[FNZ] Super Role Madness Pokemon: I choose you!

[gingerbread]

I guess we can for today have a "working theory" that Orca is town, being the major counterwagon to scum yesterday

is Polar still clearing Orca?

 

[BigTimeAnimeMan]

I was convinced N3 that Orca and PB were scum so I targeted them

And after my big reevaluation last night I thought GB was scum and could handle a PR

So you paid no mind whatsoever to what they’d claimed when you made these decisions lol?

 

[Crying bc no Cryo]

My past few days have also been lackluster, and as I have already mentioned to (IIRC) Flower and Hayumi, I do not use "activity levels" to judge alignment, because Real Life does happen and I am not going to punish anybody for prioritising that stuff over a game.

Luke died with more than one player as a suspect. If you really want to push a case against ginger, why not also point out how he went for a non-Rej slot (Shui/BTAM) on the day we lynched scum? Surely that is an equally compelling argument, is it not?

I’m not the king of mafia nor do I claim to be

I’m literally just trying to use process of elimination first and then go from there

 

[Flower]

Hmmm, why did they kill Melkor.

 

[Crying bc no Cryo]

@Ratchet
Charlie - cop
PB - cop clear
Hayumi - cop clear
Reloaded - unpaired from Yoho
BTAM - unpaired from Yoho
LM - spewed town by Yoho
Hime - parked vote on both scum so far. Doubt they’re a hellbusser

POE
Ratchet
GB
Orca
Cal
BS
TAG
Flower
York



Orca and TAG are unpaired for TAG questioning the mech on Orca so much

BTAM and Yoho are unpaired cuz why would BTAM immediately throw shade on Yoho right after subbing in?

York and GB are unpaired cuz why shoot your partner? Or why fake shooting your partner?

cal and orca has had cal in POE sus pile the entire game

Flower and BS are unpaired cuz I doubt partners blatantly shield each other this long

Yoho and Reloaded are unpaired cuz Yoho was Reloaded’s main suspect D1 and D2

Yoho and LM are unpaired cuz Yoho had LM as top tr all of D1

York and Cal are unpaired cuz he was sussing York since the start of D1

GB Orca unpaired via mech

 

[ThatAverageGuy]

I did my solving last night and found via unpairings the only possible team is ratchet GB Cal BS and TAG

Yesterday you said that Orca and Cal were unpaired because Orca had Cal in his PoE since Day 1.

But I've had bittersweet in my PoE since Day 1. In fact, I think I had bittersweet in my PoE potentially before Orca had Cal in his.

So why does Orca having Cal in PoE clear them as unpaired, yet me having bitter in PoE does not clear us?

I can't follow your logic when you apply it selectively like this.

 

[York]

What counts as offensive ability?

I shall ask

 

[ThatAverageGuy]

Hmmm, why did they kill Melkor.

Unsure. He was Naomi, widely TR'd by the entire list, and possibly a protection-dodge?

Very odd that he wasn't even cleared from voting Yoho, though.

 

[gingerbread]

"Dragon Breath: Target a player and paralyze them for the night.[3-Shots]

Tri-Attack: Target a player and you will have a 20% chance each of either paralyzing them, freezing them or burning them.[3-Shots]"


This is from Naomi role, she said she targeted RippedCal n2 {or n1?}. I wondered with which one, but she said that Cal didn't say anything about it and it's bad. But I guess Cal could have not known if he was" put lowest" in actions resolution (paralyze). Something I wanted to check, but turns out nothingburger.

 

[Ratchet]

@Ratchet
Charlie - cop
PB - cop clear
Hayumi - cop clear
Reloaded - unpaired from Yoho
BTAM - unpaired from Yoho
LM - spewed town by Yoho
Hime - parked vote on both scum so far. Doubt they’re a hellbusser

POE
Ratchet
GB
Orca
Cal
BS
TAG
Flower
York



Orca and TAG are unpaired for TAG questioning the mech on Orca so much

BTAM and Yoho are unpaired cuz why would BTAM immediately throw shade on Yoho right after subbing in?

