I'm going to be contrarian (again?) and disagree with your (implied) scum-read on York, gingerbread.
I think it is a *very* bold move from scum to come into Day 2 specifically calling out the fact that nobody is pressuring them. I know this is probably WIFOM, but in that situation, I think most scum players would be content to let the lack of suspicion on them lie, and then find a way to ease themselves into a relevant topic of conversation and slowly regain some thread presence, rather than just announce "Hey, I'm here, why is nobody scum-reading me?"
I think it belies a town awareness of the general game-state.