[FNZ] Super Role Madness Pokemon: I choose you!

[Naomi]

Want pressure on Cryo, don't really understand the Watson kill, would also like to see how AM grew so much because he was a clear leading wagon when there really wasn't much to achieve consensus from him. Makes me think scum were probably in danger at one point and consolidated on him.

watson subbed in for alex


UwU

 

[Naomi]

guessing legendary pokemon would be scum range.


UwU

 

[Ratchet]

Also I can't quite put my finger on it but I have a jard time trusting Jan so far. There is a sense I'm getting where they feel "held back", like they're being really careful with what they say and how they say it in a way that feels positional. Last game I didn't get that at all from them. Granted I was scum but the direct decisive solviness feels absent so far, that's the best way I can put it into words.

 

[Ratchet]

Why does the Watson kill confuse you, she was the most confirmed player in the game

Because it doesn't really work as a safe kill and it doesn't really work as a kill aimed to set anything up. If you're going to use a janitor why use it on someone likely to draw protection or watchers over someone who isn't but is also going to be hard to push.

 

[Flower]

Also I can't quite put my finger on it but I have a jard time trusting Jan so far. There is a sense I'm getting where they feel "held back", like they're being really careful with what they say and how they say it in a way that feels positional. Last game I didn't get that at all from them. Granted I was scum but the direct decisive solviness feels absent so far, that's the best way I can put it into words.

Do you have a full reads list?

 

[Pot Goblin]

do you still have 1 shot of it?

Yea I have shots of that left

 

[Charlie]

Does nobody else have any info so far?

i mean, you're watcher

tracker could just be mafia then

investigator either is inactive or got blocked/hit innocent target

idk if there would be other informative roles tbh

 

[Crying bc no Cryo]

Why not say so yesterday?

I thought I did? I never had u in my town list for it and I even put u in my guess of what the scum team is iirc

 

[Ratchet]

Do you have a full reads list?

I gave one yesterday, it hasn't really changed. Maybe add Shuijin to light town, the rest I'll need to see if/when I can read more.

Hayumi is getting more into firm scum read too I guess, showed up to defend himself and then vanished again, amd the reason for not voting was kinda lame.

 

[Charlie]

Yea I have shots of that left

if you have no better ideas, i could maybe take one from you

like, if not, that's cool too

don't confirm or deny it in thread to not make it too easy for scum, just something for you to keep in consideration

 

[ThatAverageGuy]

Also I can't quite put my finger on it but I have a jard time trusting Jan so far. There is a sense I'm getting where they feel "held back", like they're being really careful with what they say and how they say it in a way that feels positional.

Strange that you say that, because I had that feeling as well. I wasn't able to verbalise it adequately in my own mind, but this does encapsulate my feelings quite well.

 

[Flower]

I gave one yesterday, it hasn't really changed. Maybe add Shuijin to light town, the rest I'll need to see if/when I can read more.

Hayumi is getting more into firm scum read too I guess, showed up to defend himself and then vanished again, amd the reason for not voting was kinda lame.

Okay, please give your thoughts once you’ve caught up.

 

[ThatAverageGuy]

It sounds as if Flower/Pot Goblin should be confirmed town now - shy of any sort of scum plotting, of course.

Does anyone disagree? I'm not someone who has played a massive amount of role madness, so I rely on others to tell me if I've potentially miscleared someone via mechanics.

 

[Charlie]

Town
- Charlie
- York
- Juliet
- Cal
- ThatAverageGuy
- Ratchet
- Tepig
- Cryo
- Shujing

Wolves:
- Jan

Null
- Naomi
- Yoho
- Polar
- Reloaded
- Flower
- Orca
- Rej
- Hayumi
- Gingerbread
- Bittersweet
- Marmio
- Pot Goblin

i have vague, mech-ish reason to believe jan is town

won't elaborate since it's srm and all kinds of abilities are thrown around, but like, i guess it's something you might find useful

 

[Ratchet]

Okay, please give your thoughts once you’ve caught up.

Will have to be tomorrow, otherwise I've given them lol. Main thing really I want to see is the growth of the AM wagon because it was abnormal for the level of suspicion against him, usually you see people going to bat for that type or even scum flexing tmi over it, instead there was basically nothing. I felt quietly confident that it was a hit only for it not to be. Which means to me there was a vested scum interest in that wagon not changing.

 

[gingerbread]

It sounds as if Flower/Pot Goblin should be confirmed town now - shy of any sort of scum plotting, of course.

Does anyone disagree? I'm not someone who has played a massive amount of role madness, so I rely on others to tell me if I've potentially miscleared someone via mechanics.

I treat mech as a decent hint, but not as something confirmed for live tbh in these setups. Using abilities for credit is common.

 

[RippedCal]

i mean, you're watcher

tracker could just be mafia then

investigator either is inactive or got blocked/hit innocent target

idk if there would be other informative roles tbh

No she's not

 

[Naomi]

wondering if i got redirected...


UwU

 

[ThatAverageGuy]

I treat mech as a decent hint, but not as something confirmed for live tbh in these setups. Using abilities for credit is common.

Very well. That's good to know.

 

[Jan]

It sounds as if Flower/Pot Goblin should be confirmed town now - shy of any sort of scum plotting, of course.

Does anyone disagree? I'm not someone who has played a massive amount of role madness, so I rely on others to tell me if I've potentially miscleared someone via mechanics.

If cryo is scum, then yes.
if cryo is town then pot could go either way.