York and GB are unpaired cuz why shoot your partner? Or why fake shooting your partner?

cal and orca has had cal in POE sus pile the entire game

Flower and BS are unpaired cuz I doubt partners blatantly shield each other this long

Yoho and Reloaded are unpaired cuz Yoho was Reloaded’s main suspect D1 and D2

Yoho and LM are unpaired cuz Yoho had LM as top tr all of D1

York and Cal are unpaired cuz he was sussing York since the start of D1

GB Orca unpaired via mech

Few things:
Where has bittersweet shielded flower?
Why is BTAM shading Yoho clearing for a player of his caliber?
Why not fake shooting if there is a claim from your deep scummate to hide it? Even better if he has kill immunity baked in.

 

[Charlie]

@Ratchet
Charlie - cop
PB - cop clear
Hayumi - cop clear
Reloaded - unpaired from Yoho
BTAM - unpaired from Yoho
LM - spewed town by Yoho
Hime - parked vote on both scum so far. Doubt they’re a hellbusser

POE
Ratchet
GB
Orca
Cal
BS
TAG
Flower
York



Orca and TAG are unpaired for TAG questioning the mech on Orca so much

BTAM and Yoho are unpaired cuz why would BTAM immediately throw shade on Yoho right after subbing in?

York and GB are unpaired cuz why shoot your partner? Or why fake shooting your partner?

cal and orca has had cal in POE sus pile the entire game

Flower and BS are unpaired cuz I doubt partners blatantly shield each other this long

Yoho and Reloaded are unpaired cuz Yoho was Reloaded’s main suspect D1 and D2

Yoho and LM are unpaired cuz Yoho had LM as top tr all of D1

York and Cal are unpaired cuz he was sussing York since the start of D1

GB Orca unpaired via mech

GB is just as COP clear as PB and Hayumi. Even more so, since in his case I know for sure i couldn't be redirected

 

[Flower]

Unsure. He was Naomi, widely TR'd by the entire list, and possibly a protection-dodge?

Very odd that he wasn't even cleared from voting Yoho, though.

Probably means we still have protections then. Which is good.

 

[gingerbread]

And Cryo, I've been questioning Orca's mech just as much as TAG I think, and you again unpair Tag and Orca for this but not me I think? Indeed selective logic :p

Like, I think we had that convo before, but I can quote you actual stuff. I'm writing this not because I demand to be townread but prodding your logic.

 

[BigTimeAnimeMan]

Few things:
Where has bittersweet shielded flower?
Why is BTAM shading Yoho clearing for a player of his caliber?
Why not fake shooting if there is a claim from your deep scummate to hide it? Even better if he has kill immunity baked in.

Yoho was the first player I sussed when I repped in, but also I pretty much led the lynch there yesterday

 

[gingerbread]

GB is just as COP clear as PB and Hayumi. Even more so, since in his case I know for sure i couldn't be redirected

Ahh you checked me? I missed that. Didn't catch up everything and just skimmed. Thanks Charlie.

 

[Crying bc no Cryo]

@Ratchet But basically my solving process was this:

take the ppl I think are town
Charlie
Hayumi
PB
Hime
BTAM
Reloaded
Me

there’s 1players left and I know I’m town
So POE is
York
Ratchet
Cal
Orca
TAG
Flower
BS
GB

i used my combinations calculator on planetcalc.com to list out all 56 possible teams

I used the notes of all the unpairings I found to remove any teams that had the unpaired ppl listed as partners

I repeated the process until only one team remained

 

[Flower]

Yoho was the first player I sussed when I repped in, but also I pretty much led the lynch there yesterday

Hey, I helped, too.

 

[Crying bc no Cryo]

Just highlight it in your post field and click remove formatting.

I can’t click ive been phoneposting all game

 

[ThatAverageGuy]

GB is just as COP clear as PB and Hayumi. Even more so, since in his case I know for sure i couldn't be redirected

Outside of your mech on Polar and Hayumi, what do you think of their actual content/posts?

 

[Crying bc no Cryo]

So you paid no mind whatsoever to what they’d claimed when you made these decisions lol?

Yeah I literally just used POE and unpairings