[FNZ] Super Role Madness Pokemon: I choose you!

Status
Not open for further replies.
Anyhow, I dunno what to make of Crying. I think as scum with fairly damning mech he‘d be more likely to stop trying eventually, but he’s still going which puts me on the fence.
 
An interesting pick-up. I also pay attention to when players ping each other seemingly at random and question what their motives in doing so might be, so this is a +1 from me.



I feel that Shuijing is pointing out here that bittersweet is attempting to white-knight Naomi. I'll need to re-read the interaction again but I do recall thinking at the time that bittersweet's post was a very reasonable* stance to take at that point.

*reasonable does not always mean town. Reasonable takes are often easy for scum to make in order to appear pro-town.



I'm not sure on bittersweet yet, I'll need to read their ISO later, but I can at least see the train of thought that led Shui to this conclusion.



A very reasonable* stance to take. I would've preferred it if Shui offered up some thoughts on my reads at this point so that I'd have something to judge him by, but I think that the slight paranoia is warranted.

*reasonable in this instance is more likely +town because it pertains to a read of a specific player and not just generic "offing people early is bad" macro read. I hope that makes sense.



Now, this one could go either way for me. Town-Shui being worried that a wall-posting replacement may be pocketing his fellow towns... or scum-Shui worried that a wall-posting replacement is being widely town-read for an entry post.

I'll reserve judgment for now. I will point out, however, that I too thought Flowers' town-read of me came very easily based off a single post. Either that or the bar for scum-sub entry posts is extremely low here.

(on a veeery slightly positive note, does scum-Shui see me picking up suspicion and votes from Naomi and Alex, and just completely ignore me? Or does scum-Shui use that momentum to get more suspicion on me going. Not sure either way, and I think if I was to say 'no' I might be conf-biasing myself a little bit into *wanting* Shui to be town to reduce my PoE at this stage)



This questioning is consistent with Shui's expressed skepticism of "easy" town-reads. There is paranoia here that I don't think is feigned, and I believe this interaction shows Shui is unpaired with both Naomi and Juliet.

@Pot Goblin This is where I'm up to on Shuijing's ISO so far. I welcome your thoughts and any continuation you might be able to provide.

I have to go to work soon so I'll finish up when I return.
Thanks for the analysis, think from what you brought up I'm probably leaning more town there if anything imo
I'm not sure what's in scum Shui's repertoire but from what I've seen the little things you pointed out them doing is points in there favor. It feels natural rather than calculated if that makes sense, easy to miss too.
 
And I find that certain players having to have to be asked for reads to reveal them very, hmm, peculiar phenomenon, for lack of better words.

Let's take Yoho. Yoho is lurking the thread most of the time. When asked for reads, he'll provide something. So he has some. But he doesn't want to provide them out of his own incentive. What's the reason for this if he's town? Is he so shy? Is he so lazy? So self conscious What does he expect to happen? Does he love the attention of being asked something then providing an answer?

Truly, infinite are the secrets of the universe.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top