[FNZ] Super Role Madness Pokemon: I choose you!

[ThatAverageGuy]

@Flower @gingerbread

Help me put this tinfoil to rest.

Is there ever a world in which scum-Charlie claims Cop? Fakes a town-read (real) on Jan for N1. Then fakes town-reads on scum-Polar and scum-Hayumi for N2 and N3? Offing Jan in the process in order to make his Cop-claim look more valid?

I haven't actually checked these players for unpairings much. But how likely is this to be an actual thing?

 

[ThatAverageGuy]

Still would rather check Crying but i couldn't.

Why couldn't you check Crying?

 

[Charlie]

Why couldn't you check Crying?

Because he never said that he's town

 

[ThatAverageGuy]

Why couldn't you check Crying?

Nevermind, I remember you said you couldn't find Crying saying he was town.

 

[Crying bc no Cryo]

Because he never said that he's town

i'm town

there u go

 

[ThatAverageGuy]

i'm town

there u go

Too late.

 

[RippedCal]

Please never lie detect me

 

[Charlie]

i'm town

there u go

Well, lie detect thing is exactly the reason why i start games like this:

20 pages already? O:

Hello, what's up, i'm town and all that

 

[Mr. Reloaded]

I knew a town once

 

[hime]

Me for a start, your read on me is that you haven't noticed me which you say isnt alignment indicative but somehow im trending down?

Also pretty much all you've done today is ponder mech that youre confused about

Id have thought you'd have some more opinions on the players in the game after you just claimed to read 75 pages

if u go from town to null, u trended down
idk what is so confusing abt that
if someone is playing in a way that u find neither townie nor scummy, they r null

also yea, i focused on mech
i always pay attention to mech in srm
my opinions of players has largely been unchanged even with my catch up

 

[gingerbread]

@Flower @gingerbread

Help me put this tinfoil to rest.

Is there ever a world in which scum-Charlie claims Cop? Fakes a town-read (real) on Jan for N1. Then fakes town-reads on scum-Polar and scum-Hayumi for N2 and N3? Offing Jan in the process in order to make his Cop-claim look more valid?

I haven't actually checked these players for unpairings much. But how likely is this to be an actual thing?

I thought about this but his usage on Jan was pretty pro town. Jan was getting trouble and Charlie was saving him from a lim with his mech. Seems counterintuitive. Also overall Charlie was a bit ballsy this game. What gave me pause is that he had 4 shots (!). But then I thought it can be explained by scum team having multiple potential means to make his checks unsure.

 

[hime]

@Flower @gingerbread

Help me put this tinfoil to rest.

Is there ever a world in which scum-Charlie claims Cop? Fakes a town-read (real) on Jan for N1. Then fakes town-reads on scum-Polar and scum-Hayumi for N2 and N3? Offing Jan in the process in order to make his Cop-claim look more valid?

I haven't actually checked these players for unpairings much. But how likely is this to be an actual thing?

charlie would not fake cop i believe
thats so risky

 

[gingerbread]

saving him from a lim

maybe I exaggerated but I think scum team would like Jan to be under fire

 

[gingerbread]

Anyway I think mech on Hayumi is least "sure" (not counting myself)

it could have been very obvious for scum team to figure him out by that point

 

[RippedCal]

if u go from town to null, u trended down
idk what is so confusing abt that
if someone is playing in a way that u find neither townie nor scummy, they r null

also yea, i focused on mech
i always pay attention to mech in srm
my opinions of players has largely been unchanged even with my catch up

I dont think I knew you had me town,
Can you quote that read with the reasons pls

 

[ThatAverageGuy]

Charlie, let me put a scenario to you.

You've lie-detected a player as town. Let's call this player bingergread.

You also suspect another player might be town, despite some paranoia. Let's call this player AboveAverageGuy (thanks BTAM).

These are the only two players in the game who seem willing to defend a third player whom everybody else suspects. Let's call this player Happy bc Cryo.

If Happy turns out to be scum, what does this mean for bingergread and Above? And since Happy has been *very* highly suspected since D2, which do you think are the players who decided to bus him early?

If Happy turns out to be town, same questions.

 

[RippedCal]

As for the mech youre just tinfoiling and the fact you cant figure it out probably means there are pieces missing so you'd be better off spending your time reading players since there are 446 pages worth of posts to parse

 

[RippedCal]

Still dont think Orca or Polar are scum based on their posts

 

[Charlie]

I thought about this but his usage on Jan was pretty pro town. Jan was getting trouble and Charlie was saving him from a lim with his mech. Seems counterintuitive. Also overall Charlie was a bit ballsy this game. What gave me pause is that he had 4 shots (!). But then I thought it can be explained by scum team having multiple potential means to make his checks unsure.

I had 3 shots of cop, 1 shot of night chat, 2 shots of protection steal and locked ability that was either protection or lie detect.

charlie would not fake cop i believe
thats so risky

Actually i once faked being psychic for shets and giggles and it worked.

 

[ThatAverageGuy]

Cal, I also mentioned in my post this morning that you had been trending down for me.

Why is your focus on hime for saying that, but you have no questions for me about the same?