didn't even read this ?




i was too focussed on this xD

I can believe it lol.

 

[Polar Bear]

I don't care if we punish low posters, but rewarding high posters will be nothing but detrimental to our games

As a constant low poster, you really like punishment don't ya 👀

Ok ill stop now, it was just a lay up. Have a good rest the day everyone!

 

[Flower]

Another alternative is bringing back dead player subs. Or straight up modkilling if a player is no posting for over 24h.

 

[The Orca]

Town lynches Yoho = They get a day 2 and maybe lynch scum which did happen with Charlie.
Town doesnt lynch Yoho = Two nights of scum killing and Charlie may or may not be outed day 3.

That's revisionist. Did town have a watcher? Protection? Lighting rod? Yes you don't lynch Yoho and use moves in a smart way you have could have maybe another mafia.

 

[Fujishiro]

That's revisionist. Did town have a watcher? Protection? Lighting rod? Yes you don't lynch Yoho and use moves in a smart way you have could have maybe another mafia.

Scum has a ninja,strongman, redirect immunity,etc. If they want you dead especially early they will find a way. The risk is too high.

 

[The Orca]

Youre not presenting any argument lmao.

I already said and said it during g the game...if you want to fuck over Town having the role...Town has to have moves to help catch mafia shooting him. Unless its a bad setup I guess

 

[Jan]

Scum almost always have the means to kill someone if they want to at night. On the night of the lightning rod even @Jan forgot that @Worst for example was redirect immune.

Fair.
The local mech gods work in different ways from my own, which lead to slight struggles here and there.

 

[The Orca]

Scum has a ninja,strongman, redirect immunity,etc. If they want you dead especially early they will find a way. The risk is too high.

So bad setup, got it

 

[Flower]

That's revisionist. Did town have a watcher? Protection? Lighting rod? Yes you don't lynch Yoho and use moves in a smart way you have could have maybe another mafia.

Stop arguing against common sense.

 

[Fujishiro]

I already said and said it during g the game...if you want to fuck over Town having the role...Town has to have moves to help catch mafia shooting him. Unless its a bad setup I guess

The point wasnt to fuck over town for having the role, the role had its uses with the roleblock and the revive. Im saying that when his beloved princess debuff is out in the open then the risk for keeping him alive is way too high.

 

[Fujishiro]

So bad setup, got it

Lmao. So you think town should just freely claim beloved princess and not get punished for it?

 

[Flower]

When a Beloved Princess is claimed you lynch them. It‘s a shit role, but that’s how it goes. It‘s even recommended to get that out asap.