[FNZ] Super Role Madness Pokemon: I choose you!

Status
Not open for further replies.
Juliet

Hayumi
Shuijing


The Orca
Flower
Mr. Reloaded

JustJuice/Hime
Alwaysmind
Yoho
Charlie
Marimo_42
Jan
Pot Goblin
Handium/Luka
Ratchet
Rej

Dr_Professor/tepig19283

gingerbread
bittersweet
RippedCal

York
Michelle/TAG
Crying bc no Cryo

Naomi
Id move Luka green. He did a 1020 uturn when I asked for something simple. Usually town indicative with him

Also, why Cal green? He doesn't seem like his usual self at times
 
I looked through your first post on day 1 and you didn't elaborate much on Naomi that bothered you. Are you town reading her or not. From the way how I'm interpreting your post, looked like to me you don't have a read on her.
I have to admit, I'm not entirely sure what you're asking here. For ease of answering, I've quoted my post regarding Naomi's opening posts.

Naomi
I was a little concerned by her post number #52 in which she states she would happily join a wagon on Alexis if somebody starts one. To me this feels a bit disingenuous, because if she truly thought Alexis was scum, why could she not start a wagon herself? I don't know whether this comes from lack of confidence in her read or attempted opportunism - I'm tempted to go with the former, because to actually state that she would join a wagon on Alexis started by somebody else would probably be something scum would not announce in advance. I have a note pertaining to Cryo/Naomi interactions around post #157 that if Cryo is scum then Naomi is town.
You can think of this as a sort of 'stream of consciousness' log. To clarify:

I was initially concerned by her post 52, in which she stated she would happily join a wagon on Alex if somebody started one.

I thought to myself, "if she's that concerned about Alex, why doesn't she start a wagon herself?"

Then I wondered, "what does scum-Naomi benefit from following somebody else onto Alex, after explicitly stating that she would follow somebody else onto Alex? It looks very suspicious"

Then I concluded that her saying that is more likely to come from a town than a scum, because the chances are greater that a scum would just *do it* and not *announce they will do it*

This now leads me to where I am at this juncture; suspecting that Naomi is town, and hoping that we can engage in some meaningful dialogue to properly find each other.

Does that clarify my thought process for you?
 
Too friendly in a way that makes it seem fake.
Like someone wearing a face to hide their own.

The amount of your participation is just fine. Your approach is throwing me a bit off, and your lack of consistency.
You started with the notes you metioned, and then changed your playstyle by notreally improving a lot of your reads or at least not being all that public about your changes
I apologise if my friendly tone offends you. You are free to think I'm concealing things if you wish.

I'm afraid I can't help my "lack of consistency".

I explicitly stated that I was not fully caught up on the game state, and thus gave my vote to gingerbread to direct a he wished.

As for "not being all that public about your changes..." I stated in this very game thread the people that I town-read, the people that I would not be willing to vote, and the people I would be happy voting.

I can't get more public than that without pinging the entire player list and making my font size 26 and bolded.

My ISO isn't large; it shouldn't take you very long to dig up my reads, if you are truly interested.
 
@gingerbread

I have to depart for RL-commitments now. I'll pop back in when I can, but I can't guarantee I'll be here at end of day. So for now I'll leave my vote where it is, but if you'd like me to move it, please ping me where to move it to.

As of right now I would be fine lynching Rej, Hayumi or Juice. I've already outlined my concerns about Juliet but will put those aside for now, as well as my concerns about Handium (on Flowers' recommendation).

Other than gingerbread, my towns today would be Ratchet, Flower, Alex/Watson, and some 'okay' vibes from both York and Cryo, so I won't sheep onto any of those players.
Here we are.

Ratchet is not the most agreed with read after his drop off, why is he town to you exactly?
(I had him as town early, but I am curious about your take)

What baout york did you like? she has way less activity and without meta knowledge, is an odd pick for a townread.
 
Id move Luka green. He did a 1020 uturn when I asked for something simple. Usually town indicative with him

Also, why Cal green? He doesn't seem like his usual self at times
Moved cal green early, some good and some bad. His unwillingness to assert himself and lead tends to lean town for him, as does his early mia. The rest of the day he swapped between good and questionable. Had a good thought in the 12 hour night chat about the folks bailing on reloaded looking bad bc his claim was terrible
 
Moved cal green early, some good and some bad. His unwillingness to assert himself and lead tends to lean town for him, as does his early mia. The rest of the day he swapped between good and questionable. Had a good thought in the 12 hour night chat about the folks bailing on reloaded looking bad bc his claim was terrible
that is scum imo UwU
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top