[FNZ] Super Role Madness Naruto Shippuden: An Alternate Universe Mafia Game Thread [Game Ended - Mafia Win]

Status
Not open for further replies.
And...

I jailed Juice during the day at like 11:30 through the night phase, so by my logic and how I'm used to games being played, they couldn't veto the lynch because day ended after they were jailed. Now Ekko could have messed up or allowed moves to be entered before they actually can happen, but I have actual knowledge of a good chance Juice did not do it. Regardless of the phase today I'm still saying that, so no, they weren't outed by that. They drew attention to themselves and imo want to be lynched/killed...which leads to the scum who can't die likelihood

So basically I used my brain and didn't follow the group think for the sake of it
The Raikage has veto'ed the lynch.
Raikage: @CakeWalker
 
Part of the reason for these questions is this is what you said for ratchet. Ratchet youre familiar with. I think ratchet by some margin is the best town player in the game(that im aware of). He's also probably the best scum player.

One vote is enough to sway you to put 6 other players ahead of him in poe, which is kinda nuts. I dont think ratchet has done a whole lot so it just seems a bit of a generous read. If im wrong im more than willing to hear why.
I wouldn't say that I know ratchet well.
I think we played some games way back when we were young (old thingyman mashes on mu).
But I never had him as best anything in my book.
Not to disrespect he was a balanced player from my pov.

If you think that 6 is a lot then you did not pay attention tbh.

I think cake + Michelle are the next 2.
You are likely following after, unless something happens to change my perspective.
Add boa to the list.

And then some maybes like RA, (at the time) Orca, Brad (if michelle flips town).
It is easy to think Ratchet has several people ahead of him as of right now.

I don't even know what this pointless question about order is supposed to get you?
More busywork than usefulness, and that is my core problem with you.
 
No particular order within tiers

Town:

Jan
Daniel
Charlie
Hayumi
The Orca
Shuijing
Shanks (probably)

Lean Town:

Neeko
Polar Bear


Null:

Yoho
Ratchet
Naomi

Lean Mafia:

Fujishiro
Flower
Michelle

Mafia:

BradLand
Alexis
Cake
 
Of course. Nothing better to do at 1 am.

+

In itself not condemning, but I thought your initial read was not good and remembered questioning your list at the time.
I dont think my read was a throwaway comment. If someone lacks activity im going to look at the useful bits of what they say and that felt like something to read them off of. Felt good about it. I was wrong about it but again it was worth looking into.

The Hayumi line adds to it, because you need a scum game to judge a player that is playing the game, and you read a player that is not playing the game based on a throwaway comment.
It was strong enough to put it in your townreads without any additional comment.
I have lower opinions on inactive players then active ones. Active players can be more dangerous to carelessly town lead as they actually influence the game. Ive also played with hayumi twice so I have somewhat of a basis for them as town. The other player I have never played with so I have no basis to read them from.




Out of order. There is more, but this is the important parts..
You were very focused on the whole cake (island) thing and doubtcasting some of it while keeping your options open.
Keeping options open can also be trying to determine things, no? I mean that is me playing the game. Cant knock your interpretation of it.

I know it was one of the main topics, but to me it felt like your focus this game has been a bit limited.
Maybe that is because I tried to ignore all the 3p yapping after a while and missed something useful.

And you called Michelle your most likely scum while Cake was under pressure. Weird move tbh.
I called michelle scum before majority. There were 7 scum players alive. Why would me calling her out as scum be weird at all when we're looking for a lot of scum lol. Juice does dumb shit, meanwhile michelle has an activity tell. I dont see the issue with me being confident about michelle, especially when you just town read ratchet for voting a scum player day 1 which was away from the focus of the game at the time(bitter).
 
Isn't it normal for a jailer to picka target at night, but only block during the night?
Which means any EoD trigger happens regardless because End of DAY is part of the day.
 

Fujishiro

Cheese for everyone!
And...

I jailed Juice during the day at like 11:30 through the night phase, so by my logic and how I'm used to games being played, they couldn't veto the lynch because day ended after they were jailed. Now Ekko could have messed up or allowed moves to be entered before they actually can happen, but I have actual knowledge of a good chance Juice did not do it. Regardless of the phase today I'm still saying that, so no, they weren't outed by that. They drew attention to themselves and imo want to be lynched/killed...which leads to the scum who can't die likelihood

So basically I used my brain and didn't follow the group think for the sake of it
They are the raikage.
 
I dont think my read was a throwaway comment. If someone lacks activity im going to look at the useful bits of what they say and that felt like something to read them off of. Felt good about it. I was wrong about it but again it was worth looking into.



I have lower opinions on inactive players then active ones. Active players can be more dangerous to carelessly town lead as they actually influence the game. Ive also played with hayumi twice so I have somewhat of a basis for them as town. The other player I have never played with so I have no basis to read them from.






Keeping options open can also be trying to determine things, no? I mean that is me playing the game. Cant knock your interpretation of it.



I called michelle scum before majority. There were 7 scum players alive. Why would me calling her out as scum be weird at all when we're looking for a lot of scum lol. Juice does dumb shit, meanwhile michelle has an activity tell. I dont see the issue with me being confident about michelle, especially when you just town read ratchet for voting a scum player day 1 which was away from the focus of the game at the time(bitter).
The last part about michelle is the part about you thatmakes me doubt myself.

And the kage duell claim fiasco.
I think an experienced player can fake that (I have faked worse), which lessens the cred.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top