Controversial CMV: Kishimoto Writes women better than Lolda

BoaHancocksHusband

BoaHancocksHusband

‎
#145
#145
Mr.9000 said:
I think kishimoto does a better job overall. each kunoichi has a unique makeup of characteristics that makes them standout in their verse more than the female characters in One piece. Most of the females in one piece are often forgettable or look similar to each other that are only used as filler for an arc or two.
This might be a hot take, but I personally think in general kishi created more memorable characters than Oda.
Click to expand...
KishiGOATo for a reason
 
BoaHancocksHusband

BoaHancocksHusband

‎
#146
#146
Shanal said:
You don't need to. It's counted by people who have read Manga. And Sakura barely does it.

And you missed the entire point of my post. Nami brutalizing Luffy, the man who saved her life and family and city and dream and existence, hundreds of chapters and in-verse years into story over something miniscule and funny isn't because Oda wants to show she's grew up orphan (and if it is then holy shit that's laughably shit writing) It's because it's a funny Japanese 90s manga trope that almost all shonen leads do.

It's not that deep. And trying to make Nami brutalizing Luffy in chapter 1xxx over a derp thing he said deep actually makes her comically stupid as a character, if anything.

You can like whatever you like, but if you're taking cheap comedy that seriously and cherry picking when to take it seriously amd how on top of that, you're just not honest with yourself on reasons why you dislike or like characters. Maybe you don't even realize that

Or if that really is the case, I can only suggest focusing on actual character and plot and writing the authors want to portray rather than once ever 100 chapters comedic scenes to determine quality of writing. Probably will lead to a more pleasant experience
Click to expand...
These ppl disingenuous asf
 
BoaHancocksHusband

BoaHancocksHusband

‎
#147
#147
Konstantis said:
Yes, this is important. She was working so hard, off-screen to become strong. But she didn't become strong, and the only thing that was useful to her was her healing skills. This is a true loser who spend whole time for nothing
Click to expand...
Sakura also goes on to face Shin Uchiha. Sakura was overpowering him and keeping up speed wise.
 
Shanal

Shanal

‎
#148
#148
BoaHancocksHusband said:
These ppl disingenuous asf
Click to expand...
He's rage-baiting, that's why I didn't address his attempts to go off-topic and call Sakura weak instead of actually responding to the initial arguments first. She's a Kage level combatant by all means and possibly strongest Kunoichi in Naruto history if we assume that she at least equaled Tsunade, which author and showings heavily imply.

And even if she didn't, she'd be second strongest Kunoichi in history of series after Tsunade.

That's hardly a bum or a loser and a huge achievement combat-wise. Top off her medical credentials on top of that.

Sakura is not a well-written character. She has a lot of flaws but most dumbasses have no reading comprehension to understand why her writing is poor, so they just go "MUH USELESS", "HITS NARDO". And most of that hate just stems from childhood self-insertion into MC (90% of Sakura fans are also fans of the Uzumaki) who got rejected for good.
 
Konstantis

Konstantis

‎
#149
#149
Shanal said:
He's rage-baiting, that's why I didn't address his attempts to go off-topic and call Sakura weak instead of actually responding to the initial arguments first. She's a Kage level combatant by all means and possibly strongest Kunoichi in Naruto history if we assume that she at least equaled Tsunade, which author and showings heavily imply.

And even if she didn't, she'd be second strongest Kunoichi in history of series after Tsunade.

That's hardly a bum or a loser and a huge achievement combat-wise. Top off her medical credentials on top of that.

Sakura is not a well-written character. She has a lot of flaws but most dumbasses have no reading comprehension to understand why her writing is poor, so they just go "MUH USELESS", "HITS NARDO". And most of that hate just stems from childhood self-insertion into MC (90% of Sakura fans are also fans of the Uzumaki) who got rejected for good.
Click to expand...
I'm not ragebaiting anyone. That's my honest opinion. And to start with, this whole tread was made for ragebaiting purpose. This is why I'm not even taking seriously all this bullshit that you was talking about LOL
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top